6 ms·
It makes more sense if you think of the polariser sheets as fences with vertical bars, and light like a string going through between two bars and being wiggled.
by jiggawatts 5y ago
It makes more sense if you think of the polariser sheets as fences with vertical bars, and light like a string going through between two bars and being wiggled.
If the direction of the waves in the string are at right-angles to the slit, the wave can't propagate through the bars.
If the wave is at an angle, then some of the wave gets through, with a maximum of 100% when the wave wiggles up and down in the same direction as the slit.
In this model you can visualise how three 45-degree slits will allow some light to go through even though two 90 degree slits don't -- the light is transformed by its passage through the polarisers.
Where QM people get themselves confused is that they assume that the light is not transformed, even though it clearly is...
I.e.: If the polarisers didn't rotate the angle of the light waves, then successive aligned polarisers would result in very close to 0 light making it through, but this is not what happens. (Excluding losses due to non-polariser-related effects)
All of this goes back to a fundamental confusion between two possibilities:
1) Is it the EM field in free space that is quantised?
OR
2) Is it just the interactions of the EM field with matter that are quantised?
If you actually run the experiments to check which one, it turns out that (2) is true, but most QM people think (1) is true because most of the time they're indistinguishable.
See this video for such an experiment: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SDtAh9IwG-I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SDtAh9IwG-I
- joshuamorton 5y agoIIRC, you can grok this with linear transforms: given X = [[1,0],[0,0]] and Y = [[0,0],[0,1]], aXY = 0 for all a (because XY == [[0,0],[0,0]]). But, given V = [[1,1],[1,1]] (or, in fact, a lot of other matrices/linear transforms), XVT = [[0,1],[0,0]], which blocks all vertical components and rotates the horizontal component 90 degrees. So if you imagine light as a wave with a horizontal and vertical component, and the polarizing filter applies a linear transform to the light.
- amelius 5y agoCan you explain the double slit experiment with this approach?
- jiggawatts 5y agoNot really, the waves in the double slit experiment travel through vacuum (or air), not through a solid like with polariser sheets.
- amelius 5y agoBut they interact with the matter at the boundary of the slit.