12 ms·
Companies that use Lisp extensively
- vernie 5y agoNo mention of GOAL, Naughty Dog's Lisp dialect used for game scripting?
- mbrodersen 5y agoIt is a very short list. I wonder why Lisp has completely failed to be successful given the usual fan claims that it is more powerful, more productive, more everything than any other languages? The usual claim by Lisp fans that only a few blessed people are smart enough to understand and use Lisp is beyond ridiculous. I learned Common Lisp, Scheme and Clojure just for fun, and implemented my own Lisp variations (including macros) in both C++ and Haskell. Lisp languages are easy to learn and use. However I would never use a Lisp for production work. I absolutely could. However I simply prefer languages like C++, Typescript and Haskell. So my guess is that people are different, people’s brains work differently, and for whatever reasons Lisp appeals to certain personality types and not others. And it just happens to be that the personally/brain types that prefer Lisp is a minority. It could have been the other way around of course but it just isn’t. I haven’t been able to come up with any other explanation that seems to be even remotely plausible.
- tmm84 5y agoMy personal thought on the why it isn't popular is the fact Common Lisp has multiple implementations. Which one do I pick? What are the differences? What's the compatibility like should I decide to switch to another implementation? Experienced common lisp users will know the answer but try and get a manager or leader with no experience to spend time trying to understand/read about all these things when simpler/easier choices that work the traditional way exist. This can apply to scheme to some extent as well.
- eatonphil 5y agoThis isn't just some list someone created once and done. I've been following it for a while and it gets updated regularly every few months with new submissions. I'd recommend you to follow the repo too if you want to keep up to date.
- sour-taste 5y agoDo people decide to go to work for a company based on the language they'll be working in? Seems like something that should be very far down the priority list?
- brundolf 5y agoI think there's a little-discussed connection between dev happiness and motivation/productivity. I for one am much more driven when I feel good about the thing I'm producing, and the language it's written in has a big impact on that.
- alfiedotwtf 5y agoIt's my only priority... Every place I've worked at, I only applied after asking a) what language do they use b) is it technically cool.
- jlg23 5y agoYes, I do. Just because I know how to speak/write some language I don't have to love it. And I rather do something I enjoy than dragging myself to work every day. Increased productivity is just a corollary. (I'll still accept a java gig, but the salary must make up for the daily misery).
- jes 5y agoAt 62, I'd probably work for free for a company that used Common Lisp and had half a clue.
- agumonkey 5y agomaybe this https://nyxt.atlas.engineer/ https://nyxt.atlas.engineer/ could belong there ?
- bgorman 5y agoIs Clojure not considered a true lisp?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- waffletower 5y agoClojure is a lisp-1, but its design favors immutable data structures and attendant functional forms. These design choices do have detractors in the various lisp communities.
- eatonphil 5y agoScheme shares the attributes you mentioned.
- Turing_Machine 5y agoOr even more so, Racket. There are purists who don't consider Racket or even Scheme to be Lisps, either. FWIW, I do not agree with them (I also consider Clojure a Lisp), but they exist. There's a certain highly vocal contingent of Lisp fans who consider the Common Lisp spec to be some kind of sacred document, and that anything that's been invented in the past 37 (!) years is useless. IMO, those people have done far more harm than good for Lisp and Lisp-like languages. And yeah, there's a lot of the same religion-like purity around Rust nowadays.
- Zababa 5y agoSame thing with Haskell, in the last month I had a few people argue with me that if a language isn't Haskell, it's not functional programming.
- tephra 5y agoI've talked to several people who equate fp with "advanced type system" and not "programming by function composition" (which for me is the correct definition).
- jakear 5y agoNeat that the Roomba is written in a lisp. It has it’s quirks and hiccups, but on the whole is extraordinarily well designed, standing head and shoulders above the usual slew of “home automation” products I wouldn’t touch with a 10’ pole. The dog definitely influences this opinion. :) Is it relevant that it’s written in a lisp? Probably not. But then, maybe. Baseless speculation: mine pre-dates their internet connected models, which means it’s 100% plug and play. The only possible config is the system clock and the startup schedule, and I’m just using what the prior owner had already set. Had the OS been written in a more traditional language perhaps the engineers would have been tempted to include all the modern IOT features from the start and the result would be the complex app-driven network-needing mess that so many products tangle themselves up in (including perhaps the modern Roombas). Again, that’s all baseless speculation, but I do see a potential connection between folks who choose to code a robot in lisp and folks who eschew “sugar” features in favor of the most pure “do one thing and do it better than anything else” implementation.
- DonHopkins 5y agoDoes the Roomba's Lisp use an incremental garbage collector?
- bch 5y agoMark and sweep
- metagame 5y agoI saw a great paper on their dialect a while ago. Will try and find it and edit this with a link. Check out passage 3.4; it goes into detail on their garbage collector. L – A Common Lisp for Embedded Systems Rodney A. Brooks and Charles Rosenberg IS Robotics [now iRobot Corporation, the famous floor vacuum company] 1995 https://web.archive.org/web/20041031144839/http://www-2.cs.cmu.edu/~chuck/pubpg/luv95.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20041031144839/http://www-2.cs.c...
- MengerSponge 5y agoWhoosh :)
- stelcodes 5y agoI feel like Clojure companies should be on here too as it is very much a LISP
- eatonphil 5y ago> This list intended only for company with Common Lisp and Scheme usage Debate aside, this group seems to be fairly explicit about their intent. Here's an issue where they discussed the decision recently: https://github.com/azzamsa/awesome-lisp-companies/issues/43 https://github.com/azzamsa/awesome-lisp-companies/issues/43.
- metagame 5y agoThere are a lot of people who would debate that point. There are even some fairly common macros that are used when this comes up. My favorite is this one: «I find Clojure revolting. It is the most explicit to date abandonment of the age-old Lispers' Dream, "Lisp All The Way Down." Clojure is the antithesis of the Lisp Machine. Instead of a crystalline pyramid of comprehensible mutually-interlocking concepts, behind every Clojure primitive there lurks Black Magic. The Clojure user who is missing some routine or other will run crying to Java for help, rather than implementing the feature himself correctly - that is, as a natural part of the entire language, built on the same concepts. Clojure pisses on everything I've ever loved about Lisp. Clojure is the False Lisp, which Reeketh of the Cube Farm. A Lisp unworthy of the name; one which encourages users to pepper their code with calls to opaque routines having no underlying Lispiness. A Lisp which barfs Java stack traces. It promotes - no, mandates - the use of undigestable foreign matter in Lisp code: primitives on which you cannot pop the hood to reveal intelligible innards. The cult of Good Enough which seems to pervade all of modern computing has finally chewed its way through to the Lisp community, with Clojure as the result. I am tired of this abomination being hailed as the future of Lisp. Aficionados of real Lisps, such as myself, will keep hoping, dreaming, and working on systems which do not betray the original virtues of the language.»
- gaze 5y agowhoever wrote that has never finished or contributed substantially to a project.
- mucholove 5y agoGreat idea! Would love to see a list of companies using Smalltalk extensively. :)
- the_only_law 5y agoI actually saw one of the few commercial Smalltalk vendors hiring a while back. Though, it seemed like it was less writing smalltalk and more building the underlying platform.
- medo-bear 5y agoHexstreamSoft probably shouldn't be there. I don't think it is a registered company
- johnlorentzson 5y agoHexstreamSoft is one guy who decided to piss off just about everyone he could in the Lisp community, then his Twitter account got locked and everyone stopped caring.
- medo-bear 5y agoyes he engaged in some unwarranted personal attacks. i actually hope he is ok though. he seemed like a passionate guy just very misguided. my point about raising this is just to have a high barrier for appearing in that list. i otherwise enjoy the list alot
- vesinisa 5y agoI am pretty sure there is no "UmeÃ¥" or "UmeÃ¥ University" in Sweden. It does look like a mojibake of Umeå, which does have a university.
- lioeters 5y agoFixed: https://github.com/azzamsa/awesome-lisp-companies/commit/7fbcc8de8cc084541424222b6b07d17764877e01 https://github.com/azzamsa/awesome-lisp-companies/commit/7fb...
- LocalH 5y agoHarmonix Music Systems uses a bespoke Lisp-ish language for their game scripting that we call DataArray (or DTA for short) in the Guitar Hero II modding community. It's very powerful to be able to put script in almost any place where a variable or constant is used.
- fernandotakai 5y agodoes clojure count? if so, nubank (brazilian fintech) would be one of the biggest one. they even bought cognitect https://www.cognitect.com/blog/2020/07/23/Cognitect-Joins-Nubank https://www.cognitect.com/blog/2020/07/23/Cognitect-Joins-Nu...
- albrewer 5y agoOdd that AutoDesk isn't on here, since I got into programming Lisp when trying to automate AutoCAD.
- leoc 5y agoHow much commercial use do Prolog or other logic programming languages see these days? The impression I seem to get is that Prolog, while never exactly mainstream, had a much more significant commercial foothold 30 or even 20 years ago than it does now; but I don't know if that's accurate.
- jeffbee 5y agoThe almost total lack of large, accomplished companies in this list is the biggest red flag anyone needs.
- tom_ 5y agoPossibly relevant: https://blog.gardeviance.org/2015/03/on-pioneers-settlers-town-planners-and.html https://blog.gardeviance.org/2015/03/on-pioneers-settlers-to...
- gaze 5y agoBit chicken and egg -- nobody uses it because nobody writes it. I think once in a while a small team of aficionados will write a project in it and then eventually rewrite as it becomes evident that it's too hard to hire for. At least this is what Reddit did. If you're the one person responsible for the project and are not super worried about people picking CL up, then I think CL fans will go for it. That's what Robert/stylewarning did at HRL and Rigetti and he says it's worked well.
- vindarel 5y agoAll quantum computing companies, Google, Boeing, big industry players… besides, this list is fan-cooked. We add one when we see a job announce or a word on social media. BTW, nothing stops me from enjoying Lisp's powers for my small business even if my favorite big company doesn't use it.
- gaze 5y agoI really like Lisp. I also have the impression that the people talking about Lisp a lot are writing far more prose than code. There are maybe 10 exceptions to this, those being Nikodemus, Shirakumo, Stylewarning, Christian Schafmeister, Borodust, and some others. It's a really cool group -- everyone is super nice and very productive and generally helpful. That said, there's a nostalgia for this language that I wish we could do away with. If people would just shut up and write Lisp and so we can have a healthier library ecosystem, or just shut up and not, I think we'd be in a better place. If it's so productive, where's all the fruits of that productivity (outside of the list of people I mentioned?) Also FFS, and I rant about this once every 4 months, LispWorks pricing structure just makes me angry every time I think about it -- and I've heard all the excuses, some make more sense than others, but they do nothing to make me less angry.