7 ms·
The hard truth is that both are unsustainable and extremely inefficient in the end. Transporting 70kg of meat in a 2 tons metal box, which is sitting unused 95
by lm28469 5y ago
The hard truth is that both are unsustainable and extremely inefficient in the end.
Transporting 70kg of meat in a 2 tons metal box, which is sitting unused 95% of its life, using 10 sq meters of public space. ~25% of the materials used on a car aren't recyclable and end up in a landfill. With an average lifespan of 12 years and 1.4 billion vehicles on earth that's a lot of waste.
And that's not even talking about the current trend of ditching nuclear for intermittent energy sources while at the same time increasing our reliance on electricity
- rektide 5y agothere's still a problem of toting around multi-ton structures which seems semi-obscene, but i a little interested in decoupling some. a car as a self contained structure, with it's own motive power system, with extensive energy reserves, seems wasteful. especially given how much cars just sit around. i like to image the future as using things like the Citroen skate concept from a couple days ago[1], or other similar-ish strategies of using some kind of detachable tug or tractor that is summonable on demand. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28745304 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28745304
- sva_ 5y agoYou could make similar arguments about houses, offices, etc. Humans have a desire for comfort, being protected from the elements and such, and those desires aren't invalid. The argument of cars wasting space is a very city-centric view, in which people live in a very densely populated area. The surface area of this planet is around 500e6 km^2, of which about 1/3 is land-area (~166e6 km^2). Of course not nearly all of that is inhabitable, but if we assumed that every person owned a car, they'd all combined take 8e9 * 10 m^2 = 8e4 km^2 of space, or < 0.0005% of available land. Very, very rough estimation, but just to poke fun at the ridiculous claim that allocating 10 m^2 for every person's transportation device is wasteful. We got enough space, it's just our way of living stacked on top of each other, which is weird. Sure, it could be more efficient, but people's basic desires aren't numbers to do cold optimizations like that on.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lm28469 5y agoIf you compare everything to the surface area of the planet then sure, my 3cm brain tumor isn't that big either then... What matters is that cars are taking all the space in cities, most people do live in cities, and the rate of urbanisation is going up. I don't think cars are a "desire" either, it's more of a need we imposed ourselves because of the way we chose to live, and we see where this is leading us: polluted, pedestrian hostile cities, the creation of large commercial centers outside of cities which in turn created a need for more cars, &c. Visit any medium/big city and imagine it without parked cars, these small 10 sq meters quickly add up and would change the way you perceive the city. No more noise, no more danger for pedestrians, maybe more apartments, parks, trees/vegetations, terraces, bicycle lanes, community gardens, &c. I believe the current form of EVs are the last breath of a dying beast, personal vehicles are bound to disappear of city centers. I commute by bike and I see traffic jams every single day in virtually every major streets of my city, jams made of mostly 5 seats cars being used by one person. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urbanization_by_country#/media/File:Urbanized_population_2018.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urbanization_by_country#/media... https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.URB.TOTL.IN.ZS https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.URB.TOTL.IN.ZS
- PartiallyTyped 5y agoWhere I come from, there is so little urbanization that the average number of active cars is very close to the number of adults in the country. Even within cities, the situation is pretty rough, there's just too many cars, and too little public transportation. This creates a vicious cycle, nobody wants to move to the city because of the cars, the smog, the noise, and traffic, so everybody moves out, except that most people have to commute in the city. I have since moved to Copenhagen, and I have not used a car in 2 years, buses are always packed but there's always another one coming in 5 minutes, and a bike is more than sufficient for my needs. Contrasting the two was eye opening, and Copenhagen isn't even a Metropolis like NY or Tokyo. I hope that pedestrians and cyclists reclaim cities from cars. Vastly more efficient, better for our health, the environment, noise pollution, and far safer for children.
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoYes but self driving cars, which could be a solution for this problem since we could then have cars on demand, are way harder to implement using oil than electricity.
- LinuxBender 5y agoCars are a comfort utility for sure, but the alternatives are not viable any more. It gets really cold here and the snow gets really deep. Walking to town is possible but transporting anything meaningful beyond what fits in a rucksack is challenging in the snow. Stores don't like people bringing in rucksacks. Most people are not fat-adapted and aren't healthy enough to make that journey on a regular basis carrying that payload. The elderly would for sure freeze to death. I could ride a horse into town but there are no longer designated hitching areas or at least not many, so I would be putting the horse at risk. Horses emit CO2 and consume fuel even when you are not riding them. Most vehicles here are trucks and half of them are diesel. I have not seen any EV's in that class of vehicle yet. The closest is the Ford Lightning which AFAIK is not available until spring 2022 and that is a light duty truck. When will medium and heavy duty EV trucks be available? What companies are working on these? Are they all-wheel drive? How heavy of a trailer can they tow and how far? Are any of them flat-beds with a 5th-wheel hitch option?
- ericmay 5y agoYes but these are all problems caused by car-first infrastructure and we shouldn’t over-optimize for edge cases for locations where it “gets so cold the elderly would freeze to death”. I guess I’m not an old person but if you lived in a walkable town are the elderly really freezing to death walking to go get a cup of coffee? The only reason alternatives aren’t viable is because we actively choose to make them not viable. They’re viable all over the world. Just not here because we’d rather shackle ourselves to oil and debt instead.
- LinuxBender 5y agoThe elderly drive into town to go to the grocery store. Yes, back in the day everyone grew all the things they needed on their land. I wish this were still the case but with the common availability of stores people have grown accustom to driving to the store to stock up on food. For the elderly and physically disabled that have internet they could shop online if they knew this was a thing and have food delivered to them via someone elses truck. This is by no means an edge case. This is the normal life for 20% of people in the United States. Even in places that don't get cold, elderly are not going to be walking to the grocery store. I don't think we are going to dial back this reality short of a world-war that decimates society everywhere and/or some event that sends us back to the stone age. I should add that even if we all agreed to turn back that dial and get back to self sustainability it is not something you can just turn on. This requires a few generations for this to be functional for entire families.
- api 5y agoArguments of that form set up a dichotomy of “return to the Bronze Age, or do nothing.” They are part of why nothing has been done about climate change. The fossil fuel industry wants you to believe that decarbonizing a modern economy is impossible. They want their product to be absolutely essential and irreplaceable. Oil is irreplaceable (with current technology) to a very limited extent, but plastics and petrochemicals account for less than 10% of all oil consumption. Aviation is also less than 10%. Cars account for the majority of all oil use. We should be able to cut oil use to 25% of the current total with no deep changes to our standard of living. It’s even more extreme for coal. Only a tiny percentage of coal is used for metallurgy. Almost all of it goes to electricity production.