3 ms·
Reunification in this case is as legitimate as speaking of German reunification before 1990 or Korean reunification now. So are the quotation marks because the
by mytailorisrich 5y ago
Reunification in this case is as legitimate as speaking of German reunification before 1990 or Korean reunification now.
So are the quotation marks because they are actually quoting or because of some other reason?...
In this article it seems to me that they do beyond quoting.
- chrisseaton 5y agoWhy are people so suspicious of quotation marks these days? People are always having a go at the BBC for using them as well. It's a quotation, so they've used quotation marks. It's not a mystery.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoIt's healthy suspicion, more than a suspicion, actually when you read this article and others. Of course if it's a direct quotation then quotation marks are appropriate, but then it becomes something else when a term is always between quotation marks throughout the article. For instance: "Peaceful "reunification" best meets the overall interests of the Taiwanese people, but China will protect its sovereignty and unity, he added." Why is 'reunification' quoted there? Since you mention the BBC, I've noticed that they now always write "democratic Taiwan" instead of just "Taiwan"...
- chrisseaton 5y ago> Why is 'reunification' quoted there? Because it's a quotation. Someone other than the journalist said it. The quotation marks let you know that.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoThey are quoting a whole sentence, not a single word yet they put quotation marks around a specific word. This is not neutral at all.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> This is not neutral at all. I think you've got it backwards - the point is to be fastidiously neutral. Some people think it's reunification, some people think it isn't. So instead of taking one side and saying what they think, they just tell you what the relevant person said. They aren't quoting a whole sentence, as it comes from a speech and they want to make it understandable without having to read the whole thing. It's supposed to be simple reporting, not opinion. Especially if you look at the venue - it's a news agency. This is all totally normal, completely above-board, best-practice journalism. I have no idea why people push back against it. Are you possibly confusing quotation marks with scare quotes? That's not what these are. They aren't making a point using the quotation marks. They're trying to not make a point. Just to convey the facts.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoBut they are taking side! Of course some people are against reunification but trying to push the narrative that this is not a matter of reunification really is propaganda and not fact. What I quoted is not neutral journalism. Neutral journalism on this issue is extremely rare. It has become a widespread trick to push a narrative under the cover of being neutral or irrelevant facts. Clever use of quotation marks under the pretext that not everyone agrees, systematic use of 'democratic Taiwan' are 2 examples of subtle and clever bias when it comes to reporting of cross-straight relations. Another one is today's reporting on the BBC for the 10th October (national day of ROC), which was not even subtle. But it's hard for the public who does not know about an issue and trust what they are told. And of course there is one so blind as those who will not see.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> But they are taking side! I don't even know which side you think they're taking! So it can't be that strong a stance can it.
- ithkuil 5y agoIt's not neutral. It means "as they say", as opposed to "as we would say", or "don't get too attached to what you think this word should mean, here we're using the meaning as used by the quoted, and we all know that bit everybody agrees on that". It's a legitimate use of quotations IMO as it clarifies the text, in particular the relationship between the writer (the journalist) and the originator of the message being relayed and interpreted.
- CogitoCogito 5y agoI presume that the BBC is quoting “reunification” to make clear they don’t necessarily agree with the term’s usage, but use it because Xi did. I would do the same since I personally find “annexation through imperialist military conquest” to be much more honest description of the situation.
- hker 5y agoBecause the history of Taiwan is complicated. If you count Taiwan as a part to be unified under CCP rule, then by similar accounts you may as well argue that Iran and Iraq as parts to be unified under CCP rule. From the Wikipedia page on Taiwan [1], check out the Chronological phases on the right, you can see that Taiwan has been ruled by different regimes: * Prehistory to 1624 * Dutch Formosa 1624–1662 * Spanish Formosa 1626–1642 * Kingdom of Tungning 1661–1683 * Qing rule 1683–1895 * Japanese rule 1895–1945 * Republic of China rule 1945–present Among them: - the Kingdom of Tungning was a loyalist to Ming dynasty when Qing dynasty was ruling mainland China, - later Qing dynasty partly ruled Taiwan, - now the Repulic of China is ruling Taiwan when CCP is ruling mainland China. Then one may ask why Taiwan should be a part to be unified under CCP rule, as Xi implies, instead of being ruled by the Republic of China. One argument is that Taiwan has been ruled by regimes associated with Mainland China in the past (loyalist to Ming dynasty after it lost, then partly by Qing dynasty), hence by extension to be ruled by the current ruler of mainland China, CCP. But if you accept this argument, then you may notice that the Mongol empire (Yuan dynasty) once ruled Iran and Iraq and more [2]. If we ignore the past, then we may ask if Taiwan should be ruled by the mainland Chinese regime, CCP, or should be a sovereign country ruled by the Republic of China as the President of Taiwan said [3]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Taiwan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Taiwan [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mongol_Empire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mongol_Empire [3]: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/rest-of-world/taiwan-says-it-is-sovereign-independent-country-as-xi-pledges-reunification/articleshow/86892478.cms https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/rest-of-world/taiw...
- mytailorisrich 5y agoFlooding others with a mass of data is a rhetoric trick. Again, the situation is exactly like Germany and Korea. China is currently split and this is an issue of reunification. Taiwan is part of China and the last territory of the Republic of China, whose government was kicked out of the mainland by the communist. Today is national day in Taiwan and that commemorates the fall of the Empire and the founding of the Republic of China... Now, some people in Taiwan are opposed to reunification because of the current regime on the mainland, some are opposed to reunification full stop and want Taiwan to remain an independent country. That's the factual situation. But calling into question the term 'reunification' is purely propaganda in order to paint the PRC as trying to invade a foreign country like if they wanted to invade Vietnam or another neighbour. From the West's POV this is a standard divide and conquer strategy.