5 ms·
Not totally surprising. The way I've seen it working is people trade around where the price was yesterday and it goes up and down a bit. Then every so often - w
by roenxi 5y ago
Not totally surprising. The way I've seen it working is people trade around where the price was yesterday and it goes up and down a bit. Then every so often - when not enough coal is being produced - the buffers at the mines and ports run out and the situation becomes a straight auction for the last scraps. That usually makes the price graph draw a ski-jump shape.
It is a pretty good time to be a coal mine. A lot of investment has been scared out of the sector, so not so much competition. But people still keep using coal.
- azalemeth 5y agoEven though they really, really shouldn't. As you undoubtedly know, it's a terribly dirty fuel source that is destroying the planet. When I saw this headline, my gut reaction was actually "good -- I hope that makes other fuel sources more competitive". I then realised that I am not an economist, and that it would have the opposite effect -- increasing production. One thing I'd love to see come out of COP26 is an internationally agreed minimum tariff per ton of CO2e, including electricity weighted by its means of production. We want coal to be very expensive to buy (and very cheap to sell).
- rustnote 5y agoCoal isn't just for electricity, it usually rises and falls with the price of steel because it's needed for the process. Also has use in a bunch of other things like water filters.
- aceazzameen 5y agoI thought water filters use charcoal, not coal.
- dustintrex 5y agoIt's going to have both effects simultaneously. Production is not going to increase very much overnight, because coal mines are not particularly elastic. However, most coal consumers are actually in the market for electricity, so high coal prices will encourage substitution with alternatives like solar.
- tialaramex 5y agoHigh electricity prices also eliminate the cost of (some) subsidy schemes for sustainable energy. Which almost can't help but encourage more such schemes. The UK's CfDs (Contracts for Difference) pay schemes like wind farms a fixed price for their output, allowing projects to go out to market saying look based on our plans we're going to make so-and-so-many MWh of electricity, the UK promises to pay so-and-so-much £££ for that electricity, therefore lend us (much less) £££ to build it and we'll pay you a nice return. This means investors only need to care about whether your wind farm proposal actually makes electricity, not guess what the price of that electricity will be when it's sold. Normally these schemes cost the government money. Say electricity is selling for £50 per MWh, and your wind farm's CfD specifies £80 per MWh, the government hands over £30 per MWh extra to make up the difference. But, when prices sky rocket the government actually gets paid the difference. When electricity sells for £200 per MWh and your wind farm's CfD said £80 per MWh, you only get £80 per MWh as promised, the other £120 per MWh goes into the general fund to buy missiles or feed orphans or whatever.
- makomk 5y agoPart of the problem in the UK is that the amount of wind was at something like a 40-year low earlier this year, meaning that wind farms weren't producing that much at all. As the amount of renewable power increases and fossil fuels get phased out and become more expensive, we can expect high electricity prices to coincide more and more with times when renewables are producing very little power and low prices with times when they're producing lots of it. So even if CfD prices look good on paper compared to average electricity wholesale prices the government is still likely to lose a lot of money on the deal due to when that electricity is produced, which ultimately comes out of all our electricity bills.
- solotronics 5y agoHow do you even heat a house with wind? Aren't most homes in the US and EU are heated with gas?
- 5y ago
- tuyiown 5y ago> my gut reaction was actually "good -- I hope that makes other fuel sources more competitive". I then realised that I am not an economist, and that it would have the opposite effect -- increasing production. Not a economist either, but those are not exclusive. Also, this is not the case here, but ever lowering demands triggers structural prices increase at some point, due do scale cost reduction not working anymore, but you won't see investments in production either.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- piokoch 5y agoWelcome to the reality. People don't want to freeze in their houses. People will gladly listen to the talks how renewable energy sources are good for our planet, they will even go on "climate strike" marches... until temperature drops at home below 21 degrees.
- Lutger 5y agoA lot of people are also willing to invest in better isolation and sustainable ways of heating their homes. Meaningful action does not require us freezing in our houses, not yet. But you have a point, which is exactly why survival of our societies should not be a choice on the consumerist menu. The government, the justice system, the corporate world and finally the citizen should lead in the struggle to decarbonize the world, not the consumer.
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago> The government, the justice system, the corporate world and finally the citizen should lead in the struggle to decarbonize the world, not the consumer. That always sounds like an excuse for doing nothing to me.
- Lutger 5y agoWhat one must do as a citizen is put pressure on the government. And, as a consumer, one should also make climate friendly choices, but it's not the most important thing and it should not distract us from where the real difference is made.
- bombcar 5y agoIt's better than that, it's an excuse for doing nothing and blaming the other for nothing getting done.
- Lutger 5y agoNo. It's the other way around: shifting responsibility from government and corporation to the individual is an excuse for doing nothing and blaming you for nothing getting done. This is how recycling and the carbon footprint is invented - by the softdrink and fossil fuel industry. You have just fallen perfectly into their traps. Just listen to the rhetoric that Shell uses: this is literally what they say.
- rasz 5y ago>It is a pretty good time to be a coal mine. Not in EU where Germany decided we should all use Russian gas from pipeline bypassing other EU states. https://edition.cnn.com/2021/09/20/europe/poland-coal-mine-turow-fine-eu-intl/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2021/09/20/europe/poland-coal-mine-t...
- roenxi 5y agoAccording to the linked chart, that mine should be making on or about $(240-100)=$140/t in profit - since they were breaking even at $100 and now the price is $240. That $600k/day fine is therefore about 4,000 tonnes of coal (ie, nothing). The mine produces ~ 76,000 tonnes a day. That is what the free market thinks of the EU's fine. The situation isn't that simple since the export price is for black coal and the Polish mine would be producing lignite, but ski jump prices are no joke.