3 ms·
> EVERY single time I told people who "trust the science" and "believe the experts" about these topics, it was before any mainstream government or media sources
by dragontamer 5y ago
> EVERY single time I told people who "trust the science" and "believe the experts" about these topics, it was before any mainstream government or media sources had caught on to these ideas.
Yeah. Except we know why that happened: https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/donald-trump/trump-told-bob-woodward-he-knew-february-covid-19-was-n1239658 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/donald-trump/trump-told-bob...
This is the hydroxychloroquine dude. This is the political group that has gone towards ivermectin. This political group is __STILL__ making false and misleading claims on a mass scale today.
> I care that the scientific and political institutions in control of this country are attention-seeking frauds that never take responsibility for making incorrect predictions.
Why don't you dig a little deeper? Figure out the forces that caused the problem and blame them a little bit more? Playing down the virus was Trumps reelection plan, and provably so. This coincides with all the other misinformation (hydroxychloroquine, ivermectin, and anti-vax attitudes) going on today.
-------
Look, its cute that you're making issues about what people knew or didn't know in January / February 2020. But I have coworkers who refuse to mask up _TODAY_ and I know people who think that there's a "vaccine timebomb" where everyone will get cancer in like 3 or 4 years because they took the vaccine.
I can also point you out to some pretty abhorrent misinformation going on in July 2020, months after your dates: https://twitter.com/BadCOVID19Takes/status/1330666281348030467 https://twitter.com/BadCOVID19Takes/status/13306662813480304...
This misinformation crap is happening right now, today, still going on. And I'm a little bit tired of it.
- quacked 5y agoYou have entirely missed my point. The question you are trying to ask is "why do my coworkers listen to the GOP establishment (who are telling lies), instead of Democratic leadership and the scientific establishment (who are telling the truth)"? I am trying to answer you: "because Democratic leadership and the scientific establishment are dishonest, partisan, and incompetent". Do not accuse me of supporting Trump or the GOP; I believe that anyone who chooses to represent the GOP is a coward and a fool, and that nothing the GOP has done or said in the past three decades has had a positive effect on this country. One would think that I am in the exact correct mindset to believe "the good authorities", the same ones that you believe, and yet I do not. I again point to the line from the original article: > Relentless propaganda against public health measures no doubt contributes to erosion of trust. However, that mistrust may also be fueled by the sorry state of health insurance in this country and the deep inequities in health care — at a minimum, this could make people more vulnerable to misinformation. Whoever authored that line holds a deep faith in the scientific and Democratic establishment. They would never label anything their preferred authorities said as "misinformation", even their authorities spread information that was incorrect and stopped people from making good decisions, which they did. That they would ever question their own faith in those establishments is unthinkable. I would bet $50 that whoever wrote that line believed that the anti-masking protests of 2020 were dangerous COVID-spreading opportunities, but supported the George Floyd protests of 2020 as a matter of social necessity without bringing up COVID spreading once. Supporters of the GOP like your coworkers may be blind to the logical failings and dishonesty of their own preferred authorities, but they are not blind to the logical failings and dishonesty of your preferred authorities. That is why they do not believe your authorities. The propaganda and misinformation spread by the GOP that you linked is an excuse for conservatives to revolt against the scientific establishment, as they already wanted to do, not the cause of their revolt. If GOP leadership fell in line with the scientific establishment and started spreading pro-vaccine, pro-mask, anti-COVID information, their supporters would abandon them. Didn't you hear the protestors on January 6th chanting "Hang Mike Pence"? Are you so blind to the nature of the standard American conservative that you believe that they only take orders from their leaders, and that changing what their leaders are saying would bring them back into heel? As I explained earlier, your preferred authorities are incapable of believing themselves at fault for anything, or admitting that they were wrong. They broke public trust by their incompetence and dishonesty, and they will never regain it. Have you seen the videos of Democratic politicians, who faithfully follow the "COVID guidelines" and spread pro-vaccine and pro-mask information, interacting unmasked off-camera and then putting their masks on when the news broadcast starts rolling? Did you see Nancy Pelosi get her hair cut and hold dinner parties while at the same time advocating for stricter anti-COVID measures, and make extremely successful stock trades through her husband as the economy began to crash and recover? The "good guys" aren't real. That's why I commented.
- dragontamer 5y ago> The question you are trying to ask is "why do my coworkers listen to the GOP establishment (who are telling lies), instead of Democratic leadership and the scientific establishment (who are telling the truth)"? And you assume I'm a Democrat, which is not the case. I'm a Republican who has rejected what the party has done over the past year. Rejecting the Republicans doesn't mean accepting the Democrats. It just means rejecting the crap that comes out of our party (at least until the Republicans figure out how to start telling the truth again on simple matters). There are fewer-and-fewer Republicans who are willing to tell the truth on various matters. But they still exist. There's a fundamental issue with our party where telling the "hard truths" gets you run out (see Liz Cheney), and where telling the "easy lies" gets you lots of support (see Ted Cruz's "COVID19 will disappear when Democrats get elected"). I'll support the few Republicans who have managed to stay sane in this difficult juncture of our party. But the number continues to dwindle, and I fear that the party won't have any good leaders left in a few short years. ------- What's your plan, moving forward, to restore the Republican party to sanity? Because frankly, I'm not seeing any. There needs to be someone out there pushing for smaller government and balancing the budget, but if it includes all this anti-mask / anti-vax insanity (which historically was a crappy left-wing thing) I dunno, its not worth it to me. There wasn't any fiscal responsibility in 2016 when tax cuts were announced: there weren't any budget cuts coinciding with those tax cuts. So what am I, the lone Republican who is feeling increasingly isolated from my party, to do? The most straightforward tactic I'm going for is this: point out Republican flaws, and remind people that I am coming in from a conservative, pro-market perspective. That's my political ideology, by and large.
- nradov 5y agoWhy do you expect your coworkers to "mask up" and how long do you expect them to continue? Denmark removed all their mask rules back in August. They're doing fine.
- dragontamer 5y agoRoughly: mask up when numbers increase. Remove masks as numbers decrease. Not really that hard of a concept. USA has several states that ran out of hospital space and entered triage of care. They needed to mask up roughly 3 weeks before that happened, to mitigate the peaks that overwhelm hospitals. If you are in an area where hospitals are reaching critical levels (which is a fair number of states) you need to do everything in your power to save work from the nurses. ------- When elective medical procedures return, masks come off. Sound fair? If people aren't getting their cancer surgeries because there's too many COVID-19 patients filling the place, do something about it.
- nradov 5y agoNo that doesn't sound fair. It sounds like pointless virtue signaling. Numbers increasing are meaningless. Which numbers? We all know that official case counts bear little relation to the true number of infections. Case numbers are trending up in Denmark but they haven't reintroduced any mask mandates.
- dragontamer 5y ago> No that doesn't sound fair. It sounds like pointless virtue signaling. Whether or not hospitals are full is virtue signaling? > Numbers increasing are meaningless. Which numbers? Hospitalization bed numbers. If you run out of beds, life gets really difficult, not only for nurses, but also for people who get into car accidents or otherwise have activities completely unrelated to COVID19. Like that train derailment episode a couple of weeks ago, which caused a lot of undue stress looking for hospital space around Montana. https://www.ktvq.com/news/local-news/colstrip-man-taken-to-wyoming-hospital-for-emergency-surgery-after-montana-hospitals-were-too-full https://www.ktvq.com/news/local-news/colstrip-man-taken-to-w... When hospital space starts to get scarce, things start to get bad for your local community. ------ Democrats don't have a monopoly on hospital bed statistics ya know. A lot of these statistics are coming in from Republican administrations.