6 ms·
Help Us Find the Apps That Sell Your Location
- kiryin 5y agoIt's truly mindbending that we've arrived at a point where a database like this is necessary. What a sad and horrible existence this is.
- dylan604 5y agoHaving a database like this is useless unless the masses start to care about the subject. There has yet to be a campaign successful enough in educating/convincing the masses into why this is a bad thing. For most, as long as the app allows them to communicate with friends, entertains them (or their kids) with a game, etc, and the app is free the masses just won't care.
- missedthecue 5y agoYou should reflect for a moment about how you are fortunate enough to live in the first generation where this is qualifies for being "sad and horrible".
- nubela 5y agoI really support this. We need clarity on which offending apps are doing this. And it isn't just location data. It's also apps which added a proxy backdoor powering networks like BrightData or OxyLabs. Or Contacts app that sell contact information to companies like Lusha.
- altdataseller 5y agoIs there a way to examine the libraries that an iOS app uses? There might be a way to find apps that use common libraries/frameworks that pass your location to other services, if so.
- Terretta 5y agoExcellent thinking! These are the SDKs to worry about. Next is, who do they ‘phone home’ to? An easy way to find things is with a local proxy or DNS log, as your phone looks up things on behalf of apps. Which things are looked up by more than one app? A few I noticed back in 2019: iOS “User Linking” Trackers [business].app.link [business].onelink.me [hash].ulink.adjust.com [business].bttn.io bnc.lt branch.io Then you can also see who is invoking them coming from the domain tree: - https://securitytrails.com/list/apex_domain/app.link https://securitytrails.com/list/apex_domain/app.link (2962) - https://securitytrails.com/list/apex_domain/onelink.me https://securitytrails.com/list/apex_domain/onelink.me (998) - https://securitytrails.com/list/apex_domain/bttn.io https://securitytrails.com/list/apex_domain/bttn.io (60)
- titzer 5y agoIt is incredible to me that location data harvesting (aka mass dystopian surveillance) is so pervasive that it requires a crowd-sourced investigative campaign. A generation ago it was neither technologically nor socially feasible to get even coarse-grained location data on a person's whereabouts. I hate this future. We sleepwalked into dystopia because money.
- amelius 5y agoAll because of ads. We should just ban all ads. That would solve all of these problems. If people feel they still need ads, we can create a nice sandbox for watching ads.
- sebow 5y ago[dead]
- boplicity 5y ago> We should just ban all ads Please define what an ad is.
- m463 5y agoFolks think advertisements are "showing me something I can buy" But really ads are a huge detailed dossier on every person, being sold so that water filter companies can bid the highest to get a water filter ad in front of the people with the largest income. Meanwhile, you like legos and lego will never be able to bid high enough to show you a lego ad (probably they don't need to anyhow) and the off-label uses for these dossiers... I wonder if used car salesmen can find out your "price insensitivity" and charge accordingly?
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago> Please define what an ad is. I made this comment[0], where I talk about "building buzz." Basically, ads without ads. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28788169 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28788169
- deleted 5y ago
- dotBen 5y agoThe app stores typically tell you what permissions an app requires, including location. It would seem to me to be more efficient to programmatically analyze the permissions listed of the top 10,000 apps (or more) than have readers send in random screenshots.
- anothermoron 5y agoI don't mind app that use my location for stuff which requires it, what this project is meant to do is find who SELLS the information.
- burkaman 5y ago> This will help us understand how these prompts are worded and could help us identify apps that are using your location in ways the app developer does not disclose. They are specifically interested in how the location request is worded for each app, and maybe at what point during usage it asks. I think on Android the prompt is always the same, but apparently on iPhones they can add a short explanation.
- alufers 5y agoYou would get a lot of false positives, meaning apps that legitimately need the location. For example navigation apps or unfortunately apps on Android which use Bluetooth. This really annoys me, because the dialog looks the same for apps that want to use GPS data and apps that use Bluetooth, and there is no way to grant just Bluetooth permissions.
- soco 5y agoAnd what do we do with apps which have a legitimate reason to use your location, then proceed to sale your location history to third parties? No confirmation dialog can save us from that.
- esc861 5y agoYes, and the same goes for information about the WiFi network. Lots of apps for IoT devices require this information to set up products, but the OS presents this as location tracking.
- bruh2 5y agoIf I understood correctly, this kind of database already exists at https://reports.exodus-privacy.eu.org/en/ https://reports.exodus-privacy.eu.org/en/
- monkeydust 5y agothanks for sharing - eye opening (!) - https://reports.exodus-privacy.eu.org/en/reports/56347/ https://reports.exodus-privacy.eu.org/en/reports/56347/ - 10MM downloads and 56 permissions on your phone. Toxic.
- lopis 5y agoThose kind of trendy free apps, like photo filters, sticker makers, etc are usually the worst offenders. I mean, how else do people these companies make money? Android and iOS need to implement network connection permissions per app, but they won't because they both have an incentive against doing that.
- dreyfan 5y agoIt's not just apps, it's the providers themselves. e.g. Sprint sells customer location/app/usage data directly [1]. They don't even try to obscure that fact. > "Leveraging verified, first-party mobile data from more than 32 million mobile users straight off the network" [1] https://www.inmobi.com/company/press/inmobi-acquires-u.s.-based-advertising-and-data-company-pinsight-media/ https://www.inmobi.com/company/press/inmobi-acquires-u.s.-ba...
- e40 5y agoThe only solution to this is legislation. None of the politicians seem to care, I wonder why (follow the money... both sides of the isle are paid off).
- brewdad 5y ago> both sides of the isle are paid off The expression is both sides of the aisle since traditionally each party sits on its own side of the legislative hall. I like this use however since it suggests they are all off on an island separate and distant from the rest of us.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mfrye0 5y agoA friend introduced me to localblox.com a couple years ago to get some company data, though it looks like they have already closed up shop. These guys seemed to have everyone's data. The demo started off by showing me the company data we were interested in, but then veered into picking a random person's life to delve into. The deep dive began by showing work/education info, then went into where they live, the cars they drove, how many kids/pets, then even deeper into the location data... They showed detailed maps of everywhere they went on a daily basis. The routes they took to work, they places the visited, etc. Any of the data was for sale if we wanted it. It was beyond disturbing. We obviously passed on working with them.
- RegW 5y agoThe article seems to make the assumption that this data is collected by apps that would otherwise have no good reason for requiring permission to access your location. Seems like a bit of an assumption. It strikes me that to build a useful location dataset, just one widely used app would be more effective than any number of niche apps asking for strange permissions. I would build an app that provides many people with a really useful service that obviously requires access to your location. So it would probably provide some sort of mapping or navigation service. To consistently collect data it might well force the user to have data enabled rather than just hold the map data on the phone. Perhaps I could also shut others out of this lucrative operation, if I could just get my app pre-installed and enabled by default on every phone. Just speculating - who really knows.