3 ms·
>The same $1 in the hands of a minimum wage worker might have different economic value than if it was in the hands of a millionaire because how it is likely to
by imtringued 5y ago
>The same $1 in the hands of a minimum wage worker might have different economic value than if it was in the hands of a millionaire because how it is likely to be used in the economy is different.
It's clearly better off in the hands of the minimum wage worker. It's funny how people deride governments as central planners when companies and their owners are committing that very same central planning at a smaller scale. The only difference is that the government is much bigger and when it isn't then local governments will lick the boots of the CEOs. When people talk about trickle down they are basically advocating for more central planning. 300 million brains aren't good enough, there is no way they could possibly know what they want, instead some rich millionaire or billionaire gets to tell them what they should want.
- WalterBright 5y ago> It's clearly better off in the hands of the minimum wage worker. Why?
- aqme28 5y agoI would argue because the relative utility is higher. A higher percentage change in that person's purchasing power. OP though was arguing that that poorer people will spend it better, which might be true as well since the rich tend to hoard.
- WalterBright 5y ago> the rich tend to hoard Ironically, it's poor people that hoard cash in a can or a mattress, not rich people. Rich people invest it. Even cash in the bank isn't cash in the bank, the bank promptly loans out a multiple of it.
- simonh 5y agoThe $1 is relatively more valuable to the worker than the millionaire, but is it more valuable to the economy? I intuitively suspect so, but I don’t know why and I also suspect intuition could easily lead us astray on this.
- closeparen 5y agoGovernment is just an extreme form of monopoly. All monopolies are bad because they undermine the property of a market, competition, from which all the other good things flow.
- Aerroon 5y ago>It's funny how people deride governments as central planners when companies and their owners are committing that very same central planning at a smaller scale. The only difference is that the government is much bigger and when it isn't then local governments will lick the boots of the CEOs. It's not the only difference. Another important difference is that the central planners aren't spending their own money. The way they get money is through taxes - they use the threat of violence to get people to pay, because government has the (legal) monopoly on violence. You can't opt out from paying either. You're not wrong the large companies have the same central planning problem. One upside though is that people aren't forced to do business with a specific company - they can choose a competitor instead. That's part of why monopolies are a problem. They have the central planning problem and no alternative. The billionaire gets to tell others what to do because he's paying for it. The central planner takes your money and then tells you what to do. If you don't comply you go to prison. Also, the central planning problem does become less of a problem the smaller the scale.