5 ms·
US attorney details illegal acts, sealing the fate of the “nuclear Renaissance”
- option 5y agoour current “climate tzar”, John Kerry, made a career killing safe and promisingly nuclear designs.
- redis_mlc 5y agoI'd encourage the legions of nuclear apologist fanbois on HN to read the article. Reactors can't be built if nobody can be trusted with safety oversight.
- bpodgursky 5y agoResponding to the other comment in the thread here, I see nothing about safety concerns, only about lying about the operational status of the reactor for tax credits, in the face of mounting delays. Which doesn't excuse fraud but... cost bloat and regulatory delays are exactly what the nuclear fanboys are frustrated by. This doesn't really speak to the technology at all, just an incentive structure that motivated fraud.
- natch 5y agoIt does in fact speak to the technology, because this particular technology is extraordinarily undecentralizable and thus lends itself to corruption and boondoggles.
- mjevans 5y agoTL;DR This Westinghouse Project is to what we need, as Boeing's Starliner is to SpaceX's solution. To reduce carbon emissions and bridges us until fusion (or some other tech) is more viable, nuclear still seems to make sense; ignoring the political and scaremongering issues. This project suffered from corruption, mismanagement, and contractors who've gotten too good at "business" rather than engineering.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- yodelshady 5y agoThat's an excellent analogy. There is a scattering of fission-based startups (I'll plug UBattery, FliBe energy also looks smart). Just like SpaceX, like it or not you're not going to avoid some government involvement. (You know what, I wouldn't call the unashamedly public-sector development in the '60s sluggish either.)
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoSome other tech like solar, wind, batteries etc. perhaps? I've noticed a weird trend recently where the people still keen on nuclear power don't even mention the elephant in the room that is renewables. They used to love talking about how expensive and unreliable and unsafe it is. Gives me some small hope that a consensus is slowly being reached.
- pjc50 5y agoIt's very noticeable that all of those have an actual market, whereas if you want a reactor you have very limited choices. Nuclear power is more like the F-35, where the job of the contractor is to establish it as a "national necessity" and then bill as much as they can get away with while prolonging the programme, because there's no realistic competitors. SpaceX made the product on private money and then sold it to the government once it could be seen to work.
- onedognight 5y ago> SpaceX made the product on private money And public loans. This doesn’t fully detract from your point that SpaceX is different from traditional government space contractors, but it should be noted.
- KptMarchewa 5y ago>They used to love talking about how expensive and unreliable and unsafe it is. Because now you can just look outside. https://www.wsj.com/articles/energy-prices-in-europe-hit-records-after-wind-stops-blowing-11631528258 https://www.wsj.com/articles/energy-prices-in-europe-hit-rec... Renewables are great, but you can't 100% rely on them. Batteries are too expensive to do more than short-term load balancing. Either you massively overprovision everything - and MW for MW cost comparisons stop making sense - or you have brownouts.
- perl4ever 5y agoHow do the French do it?
- jabl 5y agoThe French have 100 varieties of cheese, and 3 varieties of nuclear power plants. In the USA it's the opposite. More seriously, the French nuclear buildout (the Messmer plan), was a state driven program doing series building of large nuclear power plants. That is the recipe for quickly building out capacity on time and on budget. (The delays and cost overruns seen today with the EPR's are largely due to there being such a long pause in building these that much of the knowhow was lost.)
- dredmorbius 5y agoSo ... the free market approach doesn't work, government intervention, leadership, and subsidy is necessary?
- AniseAbyss 5y agoWell contrary to what Republicans believe all the great things America has done have been funded by the Federal government.
- dredmorbius 5y agoNot all. But many, yes. (A few of the not-so-great things as well.)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bell-cot 5y agoWell, if the "free market" wants to create unique, hand-crafted nuclear power plants, with generally inexperienced workers... While the government's alternative is something between a production line and cookie-cutter tract houses, with experienced workers... Then duh. Not hard to figure out which one has an overwhelming advantage.
- jeffbee 5y agoWith the current cost of large-scale renewables, instead of spending 9 billion dollars to not get 2200MW of fission power they could have built 9000MW of solar power with zero risk, or more usefully half that peak capacity of combined wind and solar and the grid-scale batteries to paper over the variance in output.
- fsckboy 5y ago> With the current cost of large-scale renewables "The project was initiated in May 2008 and gained final approval in February 2009."
- CptMauli 5y agoEven then the cost of utility scale solar and wind was not that much higher than it is now.
- dredmorbius 5y agoWhich only raises furher points: - Nuclear projects have decades-plus lead times. VC Summer units 2 & 3 have been in-process for 23 years, to be abandoned due to both costs and mismanagement. Construction and commissioning remain only a part of the entire nuclear life-cycle. - Solar and wind power have seen a long-term cost declines since the 1950s. Doubling installations reduces costs by 20% through learning-curve effects. At the same time, nuclear's costs have been increasing. These trends are well-established and must be factored into future projections of presently-planned energy projects. https://ourworldindata.org/cheap-renewables-growth https://ourworldindata.org/cheap-renewables-growth - Nuclear power, along with most complex and large-scale capabilities and institutions tends to promote corruption and mismanagement, along with tremendous consequences for mishaps resulting from these. Corruption is not a technical problem with a technical solution, it cannot be engineered against. Yes, other energy modalities have seen enormous failures, but, 1) those also arose from mismanagement and corruption and 2) because they were not based on nuclear power the affected regions rapidly recovered, are once again inhabited, and no latent risks remain a statement which cannot be made of the major nuclear incidents expereinced to date.
- throwaway81523 5y agoSCANA CEO got 2 year sentence a couple days ago: https://www.courthousenews.com/judge-signs-off-on-2-year-sentence-for-ex-ceo-behind-failed-nuclear-facility/ https://www.courthousenews.com/judge-signs-off-on-2-year-sen...