5 ms·
> very outdated information no rush on that -- we have another 21,000 years of half-life to talk about it, right?
by mistrial9 5y ago
> very outdated information
no rush on that -- we have another 21,000 years of half-life to talk about it, right?
- Turing_Machine 5y agoLonger half-life = less radioactive. By definition. A half-life of infinity would mean that the isotope is not radioactive at all.
- mistrial9 5y agoa pinhead emits less light than the sun, too
- Turing_Machine 5y agoI'm not really sure what you're driving at here. While there are certainly other nuances involved such as what kind of radiation is emitted (alpha, beta, gamma, neutron), and what the immediate fission products are, if all other factors are equal, the longer the half life, the less radioactive the material is. That's literally the definition. The really nasty isotopes are ones like Iodine-131 (half-life 8 days, has an affinity for the human thyroid gland) and Strontium-90 (half-life 28.79 years, has an affinity for human bones). While saying that something has a "half-life of forty million billion trillion years" may sound scary-impressive, what it actually means is "this stuff is only very mildly radioactive).
- mistrial9 5y agoyour half-life example is technically correct, yet by making a fanciful example of "forty million billion trillion" rhetorically, it makes the statement of harm sound like "oh, 21,000 years of half-life is not at all harmful" .. I think you are aware that spent nuclear fuel is poisonous by any definition. Second, the amount of material is not at all mentioned in your definition. One half of one gram of material, is not the same as the many kilograms of spent fuels from a working reactor, or the 2000 metric tons of spent fuel generated now in the USA each year. So I ridicule that in an unexpected way, with another extreme example, comparing something tiny, to something massively large that everyone knows. There is some false confidence in my opinion, about "know the facts" of radiactive materials.. when bio-accumulation in the food chain, uncontained dispersion, poisoning fresh or salt waters where life exists, and human exposure over time, and repeated exposure, are serious things.
- Turing_Machine 5y agoNo. When someone says "(a substance) has a (very large) half-life" it is typically an attempt to make the substance sound more dangerous, when in general a longer half-life makes the material less dangerous, not more.
- freemint 5y agoOnly if dosage is not infinite either.
- imtringued 5y agoOutdated information is quite relevant for nuclear power plants. Fukushima was older than Chernobyl. Every time someone tells me how safe modern power plants are I think "great, now get rid of all the old ones".
- petre 5y ago> great, now get rid of all the old ones And burn some more coal in the meantime.
- anshumankmr 5y agoWouldn't that be better than the gigatonnes of CO2 we keep emitting into the atmosphere?
- outworlder 5y agoPlus radiation. People seem to forget that coal plants actually spew radioactive material in the atmosphere.
- mistrial9 5y agothere are lots of ways to emit less CO2 right now without any nukes pro or con.. yet, stall...
- outworlder 5y agoGetting rid of the old ones is quite difficult to do due to all the misinformation and public perception. A lot of that shaped by outdated information. So instead of building new, safer power plants that will actually help us fight climate change, many places are still running old power plants as they can't afford to shut them down. There are still RMBK (Chernobyl-like) plants running today! Mind you, Fukushima was not the only power plant that was subject to an earthquake and a tsunami. All others safely shutdown. Actually Fukushima shutdown too - and would have survived if not by the tsunami and some braindead decisions. Fukushima is like a Ford Model T that's thrown into a highway accident. It should have been replaced way before the accident. Germany should be leading the effort here. Maybe they could take a page from France.