3 ms·
> 25% of the same personality traits Good luck quantifying that without too much snake oil.
by ekianjo 5y ago
> 25% of the same personality traits
Good luck quantifying that without too much snake oil.
- dougSF70 5y agoI think they used the well-established and well-researched personality methodology called OCEAN. This has been well documented as being able to identify the big five traits (OPENNESS, CONSCIENTIOUSNESS, EXTRAVERSION, AGREEABLENESS, NEUROTICISM) and its sub traits. This framework was then used by Aleksandr Kogan to profile and harvest facebook users - who then sold it to Cambridge Analytica..etc. By relying somewhat on self-selection Aleksandr's firm was able to profile facebook users. Since there was no second-guessing by the subject of the test as what a "question might say about them" I think it was pretty robust methodology. And then when you look at the impact of his work, you can see it was effective. Not sure there is any snake oil to be found here.
- anotherman554 5y agoI've taken one of those big 5 tests, it's based on self reported answers to survey questions. While I would not call it snake oil, if self reports are not a reliable method of understanding people, it's fancy nonsense. (Like most psychology, it seems it may or may not be B.S.) I googled the Cambridge thing you mentioned and the first article that came up said it wasn't particularly accurate and was mostly just profiling based on demographics. (Shrug).
- dougSF70 5y agoYes that article, sponsored by Cambridge Analytica, does play it down :)
- anotherman554 5y agoThere's no such article that came up. There's a long tradition of psychologists making grandiose claims that are short on facts. B.F. skinner claimed "Give me a child and I'll shape him into anything." Not sure why you would assume the Cambridge thing did what someone selling it said it could do.
- disgruntledphd2 5y ago> By relying somewhat on self-selection Aleksandr's firm was able to profile facebook users. Since there was no second-guessing by the subject of the test as what a "question might say about them" I think it was pretty robust methodology. Having worked in adtech, and as a psychologist who's attempted to use OCEAN for said adtech, I never found it to work better than standard approaches. Additionally, Costa and McCrae created the Big 5, found it didn't replicate in confirmatory factor analysis, so they created a new method of CFA which did replicate it. Like, E O and N are probably real, but the overall structure does not replicate and should not be taken very seriously.
- ekianjo 5y ago> This has been well documented as being able to identify the big five traits (OPENNESS, CONSCIENTIOUSNESS, EXTRAVERSION, AGREEABLENESS, NEUROTICISM) and its sub traits. It's just a simplified model to put personalities in a certain bucket, typical PCA-style. This has limitations just like everything else that uses self-reporting to make a judgment/categorization. it's not like we are able to observe the structure of someone's brain and confirm that with actual facts. In other words, that's not even remotely what you call Science.
- matthewaveryusa 5y agoSome authors simply don't understand the importance of factual statistics. I see a lot of it in psychology. Your choice as a reader is to close the book, or change your frame of reference with regards to the statistics in the entire book. In this case, the author is probably trying to convey that for a lot of people their personalities will change over the course of 30 years such that at the 20 and 50 year mark a minority of ones personality is still present. Don't get me wrong, I hate fake stats, but at least changing _my_ expectations allows me to enjoy more books without zeroing in on what could be a minor issue in a much larger and interesting point.
- denton-scratch 5y agoIt's hardly surprising that people change over time. What surprises me is the extent to which I have become like my father, as I have aged. When I was 20, I despised my father. I haven't adopted my father's political or social attitudes; but I'm pretty horrified at the extent to which I've become like him in my personal attitudes and dealings.