3 ms·
Ok, if you look at individual actions, burning the plastic makes complete sense. But if you look at the economy as an evolving system, you'll discover that if y
by marcosdumay 5y ago
Ok, if you look at individual actions, burning the plastic makes complete sense. But if you look at the economy as an evolving system, you'll discover that if you do nothing together with burning the plastic, society will just adapt to consume the extra oil, while if you bury it, people will probably not make an effort to recover that plastic any soon.
Of course, you can burn the plastic and make some change that makes people burn less oil. But if we are talking about government intervention, you will get much more return if you focus on reducing the fossil fuels usage alone and bury the plastic.
- ars 5y agoSpoken like a true environmentalist: Make things worse for people and for the environment, in the hope we can "someday" make things different. It's exactly this attitude that is causing the trouble.
- marcosdumay 5y agoHum... What? Are you sure you are on the correct thread?
- RealityVoid 5y agoHe is maybe a bit mean, but his point is at least consistent. His whole thesis is that we don't have to reduce energy consumption but just find solutions so that we consume without ruining the enviromnet, or at least find the most impact we can have for reducing the damage right now - at least that is how I read it. And I think that is possibly the only sustainable approach, since it is going to be _very_ hard to convince 7 billion people to give up convenience. It just won't happen.
- marcosdumay 5y agoHum, ok, increasing the price of energy (because you are not burning the cheapest sources) does indeed push people a little bit into using less energy. I understand his point now. Now I have to hardly disagree, because we won't solve that problem without some amount of discomfort. And increasing the price of energy so the non-fossil sources can compete better is how can give up the least of it.
- UnFleshedOne 5y agoDo you expect significant drop in oil price if plastic was getting burned? I'd think it would displace things like coal first...
- marcosdumay 5y agoPlastic comes mostly from natural gas, doesn't it? The "oil" there is just a generalization, as I understand it is on the GGP. Anyway, the production of any of those is almost completely inelastic.