6 ms·
To save anyone reading what is a very poorly argued article, their solution is to take Facebook under public ownership or treat it like a utility company. You
by rwmj 5y ago
To save anyone reading what is a very poorly argued article, their solution is to take Facebook under public ownership or treat it like a utility company. You don't have to think very hard to understand there are problems with this:
- You're giving the government (more specifically the party in power at the time) control over a highly effective form of propaganda, which won't have a good outcome.
- The US government would only regulate FB as it relates to US citizens, leaving FB free to operate as now in the rest of the world.
- In Japan where a similar addictive product aimed at minors (tobacco) is mostly under public ownership, the Japanese government has dragged its feet at regulation to reduce harm from cigarettes - eg it only banned smoking in bars last year. In the Japanese case they don't want to imperil the profits from JTI (Japan Tobacco).
- darkerside 5y agoPBS and NPR provide a good counterpoint. They are relatively civilized media, and while some might argue they are propagandistic, I tend to think they are much more centrist than the Fox News and MSNBCs of the world. Just because we offer a utility doesn't mean that we need to shut down what's already out there. FWIW, we dragged our feet for a very long time banning tobacco from many public places, probably in large part because of lobbying. What do you think is the mechanism by which Japanese legislators would be incentivized to systematically slow down tobacco legislation?
- fineIllregister 5y agoPBS and NPR are not government owned or controlled. A more apt comparison would probably be Voice of America.
- darkerside 5y agoPBS was a bad example, as I thought it was more similar to NPR. NPR is not a perfect example, but was founded through an act of Congress and is operated by public institutions. BBC is probably a better example. I'm thinking of domestic media.
- m0zg 5y agoI turn on NPR from time to time out of curiosity, and immediately regret it. It _used to be_ balanced, but now it's full-on hard left. It used to be that there actually was some diversity of opinion on NPR. Nowadays you don't even need to guess what points of view you will hear about hot button issues - it's hard left without fail. IOW they have obviated the need for themselves by making it possible to foresee what they will say without tuning in. That said, that's how it is with most media nowadays not just NPR, including this very site. It has become socially unacceptable to surface dissent.
- bradknowles 5y agoWith respect, no. What has happened is that everyone else has shifted hard right. NPR has stayed exactly where it was.
- m0zg 5y agoNo way. Trump derangement syndrome was (and arguably still is) on full display. Every hoax was presented strictly as a fact. Not a single positive comment on any of the policies, including the unambiguously positive things such as Israeli / Arab peace accords, withdrawal from Syria, and de-escalation in Korea, and so on. You'd have to be willfully blind to conclude what you've concluded.
- darkerside 5y agoTrump Shock is not a partisan issue. People on both sides of the aisle have been disgusted by his personal traits to the point that they are blind to the positive things that came from his reign. Note that this is a nonpartisan comment.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- amelius 5y agoYes. Just look at how some governments allow malpractices in casinos and lotteries, while they profit from the taxes.
- dmurray 5y ago> In the Japanese case they don't want to imperil the profits from JTI (Japan Tobacco). Nationalizing the tobacco industry is hardly necessary to create a conflict of interest here. In Ireland a pack of cigarettes costs €14, of which €11 goes to the State [0], €1 to the retailer [1], and €2 to the tobacco company (of which a pretty decent €1 is profit [2]). Giving the extra euro to the State wouldn't change incentives that much here, even assuming they could run a business with the efficiency of the current multinational giants in the industry. [0] https://www.irishtimes.com/news/ireland/irish-news/almost-80-of-price-of-packet-of-cigarettes-is-tax-and-excise-duty-donnelly-1.4380161 https://www.irishtimes.com/news/ireland/irish-news/almost-80... [1] https://ash.org.uk/media-and-news/press-releases-media-and-news/ash-research-shows-corner-shops-dont-need-tobacco-to-be-profitable/ https://ash.org.uk/media-and-news/press-releases-media-and-n... (UK figures, should be close) [2] https://csimarket.com/Industry/Industry_Profitability.php?ind=508 https://csimarket.com/Industry/Industry_Profitability.php?in...
- wffurr 5y agoThe article was significantly more nuanced than that. Not only did it discuss a range of solutions, it also went into some detail about the narrow focus on tech as the source of problems, rather than a symptom of broader economic, cultural, and political trends. Which Facebook aids and abets to pad their bottom line, of course, but isn’t solely responsible for the world’s ills.
- NoThisIsMe 5y ago> - You're giving the government (more specifically the party in power at the time) control over a highly effective form of propaganda, which won't have a good outcome. > - The US government would only regulate FB as it relates to US citizens, leaving FB free to operate as now in the rest of the world. The article acknowledges both points and partly addresses the first. Also, it's not clear to me why you'd prefer a private corp wield this power than the government, when the latter is at least ostensibly accountable to citizens/voters and the former is not whatsoever. > - In Japan where a similar addictive product aimed at minors (tobacco) is mostly under public ownership, the Japanese government has dragged its feet at regulation to reduce harm from cigarettes - eg it only banned smoking in bars last year. In the Japanese case they don't want to imperil the profits from JTI (Japan Tobacco). Meanwhile, smoking in bars is still not banned in much of the US...
- m0zg 5y ago> FB free to operate as now in the rest of the world Actually no, it'd be fully subservient to CIA and Five Eyes in general in that case. More so than it is now.