6 ms·
"The recruiter telling me they only had budget for $30k (no software engineer would have accepted that low of pay in 2006 in Houston), making me team leader to
by giantg2 5y ago
"The recruiter telling me they only had budget for $30k (no software engineer would have accepted that low of pay in 2006 in Houston), making me team leader to get me to do more work, making me lay off around $300k worth of employees and do their work myself without giving me even a dollar of extra pay."
This sounds like basically every job to me. Are there actually places that will give you raises to pay you what you're worth without having to fight or leave?
- jermaustin1 5y agoI'm the author of this piece - I've had multiple jobs since then (obviously), and I've always been given pretty substantial raises and bonuses throughout my career enough to nearly 10x my first jobs salary in only 15 years. Now all that isn't from one job, but because I'm a contractor and basically set my rate with each new company, I invest as much as I can either in the stock market, or more recently into side projects and my family run businesses, etc.
- giantg2 5y agoIt seems like nowhere will just give you a raise because it's the right thing, valuation-wise. You basically have to threaten to leave or something. My inflation adjusted increase over 10 years with one promotion (10%) and a masters degree (9%) has been 22%.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe right valuation is determined by people rejecting job offers (or leaving current jobs) and accepting job offers. Repeated cleared transactions is what allows a market to determine the price.
- giantg2 5y agoBut can also create inefficiencies for an organization because they lose institutional knowledge and incur training costs.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoMarkets are more efficient when transaction information is public, and hence all wages should be public. Assuming the goal is to minimize that friction.
- giantg2 5y agoTrue. It would be great if they would at least post salary ranges for jobs (based on company policy and/or the people in the role at the company). I don't even feel like applying to most jobs. If it's not paying more than I make now, why should I waste my time? Such a pain to filter out jobs without it listed.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoColorado took the first step in that direction. If you are applying to a company that employs people in CO, you can check their CO listing.
- giantg2 5y agoExcept the ranges aren't even useful. I've seen most that are like $50k-150k. Not helpful at all in my opinion.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoIt will take some time, and ideally more stated will follow. If CA/WA/OR/MA/IL/NY/NJ/CT follow, then it could lead to some real change.
- nradov 5y agoHence why some companies now explicitly disallow CO residents from applying for jobs. Those employers would rather lose out on CO talent instead of weakening their negotiating position by posting an explicit salary range.
- 5y ago
- zenithd 5y agoThis strategy can be sub-optimal from the employer's perspective. Consider yourself as an employer and assume your employees have perceived switching cost C > 0. Your employee will approach you with bids b_1, ..., b_n all of which are substantially larger than C. So to keep your employee you will need to pay C plus some premium. In fact, not just any premium, but probably something close to max(b_1, ..., b_n). If you can make good guesses at C and b_1..b_n, then you can retain employees by ensuring you're always giving raises between C and max(b_1, ..., b_n). And all of that assumes that employees are fungible at any particular price point. They're not; employers also have switching costs. Among two otherwise equivalent employees you'd much prefer the one you already have.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThis might be true for FAANG employers or others employing people in high demand, but based on the behavior of the vast majority of employers, it is clearly less costly of a problem than the savings of not having to pay prevailing market prices for all their employees.
- kongin 5y agoYou don't have to threaten to leave, you do leave.
- denton-scratch 5y agoThe cost of changing jobs is pretty high, in my assessment. I mean, perhaps not if you're young, single and mobile; but if you are married with kids in school, own a home and pay a mortgage, changing jobs is personally very disruptive. And then you have to develop a working relationship with your new boss and employer, and your new colleagues; you have to learn new tools and platforms, which may make you much less productive for up to a year. And all of these learnings carry risk - for whatever reason, the new job might not work out, and you might have to move again, this time maybe with a shotgun to your head. The employer-employee relationship isn't symmetrical, even if you are a superstar engineer. No company has ever relocated just because a superstar engineer decided he preferred a warmer climate. Basically, staff are fungible, employers are not.
- bityard 5y agoI just wanted to say that I really enjoyed your writing style and the overall message of the article. Thank you. Whenever a topic like this comes up on HN or Reddit, most of the comments I see are incredibly pessimistic about the job market and/or reek of entitlement. I'm not saying that we should make excuses for exploitative employers but unless you get extremely lucky when starting out, you just have to show up and put in the work, even when the works sucks, even when the pay sucks. Then after a little while, put that shit on your resume and move on to something better. Rinse, repeat.
- jermaustin1 5y agoThank you for saying that. I love writing down my stories. It is therapeutic, almost like writing them releases me from the bad memory. It is basically a VERY lightly edited stream of consciousness.
- giantg2 5y ago"Then after a little while, put that shit on your resume and move on to something better. Rinse, repeat." I guess I'm one of the pessimists. I'm 10 years in and nothing has gotten better. The benefits have been eroding too. It never paid off and I have trouble seeing it ever pay off if the first third of my career has been so terrible. I've become disengaged, which I'm sure will lead to a vicious cycle.
- jermaustin1 5y agoI can only speak from my own history, but I've worked in Houston, TX and NYC, and both have pretty good senior dev jobs available at all times. Are you maybe not applying for those higher positions? Junior devs will always be taken advantage of unless you know someone. I even took a Jr Dev job (on paper) only 6 years ago or so, because the manager knew me. I was paid more than the senior developer, and he reported to me in practice.
- giantg2 5y agoI'm not allowed (have a wife) to leave my current area (Philly-ish). I have applied for a couple jobs. I dont apply to most jobs because there is no salary info or the salary range listed is not any better than my current job. I'm an intermediate developer. I've unofficially filled roles like senior dev and tech lead. I've also worked as an ASC (supposed to be reserved for senior devs). Oh well
- dgb23 5y agoYes. It is normal to have some process or agreement in place to regularly talk about the past and future, including raises/bonuses. Every three two twelve months seems sensible to me depending on circumstances.
- bityard 5y agoThe are companies out there that will give raises to high performers as incentives, but it's far from standard. Typically, you have to _ask_ for a raise. (And, importantly, you need to bring _proof_ of why you deserve a raise.)
- red_trumpet 5y agoBut getting personnel responsibility should be a good reason to ask for a raise, right?
- HeyLaughingBoy 5y agoAnything's a good reason to ask for a raise if you think it is.
- filmgirlcw 5y agoIt’s rare, but it can happen. I once negotiated a a raise in salary (of about $15k a year) because they wanted me to move to a much more expensive city. No quitting threats, it was just decided that it was a requirement for me to relocate. Then, the week I arrived in the new city, I got another $10k raise. It was because we’d just lost another senior employee to a large company and they wanted to preemptively retain me, but it was one of the few “out of nowhere” raises I have ever had. But in general, it isn’t in a business’s best interest to just offer raises without any negotiation or discussion. If a person isn’t asking for more, why should you offer it? Like, morally, I totally see the argument to do it preemptively, but as a business function I don’t. It’s true that the best way to get a promotion or a significant raise is to get an offer at a competitor. And that sucks. But, it is also possible to make the argument for a promotion or raise without threatening to quit. I’ve done both over my career and while the competing offer tactic usually works faster, it isn’t a pre-requisite. The one important thing to note is that if you are going to leverage another offer for a promotion/raise, you need to be prepared to walk if the company says no. If you don’t, you will never have any leverage ever again. So my advice is always to not make idle threats you aren’t willing to back up. I’ve had job offers before for substantially more money but at places I did’t want to work at. I don’t take those offers to my current employer (assuming I still want to work there). Instead, I use that knowledge of my value/worth to leverage get an offer at a place I would leave for OR to craft a better argument when I present my case for promotion/pay raise at my current employer.
- mywittyname 5y ago> But in general, it isn’t in a business’s best interest to just offer raises without any negotiation or discussion. If a person isn’t asking for more, why should you offer it? Like, morally, I totally see the argument to do it preemptively, but as a business function I don’t. It demonstrates that a business values its employees, literally, and this does build good will. Honestly, this is how you keep the better employees, and you're probably keeping them at below-replacement rates, even if yo do give "generous" raises. I have a friend who gets a consistent 4-8% annual raise and he refuses to interview because he likes that reliable growth. Replacing a worker is a dice roll, and if you already have a five, it doesn't really make sense to let them leave for greener pastures in the hopes of scoring a six on the next role. But it definitely doesn't make sense to keep raising pay on take-em-or-leave-em middling employees. Let them keep doing a mediocre, but useful job for a few years until they leave, then hope you role a five or six on their replacement.
- nostrademons 5y agoThe moment the high-tech antitrust employee lawsuit was announced, I got a pay bump of 50%. (Literally the moment - the press release went out and within an hour managers were making the rounds and saying "Well, looks like you got a raise.") It equalized at about 2x my hiring comp. Makes the $1000 I got from that class action lawsuit look pretty piddly, though - if the whole industry's salaries were increased by 50% in a day, how much were we being underpaid before?
- HeyLaughingBoy 5y agoYes, of course there are. When I moved on (from the underpaid job I mentioned in another post), I got almost double the salary because I was so underpaid at that previous job. After being there a year, I was offered a 5% raise, but I negotiated it to about 15% IIRC because I was clearly worth it and they didn't want me to leave. Some companies prosper in business by being run properly, others do it by sheer coincidence.
- giantg2 5y agoI work in finance, so I think the company knows perfectly well what they are doing. Ifs no coincidence they are taking advantage of people.
- denton-scratch 5y agoThis. It's business. If they treat employment as some kind of "friends" relationship, they will go broke, and you will lose your job.
- giantg2 5y agoThey don't have to treat it as a friends thing to treat people fairly. The least they can do is not violate their own policies (happens all the time at my company).
- kova12 5y agoI wonder how that employer got affected when the guy left, and employer was left with $300k worth of employees laid off. In 2007 engineers have already started being pretty hot commodity.