5 ms·
That sounds like they are knowingly incompetent? If a utility regulator had no one on staff who knew how utility scale power transmission/generation/whatever wo
by lazide 5y ago
That sounds like they are knowingly incompetent? If a utility regulator had no one on staff who knew how utility scale power transmission/generation/whatever worked, that’s what we’d call it for sure.
And aerospace engineers are dirt cheap. What sort of clown show is the FAA running?
- tw04 5y ago> That sounds like they are knowingly incompetent? That sounds like they are knowingly underfunded, which they are. > And aerospace engineers are dirt cheap. They are? Where are all the airline startups? I assume they measure in the hundreds with all this dirt cheap talent running around.
- tester34 5y agomaybe this industry isn't like software where all equipment you need for almost all jobs is 16gb ram, nvme m2 disk, decent cpu laptop
- lazide 5y agoAerospace engineers have as much to do with airlines as software engineers have to do with data entry companies. Which is to say pretty much nothing. Aerospace requires lots of capital expense and is very ‘large customer’ driven and aerospace engineers play second (or third) fiddle to that, unlike in software.
- Waterluvian 5y agoI think you’re deeply misunderstanding the purpose of the FAA and the magnitude of the problem here. Like almost every other agency (the FDA didn’t do the vaccine trials; are they incompetent too?) they don’t do the tests. They just police the industry. Theoretically if you set laws and regulations and dole out severe punishment for bad behaviour, you don’t need to be the one running the tests. People should want their government to run on trust (if their culture is compatible with trust) because it’s far cheaper and more efficient.
- landemva 5y ago'and dole out severe punishment for bad behaviour' When will Boeing CEO and Board of Directors get locked up as part of the severe punishment?
- KMag 5y agoPresumably when it is shown beyond a reasonable doubt that they conspired or deliberately overlooked the fraud. The prosecutor has every incentive to get participants to roll over and follow the conspiracy as high up the ladder as it goes. Successfully prosecuting such a large profile case, particularly with defendants with very little public sympathy, would make his/her career.
- lazide 5y agoSince you’re not going to find any documentation of that because of CYA, and Boeing is the flagship US aircraft manufacturer with a protected (as in ‘in the interest of national security’ protected) position to offset Airbus - that’s pretty much not going to happen.
- KMag 5y agoI think it would be possible to ring-fence the individuals to be prosecuted, facilitate an orderly handover of power inside Boeing, and then prosecute the individuals without risking mortal damage to the company.
- ethbr0 5y agoThat ring should probably extend around McDonnell Douglas' management from the 90s, which made their ways into the upper echelon of Boeing during the merger.
- Cipater 5y ago>The prosecutor has every incentive to get participants to roll over and follow the conspiracy as high up the ladder as it goes. This is naivette. See this: https://www.corporatecrimereporter.com/news/200/lead-boeing-prosecutor-joins-boeing-corporate-criminal-defense-firm-kirkland-ellis/ https://www.corporatecrimereporter.com/news/200/lead-boeing-... From the article: the case was settled with a deferred prosecution agreement — an agreement that Columbia Law Professor John Coffee at the time called — “one of the worst deferred prosecution agreements I have seen.” Boeing did not have to plead guilty to any of the allegations. No Boeing executive was charged. And the Boeing deferred prosecution agreement included an unusual provision finding that a compliance monitor was not necessary because “the misconduct was neither pervasive across the organization, nor undertaken by a large number of employees, nor facilitated by senior mismanagement.” “That is without precedent,” Coffee told Corporate Crime Reporter earlier this year. “I have not seen that anywhere else and I’ve looked at a number of deferred prosecution agreements. Prosecutors themselves are not conducting the investigation.” Boeing’s lead corporate criminal defense law firm is Kirkland & Ellis. Erin Nealy Cox, the lead prosecutor in the Boeing case, left the Justice Department earlier this year. And last month she joined Kirkland & Ellis as a partner in its Dallas office.
- aerospace_guy 5y ago> And aerospace engineers are dirt cheap Inaccurate, please stop sharing misinformation. Seeing this on HN is unfortunate.
- lazide 5y agoDo you have any data to share? Most of my family has been involved in Aerospace, with my dad working for skunkworks, my brother working for Garmin (and a formal aerospace engineer). Most aerospace engineers are lucky to break 75k/yr to start with little to no equity, and often need to move to the middle of nowhere (compared to say NYC, SF, LA, etc for software), and get hit with periodic catastrophic layoffs with the regular cycles in the industry. It’s pretty common that software folks are paid 2-5x with far less intense or zero credentialing and better work conditions - at the same company.
- ethbr0 5y agohttps://online-engineering.case.edu/blog/highest-paying-engineering-jobs https://online-engineering.case.edu/blog/highest-paying-engi... Median numbers, so masks variability. But it looks like AEs are generally paid decently, relative to other engineers. https://www.bls.gov/ooh/architecture-and-engineering/mobile/aerospace-engineers.htm https://www.bls.gov/ooh/architecture-and-engineering/mobile/...
- lazide 5y agoOof, even worse than I noted. So median (and that includes established mid and late career aerospace engineers too) is $118k all in? That’s roughly half of the initial comp for an entry level software engineer at any of the SV firms, and most folks will be making much more than that at said SV firms within a couple years. Being able to get a team of 4-5 experienced and credentialed aerospace engineers for the comp of a single ‘senior’ (mid-level somewhat competent but not amazing) software engineer sounds dirt cheap to me?
- ethbr0 5y ago
- nuerow 5y ago> And aerospace engineers are dirt cheap. I suspect you're letting your software world experience dictate your expectations of what engineering is all about, and what it takes to actually get work done. Software development is a rare field where the only relevant resource is man hours. In other fields, including aerospace engineering, trained meat bags tend to have a negligible cost to the point where replacing a whole engineering team might be a minor inconvenience. However, crashing a prototype is a project killer due to cost alone.
- lazide 5y agoIt sounds a whole lot like you’re agreeing with me - but seem to think you’re not?
- notahacker 5y agoI believe the OP's point is that if you're not just using engineers to audit the tests Boeing does, then additional engineers are a fraction of the cost of running a full parallel aerospace test programme. The capex to set up the test infrastructure is significant even if Boeing is legally obliged to supply you with prototypes to destroy at no cost (which obviously has an impact on the amount of R&D Boeing is willing to do). Also, you're not hiring from a diversely employed Valley pool: most of the engineers with the requisite level of understanding to test Boeing's hardware work for Boeing (and to an extent its supply chain), which might mean you don't have to offer them much of a pay rise, but it also means [i] you're weakening the engineering capability of the firms actually designing and building the stuff by poaching them and [ii] their views on what's safe and what's an appropriate level of testing aren't fully independent anyway.
- lazide 5y agoEh, that doesn’t sound like it? 1) Boeing lays off thousands of aerospace engineers regularly (they did as part of the max disaster), and doesn’t rehire them all back - the industry is highly cyclical, and Boeing is periodically shifting locations anyway 2) the stated concern was Boeing brass was applying undue influence to engineering correct? If those folks worked for the FAA directly after being laid off , wouldn’t they be more than happy to stick it to Boeing brass if they were telling them to cut corners? 3) we’re talking design overview and identifying where Boeing (or others) may be ‘putting their finger on the scale’ or trying to snow regulators by asserting bogus test results or designing tests that they can pass by not including important test criteria they may not pass right? That is certainly something an engineer who was previously in the industry would be aware of, or even a independent engineer should be capable of spotting from ‘the outside’ - and require they do. 4) at (linked in a parallel thread) a median salary of $118k, which is well within something the feds could cover, the FAA can certainly afford to hire a non-token amount of aerospace engineers onto their staff if they actually wanted too/Congress wasn’t trying to kill them. This isn’t like hiring on a FAANG staff software eng for 700k or whatever which would cause outrage or break the pay scale, and this is for something for which there are clear large body counts that can be pointed at. Now if we want to say Congress has been strangling the FAA for a long time (like the IRS and USPS) and forcing them to outsource to industry or whatever, hey - I could believe it - but that is something that should be yelled from the rooftops because that can be fixed, and that will cost us a lot in blood. I don’t want more Americans dead due to corruption of a regulatory process, especially not my friends or family, and those are the stakes here.