8 ms·
Strike Date Set for 60k Film and Television Workers
- calcifer 5y agoThis is set to be even bigger than the 2007 WGA strike, which was ~12k people for 100 days. WGA had some precedent-setting wins with that, hopefully the same will happen with IATSE.
- Waterluvian 5y agoThat strike produced some of my favourite TV ever. Conan was a riot.
- thrill 5y agoYeah, a lot of television shows really suffered due to it.
- tonyarkles 5y agoAlthough, if legend serves correctly, the entire last half-season of Battlestar Galactica was rewritten during the strike and the writers were much happier with the second version.
- scrumbledober 5y agoand we got dr. horrible
- tehjoker 5y agoThe WGA strike was really significant world historically. My recollection is that that strike created the impetus to do more reality television, which in turn created The Apprentice, which in turn gave us the 2016 election. America is a completely TV addled nation lmao At the time, the only thing I noticed was one of my favorite actresses from House MD participated in the strike and that the quality of the writing declined shortly after it started. That said, I completely support the strike! The workers need it badly and the stronger the strikes, the more control the workers will have. The more control they have, the less of a disaster America will be and leave less room for those kinds of consequences! My only criticism of the earlier strike is that it wasn't strong enough to include Reality TV in its coalition. EDIT: Welp, I was wrong! Sorry about that. EDIT2: Some people seem to think the show took off after the strike even though it started before: https://www.buzzfeed.com/arianelange/writers-strike https://www.buzzfeed.com/arianelange/writers-strike http://revolutionaryoldidea.squarespace.com/roi-blogi/2020/10/10/trumpism-is-reality-tvs-fault-but-not-for-the-reasons-you-think http://revolutionaryoldidea.squarespace.com/roi-blogi/2020/1...
- CrazedGeek 5y agoThe Apprentice actually started in 2004: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Apprentice_(American_TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Apprentice_(American_TV_se...
- itsdrewmiller 5y agoThe Apprentice started in 2004, 3 years before the WGA strike.
- tehjoker 5y agoI never watched it, sorry I got the timeline wrong. I thought it was popular after the strike. (EDIT: Looks like it ran 2004-2017) That was one of my favorite alt-history theories. Sad.
- cush 5y agoThis is why we have reality TV
- cush 5y agoWhen the writers guild went on strike in 2007, reality TV was born. I wonder what will happen this time!
- djbusby 5y agoWow, 90% voted, 98% in favor of strike. Solidarity!
- petee 5y agoAnd nearly 53,000 votes too! There isnt a member that hasnt suffered on a production, so we all really are amped up to call shenanigans
- vncecartersknee 5y agoAmazing! great to see worker solidarity on HN
- wildrhythms 5y agoMeanwhile the top comment here is prefaced with "I'm not super pro-union (plenty of mess there)". I genuinely believe Americans- especially upper-middle class workers like HN visitors- are the subject of a mass disinformation campaign against organized labor.
- reducesuffering 5y agoMost of the stronger conviction anti-union comments I’ve seen on HN are about personal experience. “Mass disinformation campaign” seems like an easy handwave where you don’t acknowledge that unions could have any downsides.
- djbusby 5y ago> upper-middle class workers like HN visitors. Not all of us. And I know for sure there is at least one trucker on here, I seent it, not sure where that is on the income spectrum, dang-sure not SV money though (is it?).
- mig39 5y agoThe best way to avoid a strike is to have a strong strike mandate. It's easier to bargain, to play "chicken" when you know you have your membership behind you. It's not easy to threaten a strike when you have a 60% vote, for example. A union's power is in solidarity.
- m0zg 5y agoProbably worst time in recent history to stage such a strike. I can't even _see_ the "stage workers" except through fogged up glasses while wearing a face diaper. This would be a lot more effective if their corporate overlords were making a ton of money like before.
- nafix 5y agoSeems like a great time to stage a strike if the corporate overlords are already under some level of duress. Also, what does being able to see the stage workers have anything to do with it?
- m0zg 5y agoThey could just be laid off under the present circumstances. If a tree falls in a forest and there's no one there to hear it, does it make a sound? Edit, since HN is throttling my response to the bigman433 below: I absolutely agree with you. Much like music industry, to paraphrase Hunter S Thompson, movie industry is "a cruel and shallow money trench, a long plastic hallway where thieves and pimps run free, and good men die like dogs." It's just that now is not the best time to effect change there. Think of it from the standpoint of the owner: you have a venture which is barely making any money at the moment and is not projected to make a lot of it at any point in the next few years. And that venture is starting to cause you legal, PR, and labor problems on top of that. You'd get rid of it at the drop of a hat. Now, if you actually were making money hand over fist, and the flow of money suddenly stopped, that's a MUCH better leverage to make a deal. This presupposes, however, that they'd actually like to solve their problems, rather than just stay angry, which is how it often is. Problem solving is less profitable to the agitators than constant, simmering anger.
- margalabargala 5y agoDoubtful. There's a notorious shortage of workers in every industry right now, the striking workers will be particularly hard to replace due to their timing, and their strike is probably going to be particularly effective because of that.
- peterlk 5y agoI've just spent a bit over a year in the live entertainment industry, and feel like I might be able to provide some insight here. On the one hand, this feels like an own-goal because no one in live entertainment has been paid since the beginning of 2020. Though that started to change a little over this summer. On the other hand, many of the people from the live entertainment industry found refuge in film and television. There has been a hollowing out of the industry where the senior folks have stuck around, but lots and lots of people who were early in their career have left and are not coming back. The senior folks can afford a few more weeks of no pay. However, if they cut off revenue to the film&tv world, they are setting up a 1-2 punch to the entertainment companies (1. COVID, 2. strike), and that puts them in a good negotiating position.
- agperson 5y agoI read the headline as "strike data set" and was really interested to see what industry data IASTE was releasing to help justify the strike to the public and build support. Alas.
- slownews45 5y agoI'm not super pro-union (plenty of mess there) but there really are some reasonable asks union side. My guess, folks have been NOT working the 12+ hour days, have NOT been doing the "rolling lunches" and other wild hollywood stuff (that a construction worker would think was crazy) during COVID. Might have opened their eyes to life outside of the hollywood dream machine. Maybe look for things as basic as: Mandated stop production 30 minute lunches. Mandated 10 hour turnarounds seem totally reasonable And bottom line, new media isn't new media anymore, it's big business so sorting that out also makes sense I've never fully understood why hollywood can't always take a standard 30 minute lunch break. The job site across the street, lunch time, everyone puts down their stuff and eats and relaxes. And end of day, they are gone (unless it's a rush and paying overtime). (note this is my list - union's position may be different etc).
- TheDudeMan 5y agoAren't there already laws that grant breaks during work? Does Hollywood not abide by those? Who polices that sort of thing? (Also not very pro-union.)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- breadzeppelin__ 5y agoNot related to hollywood but I worked wildland fire for the local sheriff for a couple years and the 'mandated lunch breaks' were pretty much bullshit. MAYBE 15 minutes to stop and eat (often not even sitting down), then get back to work but had to report at least a half hour of unpaid downtime on the shift report at the end of the day. No wonder that area expertise is also hemorrhaging skilled workers. Luckily it was only part time for me but those guys are really getting fucked over between low pay and the ridiculous breaks
- mchusma 5y agoThey have to abide by them, which is what I can't understand here. I'm in California and the laws are strict, it's easy to sue, and the companies involved (e.g. Disney) are giant. So I just can't see them getting away with violating labor laws. I assume they are looking for protection above and beyond what the law requires? I can't find the actual demands anywhere. The website and links are all basically propaganda links (no section that says "this is what we are asking for").
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoIs there a list of demands compared to the current agreement? I can't find the specifics anywhere.
- petee 5y agoThere is some information on IATSE's site, I'll link below. Most specifics are confidential even once the contracts are ratified; there are also two separate contracts in question. I can say, the core of it is demanding safe work hours, the rest is important but workable. The producers are trying to reduce pay, increase health care costs, skip lunch, and while asking us to work harder, and still pretending streaming media isn't viable. IATSE has been good over the years making okay, but arguably fair contracts, but producers consistently take advantage of the situation and contract language https://www.asa.iatse.net/ https://www.asa.iatse.net/ https://www.basicagreement.iatse.net/ https://www.basicagreement.iatse.net/
- cwkoss 5y agoIs there a page on their website that has a good list of: - What the workers' demands are? - What they want consumers to do to support the strike? Finding it hard to navigate their website, and hearing people on social media say conflicting things, hard to get a read on what the official position of the union is.
- wildrhythms 5y agohttps://www.basicagreement.iatse.net/ https://www.basicagreement.iatse.net/ 1) Reasonable rest periods 2) Meal breaks 3) Living wages for workers at the bottom of the wage scale 4) Some other issues that are not publicized during the negotiation process
- cwkoss 5y agoThanks! I find the confidentiality around these negotiations interesting. Does anyone have insight into what issues are not being publicized (and why)?
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoIt would be very interesting to know what the current rest period and other issue status quo is and what the union wants it changed to.
- mikewarot 5y agoIt looks like I'm going to have a lot more free time, without Netflix and Amazon Prime to keep my mind busy. This is gonna be rough.
- npteljes 5y agoThe thing to realize is that abuse works well. You can, from the same workforce, extract more value, or the same value faster, with more abuse. So when it's not regulated, the way to get ahead, or even stay in business, is via abusive practices. So the only way toward a sustainable future is regulation. That way the playing field is level and so there's less incentive to abuse.