3 ms·
>"The tech giant says that when evaluating content against the new policy, "we’ll look carefully at the context in which claims are made, differentiating betwee
by perihelions 5y ago
>"The tech giant says that when evaluating content against the new policy, "we’ll look carefully at the context in which claims are made, differentiating between content that states a false claim as fact, versus content that reports on or discusses that claim."
This is obviously an unrealistic and impossible moderation task (at Google-scale), and they're plainly lying if they claim they can do that. Clear evidence: YouTube took down a podcast by a member of President Biden's Covid advisory board -- spectacularly failing the use/mention distinction test (about the subject of anti-vaccination sentiment). Their misinformation classifier does not pass the Turing test. Specifically, it can not "differentiate between content that states a false claim as fact, versus content that reports on or discusses that claim".
(Michael Osterholm's Episode 61, "Divided by Delta", if anyone wants to research further. It was reinstated in a few days).
(late edit) Here's a source: https://twitter.com/cidrap/status/1420482621696618496 https://twitter.com/cidrap/status/1420482621696618496
and a bio: https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/about-us/cidrap-staff/michael-t-osterholm-phd-mph https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/about-us/cidrap-staff/michael-t-o...
- Craighead 5y ago"N=1 proves my argument" Gosh why does HN continually fall for this type of absolute drivel.
- darkhorn 5y agoYes, probably they are going to use ML to classify if content has some kind of climate change denial. There could be some persantage that will be evaluatef wrongly by the AI. That is okay, I mean it cannot be perfect. Some Youtubers will loose their channel just becaouse they said somwthing about climate change. At the and everyone will stop talking about climate so that they don't fall under false positeves.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- perihelions 5y agoThe point is they're saying completely different: they claim they look at context, and they claim that they can handle use/mention distinctions. State of the art ML can't do that. They're soliciting buy-in from the general public, with assurances that they know are false.
- true_religion 5y agoThe distinction of context could be drawn via human moderation. I think they will set a flag that states if a channel is news. News channels get to report on questionable material without triggering ML, or at least get a human review at some point. Non-news channels would get regular ML.
- visarga 5y agoIf you sort the channels talking about climate-change by views, then you can manually vet the top few thousands and use ML for the rest. You can also do graph analysis to classify channels based on common viewers, starting with a seed of manually labelled channels and the graph.
- FormerBandmate 5y agoThat sounds like a recipe for ensuring today-small, potentially future major channels never talk about climate change
- angelzen 5y agoGoogle doesn't care to pass the Turing test. Their goal is to suppress any and all discourse skeptical of the official line. A few false positives are not a problem. Even better, the subjects learn that nothing and nobody will pass the censor wall. Don't even think unclean thoughts, are you a mass murderer?
- joelbondurant 5y agoThe USA Fact-Check Algorithm by the Science Ministry is the official arbiter of truth, it alone exactly determines misinformation classification.