9 ms·
‘I hope you die’: how the Covid pandemic unleashed attacks on scientists
- fithisux 5y agoIf someone insults a scientist these days because of his/her support of unpopular measures, is by definition a terrorist or a criminal. This is the textbook definition of fascism.
- simonh 5y agoThat is not the issue here, a range of different types of hostility were catalogued. Some are I'd say excessively hostile but essentially just dissenting opinion. I don't see anything in the article or opinion here suggesting that sort of speech should be suppressed or interfered with. Do you? Others were explicit death threats or persistent personal harassment. I think we can agree those are a potentially criminal matter, right?
- iammisc 5y agoAs bad as this is, this is not 'the textbook definition of fascism' Can we please use words that mean things instead of just calling all things the same thing
- goto11 5y agoWhat textbook would that be? Fascism is a political ideology, not just another word for being an asshole.
- rscho 5y agoInsulting people publicly for their support of legal rules is socially acceptable only in the Facebook age. In other times, the person on the receiving end would have challenged you to a duel.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- poo-yie 5y agoFor starters, it would be a great first step to see the scientific community come out and denounce any and all gain-of-function research as immoral, unethical, irresponsible, and incredibly dangerous. After stating this publicly and repeatedly, then ADHERE to this position and REFUSE to be part of any efforts to conduct such research.
- rscho 5y agoOh yes, refuse. I'm sure no one will try to force you.
- poo-yie 5y agoI don't disagree that there would be attempts to force them. Hopefully, the individual scientists would be able to maintain their ground and refuse to be part of it. There are many tragic examples in the history books of 'just following orders'.
- rscho 5y ago"Just following orders" is the prototypical judgment of past events through the lens of current culture. Refusing to just follow orders meant torture and death for you and your kin under many regimes and in many historical episodes.
- poo-yie 5y agoOf course you're right. My frame of reference is for a civilized society in current times, where the individual is not subject to torture or death.
- over_the_raibow 5y agoThen don t ask for respect or trust from the average Joe. No "trust the science" for you
- dangerlibrary 5y ago"The police officer who visited Kuppalli after a second death-threat call suggested she should get herself a gun." It is hard to overstate how bad this advice is, and how demonstrative it is of the broken policing system we have in the U.S. Gun owners are substantially more likely to die of gun violence than non-gun owners. Gun owners have a 3x higher risk of suicide. In the event that someone does break in, gun owners are more likely to die than non-gun owners. All of this is publicly available information, and the cop's advice to someone facing substantial psychological stress was to "get a gun." We are so, so far away from a sane, functioning public safety system in this country it can be depressing.
- twofornone 5y ago>Gun owners are substantially more likely to die of gun violence than non-gun owners. Gun owners have a 3x higher risk of suicide. It is disingenuous to conflate "gun violence" with suicide. >In the event that someone does break in, gun owners are more likely to die than non-gun owners. I've never heard of this statistic and I suspect that the relevant literature is an interpretation based on questionable assumptions. Do you have a source? >We are so, so far away from a sane, functioning public safety system in this country it can be depressing. Allowing responsible gun ownership is neither insane nor an indication of dysfunction. In fact if you remove a single demographic from gun violence statistics, the US becomes one of the top 5 or so safest nations, in spite of the highest rate of gun ownership in the world.
- iammisc 5y agoYour downvotes show why this problem will never be solved. Getting rid of guns is not going to solve violent people.
- thomastjeffery 5y agoThat isn't the argument here. The argument is that giving people guns is not going to solve violent people.
- saiya-jin 5y ago
- iammisc 5y ago'scientists' are not a homogeneous group. Some are good, some are bad. The world would be better off with some dead, and better off with others living forever. Few would wince for example, had someone wished an early death to mengele, while many would wish Einstein or Feynman were still around.
- rscho 5y agoSo we could build even bigger bombs?
- waltbosz 5y agoI have found myself increasingly interested in understanding the reasons behind what motivates the people making these threats. My interests aren't really in the threats per se, but rather, the hostility towards science. Do they have poor critical thinking skills? Why are they so angry about the scientists? Do they consider science some sort of a threat ? Maybe there is a mental illness at play? Maybe not in the generally angry people, but at least in the minds of the people who actually make the threats. I suppose one may take anti-social action without being mentally ill, just immature. Fundamentally, I'm curious about how their brains work. By what thought processes do they reach their conclusions?
- Elte 5y agoI don't think it's about reaching conclusions; I think people just don't like hearing bad news, much less bad news about things that they regularly participate in. We say "don't shoot the messenger" for a reason - it's just much simpler to shoot the messenger than to consider the message. What I'm personally always worried about is to what extent I might be doing it myself. It stands to reason that these people themselves don't believe they're engaging in unacceptable behavior, after all.
- simonh 5y agoA lot of these people have become convinced that there is a massive conspiracy of elites to deceive and control them. They're not necessarily anti-science as such, they simply believe anyone telling them things they don't want to hear is an enemy trying to cheat them.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoMultiple studies have shown they tend to narcissism and sociopathy. For example: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8035125/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8035125/ They've also been farmed and radicalised by Q-like coordinated anti-vaxxing campaigns which use emotively loaded disinfo to legitimise violent beliefs. The disinfo includes claims that the vaccine kills children (it doesn't) and causes lasting side effects (it doesn't.) The combination of emotionally disordered people and lurid claims about a vaccine "threat" promotes violent outcomes. News from the UK is that an MP was stabbed in his office today. The anti-vaxxers on Twitter seem delighted about this.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ksec 5y agoOk this is not what I expected. I thought the headline was Scientist sending a message to destroy COVID. And COVID is attacking Scientists on an intellectual level. I didn't expect, quote >Dozens of researchers tell Nature they have received death threats, or threats of physical or sexual violence. This is disturbing. I am wondering if these reaction are more mixed with political reaction rather than the refusal of science. And interestingly, they are mostly twitter and not Facebook. But currently Facebook gets all the blame.
- oceanghost 5y ago“We’re an empire now, and when we act, we create our own reality. And while you’re studying that reality — judiciously, as you will — we’ll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and that’s how things will sort out.” - Karl Rove
- sto_hristo 5y agoPeople think that scientists go out on TV to scare them. They think that if the scientists tell them what they want to hear instead of what the reality of the situation actually is, Reality will bend over and do as people want and expect from it. But Reality doesn't do that and people just can't understand this. It's just common stupidity.
- tonfreed 5y agoPart of the problem is that these people don't like being treated like idiots, and we've now got governments all over the west talking down to them and denying them the right to earn a livelihood, and a bunch of inner city midwits with useless degrees very openly calling for their exclusion from society or even genocide in some corners of Twitter. There is a very loud lack of respect from all sides of the equation.
- sto_hristo 5y agoI don't like to be treated like the next ordinary person. I want to be treated like the royalty i wish i am. So get on with it? Remove the people with the "useless degrees" and you'd be left with shamans, witch doctors and a pathetic existence that can be ended on a whim by any civilization that kept its own people with the "useless degrees." That is what happened to natives in the Americas when the European touched their shores. Their demise was trivial. Not even with modern WMDs can you wipe off whole populations across whole continents that easy. So if these people don't like to be treated idiots, they better stop acting like idiots.
- tonfreed 5y agoThis is exactly the kind of attitude I'm talking about. You're pushing people to the edge of society and calling on the government to take away everything they have and still expecting them to fall into line. There's going to be a VERY angry, VERY desperate underclass that's going to overrun to indolent elite in society if they keep going down this arrogant path.
- rspoerri 5y agoWhy is this downvoted?