7 ms·
I think the most intriguing aspect of this report is the dog somehow sensed this meteorite was on its way. "she awoke to the sound of her dog barking, giving h
by asdff 5y ago
I think the most intriguing aspect of this report is the dog somehow sensed this meteorite was on its way.
"she awoke to the sound of her dog barking, giving her a moment's notice before a rock from outer space hurtled into her bedroom."
- jonny_eh 5y agoPerhaps another piece fell nearby just before this one.
- skulk 5y agoMaybe a rock hurtling at terminal velocity straight towards your head (approximately) makes some interesting high frequency sound waves that only dogs can hear?
- CobrastanJorji 5y agoNo, they wouldn't. Sound travels at the speed of sound. That speed is the same regardless of the frequency (although it varies by temperature and air pressure). Supersonic things travel faster than sounds. You could get around this by, say, making the air itself move directly towards the person nearly as quickly as the meteor, but that is probably safe to exclude as a possibility.
- Koshkin 5y agoThere is also Doppler effect, and dogs are known to be able to hear ultrasound.
- mwint 5y agoDoppler effect doesn't allow sound go to faster than the speed of sound.
- CobrastanJorji 5y agoDogs can indeed hear ultrasonic frequencies, but ultrasonic frequencies of sound, being sounds, travel at the speed of sound. Things that travel faster than the speed of sound go faster than sounds.
- russdill 5y agoDid you see the picture and get the impression that the rock was traveling at supersonic velocities? Really?
- sysstemlord 5y agoAre you being serious? It's a known fact that meteorites travel many many times faster than sound!
- MauranKilom 5y agoWhen they enter the atmosphere, yes, but not when they reach the surface of the earth. Any rock-like object below ~15 m in size will reach terminal velocity before hitting the ground.
- MauranKilom 5y agoBut this object was not traveling at supersonic speeds when it hit the house. Meteorites below a certain size slow down to terminal velocity long before they reach the surface.
- radicaldreamer 5y agoDogs definitely have some sort of “sixth sense” or are very attuned to the environment. Tons of reports of dogs waking their humans prior to impending but hard to detect dangers such as earthquakes…
- dekhn 5y agoThe one time I was in a noticeable earthquake in California, this is what happened: all the dogs in the neighborhood started barking at the same time. a couple seconds later, all the car alarms went off. a couple seconds after that, there was a huge JOLT and then gentle decaying shaking.
- lisper 5y agoIn the case of earthquakes, dogs can detect compression waves which travel faster than the stronger and more destructive transverse waves. In the case of a meteorite it is harder to imagine a plausible mechanism. As most meteorites are supersonic, it's not possible for any waves to arrive at their destination before they do. [UPDATE] Reading some of the other comments it occurred to me that this particular meteorite was probably traveling at terminal velocity, and was thus sub-sonic. So it's possible a dog could hear its approach.
- asdff 5y agoi wonder if the rock was magnetic
- outworlder 5y ago> "But the workers had seen a meteorite, or a falling star, explode and there was a couple of booms" Dogs don't really like 'booms'.
- Avalaxy 5y agoThe rock would have been there before the dog would be able to hear the boom. More likely explanation: there was a bright flash in the sky, and the dog saw this.
- jcims 5y agoIt would have been falling at terminal velocity at that point, which would have been subsonic (200 to 400 mph) https://www.amsmeteors.org/fireballs/faqf/#12 https://www.amsmeteors.org/fireballs/faqf/#12
- haimez 5y agoPossibly, but the rock also came to rest on the mattress and not underneath her basement so there’s a possibility that it was already sub-sonic and that the dog had a chance to hear it before it arrived.
- eevilspock 5y ago@jcims terminal velocity only applies to something in free fall, not to something with a high magnitude inertial vector relative to the Earth (like a meteorite), or anything with thrust (like a supersonic plane or a bullet). I think @krona's got the right answer.
- sjburt 5y agoIt will slow and eventually reach terminal velocity. I don't know if it has enough time/distance to do that before hitting the earth but given the small size I wouldn't be surprised.
- outworlder 5y ago> velocity only applies to something in free fall, not to something with a high magnitude inertial vector relative to the Earth (like a meteorite) It could be conceivably coming at a speed high enough to still be supersonic when it hit the ground. However, were that the case, I doubt there would be still much of a house remaining. Or maybe a block for that matter, depending on how fast it was going. More likely, it just slowed down due to friction. This is even more likely for a small rock. > anything with thrust (like a supersonic plane or a bullet). Plane has thrust, but a bullet doesn't ;)
- sjg007 5y agoDogs are really amazing animals and we are super lucky that they love us. They will clean up any food you spill, the alert you to danger, they will fight off bears or other attackers. They can smell cancer, covid19 and contraband. Just simply amazing animals.
- csomar 5y ago> They will clean up any food you spill I don't think they are cleaning, but eating that food. > the alert you to danger They alert when they are scared and looking for your help. > they will fight off bears or other attackers Not really. Some trained breeds are powerful enough. But smaller and non-trained dogs will run for their lives. > They can smell cancer, covid19 and contraband. No. They can be trained to smell them, though. They just happen to have a strong sense of smell like many other animals.
- rpmisms 5y ago> I don't think they are cleaning, but eating that food. Still helpful > They alert when they are scared and looking for your help. Never owned a guard dog, I see. My dog has almost zero reason to be scared of anything, she's massive and strong. She lets me know when anything suspicious happens nearby > Not really. Some trained breeds are powerful enough. But smaller and non-trained dogs will run for their lives. Well, obviously. My Pyr can take a small bear, or at least her dad did with no problem. > No. They can be trained to smell them, though. They can already smell them, they can be trained to alert us to those smells. Do you just not like dogs?
- csomar 5y ago> Do you just not like dogs? No, I have a dog and had dogs since ~10. I just don't have that emotional attachment that makes me see them as these amazing fairy-tale creatures. They are just animals with a human bond. Also a huge dog doesn't make me feel any safe. Unless you are living in a jungle or war is breaking out in your neighborhood, you don't need a massive dog that can take a bear. Some dog breads are too powerful and can hurt real humans. These are still animals after all and can be unpredictable and harm others[1]. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fatal_dog_attacks_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fatal_dog_attacks_in_t...
- krona 5y agoThere was an audible explosion and what fell through the roof was likely a fragment that fell far less than the speed of sound (340 m/s vs < 100 m/s)
- MawKKe 5y agoMy hypothesis is that her dog didn't necessarily observe the meteorite, but began to bark as a response to other barking neighborhood dogs who did see the flash.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Strilanc 5y agoI just assumed she was remembering it out of order. A lot happened very fast and she started off asleep.