3 ms·
Why is it that when Americans want to criticize Americans for doing bad things they compare themselves to non-Americans? Is the society really that xenophobic?
by AndyMcConachie 5y ago
Why is it that when Americans want to criticize Americans for doing bad things they compare themselves to non-Americans? Is the society really that xenophobic?
The term Banana Republic comes from the idea that a south/central American country is a dictatorship run by a small oligarchy and a powerful foreign company. The classic example is Guatemala or Cuba under the United Fruit Company.
The US exported murder to central America to ensure that the UFC didn't have to deal with unions and violently molded these Banana Republics. Now, completely unironically, this article uses the term to compare wealth inequality in America to America's imperial projects. It's gross.
Rhetorically, it's as if the article is saying, "We're supposed to be the exploiters, not the exploited." And it's not as if America's imperial projects have slowed down. These monsters are still regularly overthrowing governments in central and south America. See recent attempts in Bolivia and Nicaragua.
I don't understand American culture. The people there don't give a shit about what their government does in other countries, but then when they're subjected to the same inhumanity, suddenly they're comparing themselves to what they created elsewhere as a means to object to their local circumstance. The writer of this article expects their audience to know what a Banana Republic is, hence the title. So it's not like Americans are ignorant of the term or its history. They just don't give a shit until it happens to them.
- vehemenz 5y agoI don't necessarily disagree with you, but I'm not sure what this article has to do with "American culture". ZeroHedge is a fringe website—hardly representative of the average American. Either way, I don't think it's a problem to compare aspects of one's state to more regressive ones. It is useful to point out that China under Xi looks a lot more like North Korea and that fundamentalist Christians hold views similar to Islamist extremists. In this case, the average, uneducated citizen might not be aware that their great America resembles "shithole countries" (their words) in many ways, and if a rude comparison is what's needed, so be it.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoI think his gripe is with the fact that US had, in some cases, created those 'shithole countries'
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago" So it's not like Americans are ignorant of the term or its history. They just don't give a shit until it happens to them." Most people are thouroughly ignorant of the evils their governments do abroad, and when someone like assange exposes it they are prosecuted hard. Ofcourse many dont care I think you are right, there is a certain irony to it
- BBC-vs-neolibs 5y agoI think it's pretty apt. They co-opted their own system.