2 ms·
The initial primary explosion could cause significant enough destruction to the ship that it acts like the “scatter charge” in a thermobaric weapon, spreading t
by refurb 5y ago
The initial primary explosion could cause significant enough destruction to the ship that it acts like the “scatter charge” in a thermobaric weapon, spreading the undetonated oil sufficiently into the air that a larger percentage of the onboard oil is detonated as part of a “single event”…
Oil doesn't detonate, even if scattered by an explosion. Fuel-air explosions require very specific conditions it's entirely unlikely those conditions could be met with crude oil. Thermobaric weapons use chemicals like ethylene oxide that are: 1) highly volatile, 2) easily dispersed [no thick like oil], 3) have a very broad air-fuel mixture range which is flammable.
Could the vapor explode and spread burning oil everywhere? Sure.
Could it explode, distributing microscopic oil particles in such a way to sustain a fuel-air explosion? Highly unlikely.
- techdragon 5y agoThat’s a good point about it being crude oil and crude oil not detonating. Detonate was probably the wrong word to use later on in the chain of events, they will have much more in common with a movie/tv special effects “explosion” (lots of smoke and fire with a smaller boom) than a proper “explosive detonation” but minus the point about supersonic detonation shockwaves there’s still a terrifying chain of events that all start with either fire or fuel vapour explosion and lead to lots of fire, spilled oil and almost likely a sunk ship.
- Aeolun 5y agoJet fuel can’t melt steel beams either, and yet… Regardless of the failure mode, there’s probably a few that people haven’t thought of yet.
- jquery 5y agoAnd yet it can weaken them severely beyond design limits.