6 ms·
What do you mean, "are becoming"? They have always been. If the payment processors don't want to be associated with a service, they'll refuse to handle payments
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
What do you mean, "are becoming"? They have always been. If the payment processors don't want to be associated with a service, they'll refuse to handle payments and then there's simply no way for the service providers to get paid. See wikileaks and other "problematic" sites.
Advertisers are also regulators. I've seen sites start heavily censoring themselves because someone complained to Google and they pulled the ads. Stuff like this ruins the web.
- White_Wolf 5y agoIn a world where cash is starting to dissapear, payment processors and banking in general should be regulated and treated just like some sort of utility company (Ex: Water, electricity). Advertising is a different beast altogether. Being able to to exchanges (money for goods, etc) is something quite a basic right(If I can call it that). That doesn't apply to making money though. I don't think it's normal in any way to force anyone to conduct business with someone they don't want to unless is a basic necessity in that particular day and age.
- dotancohen 5y agoI'm not a fan of digital currencies, but this is one of their shining points.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoIt is supposedly coming, albeit decades late: https://www.frbservices.org/financial-services/fednow https://www.frbservices.org/financial-services/fednow
- mcherm 5y ago> In a world where cash is starting to dissapear, payment processors and banking in general should be regulated and treated just like some sort of utility company I'm not sure if you are missing contacts or providing irony. But the fact is payment processors and banking in general is extremely heavily regulated. A few years ago when you saw almost all banks and payment companies starting to crack down on spending money to buy and sell cryptocurrency, that was to no small extent because federal regulators gave them a little side-eye about the subject. No specific regulations, to be clear, but a few pointed questions. When every means of sending money overseas demands clear documentation of your identity, That's not so much because banks feel the need to know every detail of your business; it is strictly mandated by federal law. And while my examples all involve US banking, most governments around the world are similarly strict.
- woofcat 5y agoI think they're saying the regulations should include not excluding someones legal business because you 'dislike it' ala WikiLeaks.
- londons_explore 5y agoTodays finance regulators require you to not do business with some people, often without good evidence. For example, if you do business with wikileaks, you will get a nudge from the regulator to 'reduce the number of high risk clients' you work with... They're not saying it's illegal, but they're also saying they're going to find some regulation to prosecute you with unless you do as they say. It's a sad state of affairs when these kind of regulations aren't written in stone, but instead are flexible and applied on a case-by-case basis.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoThis sort of thing is exactly why we need private and anonymous cryptocurrency like Monero.
- webspinner 5y agoIs this still the case today, in 2021? I know that Wikileaks was blockaded for several years, but I thought those were all dealt with.
- superkuh 5y agoThere are different types of regulation. The one that exists now and primarily is regulation such that individual human people cannot transfer or store in to large amounts of money without federal investigation of the source and identity. Banking and processors comply with these rules and generally go overboard making things hard for human people so they can keep their own corporate asses safe. But the type of regulation that is needed is regulation of the banks and payment processors themselves. Not of their clients or things related to their clients.
- franga2000 5y agoHow credit card processing hasn't been classified and regulated as a utility is truly baffling to me. Especially with governments explicitly recommending contactless card payments instead of cash during the pandemic and many doing things like taking large bank notes out of circulation for years now. We don't need crazy things like crypto - we need decentralised and accountable banks and payment processors (not that the distinction between the two makes any sense either). Speaking of credit card companies: why do they exist?? Why can't my card just sign a digital request for transfer and tell the POS terminal to send it to my bank to be executed. A room of computer science students could write an open standard for that in like a month and have a working implementation within the year.
- psychlops 5y agoCrypto is the only competition that can force financial innovation in TBTF era.
- franga2000 5y agoInnovation isn't what's needed, it's regulation. Making an alternative that does a couple things better but a thousand things worse isn't going to turn a broken market into a free one. There are multiple types of decentralization and the one we need for finance isn't the "everyone is (theoretically) equal and there are no rules" of crypto but the "distributed network of trusted providers" that we use for things like public key infrastructure and email. People WILL get hacked, lose their wallets, etc. so recovery MUST be possible and like it or not, law enforcement SHOULD have the power to freeze accounts and take back money that doesn't belong to someone.
- mindslight 5y agoI'm no apologist for corporate power, but most payment network censorship seems to be driven by government regulations - Wikileaks, sex work, weed, and gambling are all things the government has passed laws to explicitly harm. As such, additional regulation is more likely to cement the current restrictions rather than repudiate them.
- chuckee 5y ago> Advertising is a different beast altogether. You are correct. Web advertising is long overdue for some trust-busting. But for some reason, antitrust law is rarely enforced.
- rawbot 5y agoThis is a recent situation. Back in the early 00's, paying for something online with a credit card, other than porn, was a novelty. I think things started to change in the late 00's. I remember a LOT of software being sold online (licenses and such) was sold via money orders or sometimes wire transfers.
- thriftwy 5y agoTravel is what enabled CC payments over the net. Airline/train tickets and hotel accomodations and internet payments are a match.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhy would online retail not also be a match? I assume there is are many more online retail transactions than travel related transactions simply because people shop retail more than they travel.
- thriftwy 5y agoPeople did not shop online that much, 15 years ago (especially outside USA). But they already had travel booking needs, which could be taken fully online with CC payments over the net. You could often pay upon delivery even when shopping online, but there's no need of delivery for tickets.
- 5y ago
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoAnd they should, for their own protection; they will be taken down hard if they are found to be complicit in financing things like terrorism and child pornography. When it comes to the recent events around Pornhub and Onlyfans, the payment processors erred on the side of caution, because those two customers of theirs couldn't for definite guarantee that nothing shady was going on on their websites.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"nothing shady was going on on their websites" There is more childporn on Facebook than Pornhub, you know why? Because pornhub requires an ID. But Facebook is untouchable because it's too big. If they were concerned about 'shady', they would shut down Wells Fargo for fraud
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> they will be taken down hard if they are found to be complicit How can the provider of vital infrastructure be complicit in anything? Is the engineer who designed and built a bridge complicit when a criminal crosses it? They should be considered neutral. Just like information carriers are considered neutral. Not liable for what goes on inside their networks. Searching for and punishing anyone violating any law is up to the authorities and they must do that without violating everyone else's privacy no matter how frustrating it must be for them.
- spottybanana 5y ago> I've seen sites start heavily censoring themselves because someone complained to Google and they pulled the ads. Stuff like this ruins the web. You mean my web is ruined because I don't see more those ads selling the newest crypto ponzi scheme which promises 10000% yearly returns? Let's deal with it, if advertising was totally uncensored that would be a nightmare for average user.
- jstanley 5y agoMore like your web is ruined because the site that tries to write about some controversial topic has to stay less controversial else they can't make money by showing ads.
- SiempreViernes 5y agoPeople can blog just fine without having to make money off them you know, and of those making doing it for the money the vast majority have to censor themselves to be able to grow and maintain their audience in the first place. Somewhat obviously, you don't actually get a lot of people willing to pay for your content if you hold truly unpopular opinions.
- gamacodre 5y agoThis bugs the crap out of me, it sounds like "waaaahhh I can't rake in ad money being a provocateur". So deal with it. Get a day job. Accept that large chunks of society will hate you (that's the goal anyway, right?) and that your business won't be welcome.
- Dylan16807 5y agoThey should still have access to basic banking services, as a utility. Would you think it's okay if their water company tried to cut them off?
- gamacodre 5y agoI was responding to a comment about making money from ads, but a similar line of thought works for banking services, I think. Suppose that your use of the water service was creating public lashback against the water utility for "supporting" your business. A loud minority is pestering the water board members and complaining that what you're doing ought to be illegal even if it isn't strictly yet. Some are pressuring other big water users to reexamine their contracts with the utility, and someone even managed to talk a pump supplier into severing their relationship with the utility. A different minority is yelling stuff about "rights" and making trouble at board meetings. The easiest possible thing to do in this situation is to find some vaguely plausible reason to cut your access to the public utility, and tell you that you have to truck your water in yourself from now on. Note that this kind of stuff actually happens to farmers, refineries, and other businesses. As far as what's "right"... Damn if I know. None of this is happening in a vacuum, and these decisions end up being made by people who are accountable to and influenced by their family, friends, and community for the choices that they make. Clear laws can dilute that responsibility, but only to a point.
- gumby 5y ago> If the payment processors don't want to be associated with a service Generally financial institutions are happy to take anyone’s money, and lend to them too unless they don’t think they’ll get their money back. Their regulators can change those criteria though, forcing upon them an unfunded mandate. This is no different than policing entities washing their searches through private entities (e.g. the telecoms). I consider this a pernicious trend.