8 ms·
We've spotted a planet surviving its dying star
- yummybear 5y agoIf you write an article with "we spotted", then please provide some image material, even if only a graph.
- zhte415 5y agoWhile I'm no astrophysiyst I don't think it's a matter of 'their sun was there last week, look, this week it's not' and nor do I think an artist's impression of something orbiting nothing adds any more, nay, indeed adds nothing, to the written description.
- wongarsu 5y agoThe paper contains figures like [1] or [2], which I think do add something to the written description (and obviously the paper authors thought so too, otherwise they wouldn't have included it in the paper). These visuals are quite useful when talking about what we mean by "spotted" (though the context is important and the article only spends maybe two paragraphs on the actual observation method, so there's some danger of misinterpretation) 1: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03869-6/figures/10 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03869-6/figures/1... 2: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03869-6/figures/7 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03869-6/figures/7
- simonh 5y agoThose images would be copyrighted, so may not be available to the publisher of the article.
- sigg3 5y agoWhere are all the graphical artists at? We had an Ask HN here, like yesterday.
- wongarsu 5y agoI'm sure the authors and their institutions would be happy to grant the right to use the images in an article about the paper if somebody asked them. Publicity for the finding is in their best interest. Unless their publishing agreement with Nature restricts this, not sure how strict exclusivity is in those cases
- simonh 5y agoIn some cases, for some papers it might be possible to eventually get rights to the charts that would satisfy your own publisher's legal department yes. They'd have to jump through those hoops every time though, and time is money.
- purplecats 5y agoIt seems to be the cool thing to do lately. Especially if you have a visual web app, a tool that has a functional GUI component, or a breaking story about the planet or a new piece of hardware, you must make sure not to include the one thing that would make it most worthwhile -- a picture.
- reedf1 5y agoYou'd probably be disappointed. The best you could hope for is a graph of luminous flux vs time, showing the slightest decrease as the planet transits some emission nebulae.
- nsonha 5y agoAstronomy "images" are computer generated anyway, often with artistic touches.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- eesmith 5y agoPublished at https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03869-6 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03869-6 . "Dying" refers to "survive the volatile evolution of their host stars into white dwarfs."
- denton-scratch 5y ago"Dying" is a bit of an under-statement. A white dwarf is to all intents and purposes dead. It has no source of energy, and radiates only because of stored heat. That heat dissipates so slowly that (AIUI) no white dwarf in the universe has yet had time to cool down enough to stop radiating (i.e. the universe does not yet contain any black dwarves). So a star that is in the process of collapsing into a white dwarf could reasonably be said to be "dying". Once it's collapsed, it's dead.
- sailingparrot 5y ago"Dying" is not referring to the state of the star today, but to the process of death: the planet survived while it's star was dying, which is the interesting bit of the story.
- denton-scratch 5y agoAgreed. To survive in orbit around a WD is not a remarkable achievement - you just carry on orbiting forever (roughly). Orbiting a red giant would be pretty interesting, though - the RG has an indistinct surface, its diameter and luminosity varies, and it emits a lot of material as wind. To survive in orbit around a neutron star would be another thing again. Neutron stars have intense magnetic fields, and spin rather quickly, resulting in a rotating field that is wrapped around on itself. That in effect creates a particle accelerator, driving electron flows (the electrons were all expelled when the NS collapsed) with extreme energies. Short of hanging around near an exploding supernova, I can't imagine a more hostile environment.
- hinkley 5y agoWould the magnetic fields of a neutron star create a tidal locking effect through eddy currents in the planet’s core, boosting it into a larger orbit and slowing the spin of the star? Seems like a giant inside out induction motor. I wonder what the band of survival is, where the planet doesn’t get turned to Swiss cheese first.
- 5y ago
- ziddoap 5y agoPerhaps I missed it, but I'm curious to how they know this is a planet which survived the red giant phase vs. a planet which was captured afterwards (or formed from the debris caused from the star -> red giant -> white dwarf transition). Maybe it's covered more in actual paper.
- ceph_ 5y agoThey mention in the article that a handful of previously discovered planets orbiting white dwarfs are believed to have arrived after transition due to their orbits.
- platz 5y agoBut, who wants to live forever?
- t789623239782 5y agoThe first extrasolar planets discovered had survived a supernova explosion: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PSR_B1257%2B12 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PSR_B1257%2B12
- tlholaday 5y agoSol is gas, right? Gasses cool when they expand, right? What’s the expected surface temperature of Sol after it has expanded past Earth’s orbit?
- gs17 5y agoLooks like it will drop to about half the current surface temperature as it expands (although this seems to be talking about it at around 0.5 AU) http://www.astronomy.ohio-state.edu/~ryden/ast162_4/notes15.html http://www.astronomy.ohio-state.edu/~ryden/ast162_4/notes15....
- tlholaday 5y agoThanks for the link. I wonder what temperature prevails at 1.0 AU. On the one hand, artists’ conceptions of boiled oceans and cities in cinders that saddened and discouraged me in my childhood. On the other hand, the heat energy density of Sol today is comparable to a compost heap. When the radius of a sphere doubles, it’s volume increase eight times. If Sol is too itsy to start helium fusion, maybe orbiting within the post-expansion photosphere - the hydrogen envelope - is chill, damp, and sparky?
- rootusrootus 5y agoThe sun won't (potentially) swallow up the Earth for about 8 billion more years. The carbon cycle on this planet will have ended about 7 billion years before then; the increased output of the sun will have boiled away the oceans; plate tectonics will stop, etc. There won't be anything alive on this planet left to see the sun burn out.
- tlholaday 5y agoSounds bad for surface life. Morlocks live underground.
- edge17 5y agoOut of curiosity, the video part way down ("White Drwarf System Animation Text") showing the dying star... how are these videos created? Is it done in something like Blender? The video credits Keck Observatory, do they have 3d artists on staff for this kind of thing? Do Astronomy grad students just learn how to create visualizations? What's the turnaround for getting something like this made because I'm assuming it was made for the press release.
- Gauntleteer 5y agoI work for the Keck Observatory (engineer). Far as I know we do not have any 3D animators on staff. We produce images from our science instruments for the astronomers to download and they all eventually end up here: https://www2.keck.hawaii.edu/koa/public/koa.php https://www2.keck.hawaii.edu/koa/public/koa.php
- shadykiller 5y agoWhy would the planet be destroyed or have it's course altered ? The Star's mass remains the same and so does the gravity. Wouldn't the planet's own gravity hold it up when it's engulfed, and retrain shape when the star becomes a white dwarf ?
- joe-collins 5y agoWell, there would be some extra drag, for one.
- FredPret 5y agoNot an astrophysicist, but it might get torched, blown away by the initial shockwave, or maybe drag between the planet and the solar atmosphere will slow its orbit into a collision course.
- MauranKilom 5y ago> The Star's mass remains the same What makes you think so? I'm no expert, but matter is definitely expelled in the process of forming a white dwarf. The stuff scouring the inner planets doesn't appear out of thin air... This random paper also appears to say that the mass lost is on the order of half the initial mass: https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/1538-4357/aadfd6/pdf https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/1538-4357/aadfd6/... > total stellar mass loss ranges from 33% of M_initial at 0.83 M_sun to 83% of M_initial at 7.5 M_sun.
- tamaharbor 5y agoI assume this would accelerate global warming.
- TMWNN 5y agoThe classic short story "A Pail of Air" (1951; <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Pail_of_Air https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Pail_of_Air>) depicts human survivors of a frozen Earth without the Sun.
- justshowpost 5y agoIsn't that just a simple formula? I even seen planet destroyed/remains on some of stellar evolution simulators. It all depends on orbit radius and star mass at the end of Asymptotic Red Giant Branch. Note that white dwarves aren't stars but rather stellar remnants without energy source.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y ago> How will the Solar System die? It’s a hugely important question Why?
- anonporridge 5y agoBecause it's where we live?
- subroutine 5y agoIt's not. At least not right now. But probably something we should revisit in around 2 billion years. (using we loosely to mean whatever entities humans have become by then). Although it might be cool to get a shout-out from the apex species of 2,000,002,021... we'd like to thank Homo Sapien sapien for first bringing this to the attention of sentient life in this solar system
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]