21 ms·
Random thought: before the Internet were reviews any better? I know there were/are quality reviews like Consumer Reports and such. But were there any crowdsour
by Waterluvian 5y ago
Random thought: before the Internet were reviews any better? I know there were/are quality reviews like Consumer Reports and such. But were there any crowdsourced reviews?
Are we worse off or are we just needing to protect people from their inability to scrutinize a new source of bad data?
- irrational 5y agoBefore the Internet? Other than advertisements, any information about a product came from word of mouth (family and friends) or from magazines like Consumer Reports. How would crowdsourced reviews even be generated or disseminated? The only way for large groups of people to talk to each other was in person.
- Moru 5y agoBuying reviews has long been a thing. Snake oil sales persons were standing on markets selling their bottles of oil, they paid people to come up and "buy" a bottle and do a review in front of the crowd.
- irrational 5y agoYes, but a crowd isn't anywhere within orders of magnitude to what we see on the Internet.
- cortesoft 5y agoPeople either got their reviews from quality, trusted third parties like Consumer Reports, or they got reviews from friends. It would be pretty expensive to bribe consumer reports, and it isn't as cost effective to pay someone to give fake recommendations to their friends as it is to pay for fake recommendations on a website. Although some companies do that; it is called multi level marketing.
- Notanothertoo 5y agoConsumer reports kind of went down hill too. It was the solution though, I remember people paid good money for sun service.
- silisili 5y agoYeah...they were good even after the internet became big...for a while, but the last few years have been so far downhill I don't even look to them anymore.
- cortesoft 5y agoIt was hard to compete with free online reviews.
- willis936 5y agoReplace "free" with "valueless" and the prospect of competition looks brighter.
- cortesoft 5y agoDoes it? It doesn't matter if we know the reviews aren't as good, people still don't seem willing to pay for good reviews. Many companies have tried, but I haven't heard of any success stories yet.
- willis936 5y agoPlenty of people are. CR is still in business. However, there is an issue with the quality of CR dropping in recent years. Why pay for a service that is getting worse?
- jdeibele 5y agoI think a big part of the problem is that manufacturers and big stores do a thing where Best Buy gets model XAB234b, Costco gets model XAB234c, and Home Depot gets model XAB234h. They're almost identical in specs and features. This mattress has 2" of foam while one has 1.5" and another 2.5". Or one dishwasher has the controls on the top while the others have it on the front but one has a latch with a bar handle and one has a latch without a bar handle. They're all "different" so they can't be price-compared and the models don't match exactly the model that Consumer Reports reviews.
- xxs 5y agoAside word from mouth, certain magazines that you'd trust (or unsubscribe otherwise), the most prominent part was: the brand name. Before moving to Taiwan (and then China) a lot of the goods were produced quite locally and not outsourced, so it was even possible to have a most so remote relationship to the factory/engineers responsible for a product. The brand is still a thing, yet a lot of brands are owned by the same mega corporation and effectively produced/assembled in the same outsourced factory with unknown amount of suppliers.
- CivBase 5y agoI imagine large-scale slander campaigns in the form of fake reviews was probably much more difficult, costly, and risky prior to the internet.
- mymythisisthis 5y agoOr easier.
- CivBase 5y agoHow so? The internet makes it easier to hide your identity, automate attacks, and reach a large audience at practically no cost. For example, if I want to influence Skippy peanut butter's review score online I can just leave fake reviews on a few dozen products on a few dozen websites with a few dozen (maybe hundred) fake accounts. Alternatively, I could make up something on social media and hope it goes viral. If I wanted to do the same in the physical world I'd have to pay for some massive marketing campaign which would trace right back to me.
- ekianjo 5y agoReviews were probably even worse before because so much fewer in number and easily corrupted by financial interests.
- tyingq 5y agoThere were a fair amount of bullshit fake testimonials on TV. Informercials being particularly brazen.
- DaveExeter 5y ago>Random thought: before the Internet were reviews any better? Before the internet, there were these things called "magazines". These magazines earned money by selling ads. Advertisers sold products that were reviewed in the magazines they advertised in. And if a magazine's review was unfavorable to an advertisers product, that advertiser could reduce their ad spending. Also, advertisers could "bribe" reviewers. Probably not with direct cash payments, but it was generally expected that a reviewer would be "gifted" the product reviewed. So, this has always be a problem.
- topkai22 5y agoYeah, but there was/is more balance when the magazine had to keep its overall readership up and quite possibly had a manufacturer’s competitive advertising as well. Advertisers could influence reviews, especially to keep from getting a super low review, but I don’t recall stupendous reviews for absolute rubbish.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoIn many fields, though, there were the magazines that everbody knew were bought and sold by advertisers, and those that weren't. In my domain, Sound on Sound (about pro-audio and music creation tech) is in the latter category, and has been for decades. Even the advertisers know it, and seem willing to deal with the periodic "actually, the new Foo from Bar is mostly a piece of junk that you will not want to buy" because it makes the "wow, the new Baz from Bomb is totally awesome and you will use it everyday".
- ghaff 5y agoSome but very limited. Zagat was one for restaurants but they sold out to Google. I used to buy their books/do reviews in exchange for free books. Certainly imperfect but I liked their results pretty well probably because their reviewers lined up pretty well with my preferences--i.e. semi-serious survey. And many quantitative things including TV ratings involved consumer surveys/polling.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoThe red Zagat books were gems.
- zz865 5y agoI think the point is you didn't rely on reviews. Before the internet you went to the shop and you could actually touch the product, try on clothes, use sporting goods, see how this laptop feels and how fast it works. Now buying online you have to trust reviews to choose what to buy.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI think this is bit simplistic. Before the internet, if you were going to buy something that was supposed to have objectively measurable properties, there would likely be a magazine/zine/journal that would include reviews by domain experts. Shovel? Laptop? Scalpel? Engine oil? Covered, you just bought the magazine. The problem now is that the magazines are generally not as good at covering all the options, many of them have vanished, or have become online only equivalents. Also, this is in part what the Whole Earth Catalog (later CoEvolution Quarterly and even later Whole Earth Review) was all about, and that's why more than a few people see it as a precursor to the web.
- Gibbon1 5y agoBefore the internet, brick and mortar stores and distributors had 'buyers' who were intimately familiar with products in their particular sector. They would review products and decide how many to order if any. If you wanted to sell some consumer product you'd have to ship pre-production models to the buyers. They would test them and tear them down to see how well they were built. That imposed reasonable quality standards on manufacturers. With the rise of Amazon that's all gone.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoIt is not solely Amazon. It mirrors the widening gap in income/wealth in society. Walmart and BestBuy were already selling models of appliances slightly tweaked to have inferior components at cheaper prices, imperceptible to people who were not doing deep research online. Although the veneer of quality Amazon have to third party sellers certainly exacerbated the issue, but I think that is close to exhaustion.
- vineyardmike 5y ago> we just needing to protect people from their inability to scrutinize a new source of bad data? I think this places more blame on the consumer than is due. Sure people need to understand how to interpret data, but a lot of this is plain fraud. Fake reviews are fraud. They make a product seem better than it is. Its sorta like false advertising, in a way. A lot of modern times uses automated systems, eg. maybe amazon top page might require 4+ stars, etc. This would normally be a positive feedback loop (good products get in front of more people, more reviews if good means stronger basis for being in front). With fake reviews, you're disrupting the systems we have for everyone, hurting other brands (if not directly through slander campaigns) and also acting fraudulently.