11 ms·
Steve Jobs tried to convince Dell to license Mac software
- sys_64738 5y agoVolume PC sales is about margins so you can't pay a fee two multiple OS vendors as that would make Dell be at a competitive disadvantage. Also, isn't Dell the guy who said Apple should be liquidated and funds returned to shareholders in the mid-90s?
- mariodiana 5y agoThe article is too polite to tell the story of how Jobs really used Michael Dell's "sell the company" remark to motivate the troops: https://lilly.tumblr.com/post/11230723028/steve-jobs https://lilly.tumblr.com/post/11230723028/steve-jobs
- drewg123 5y agoIf they could have worked out a deal to license MacOS X in the late 90s, it would have been a real game changer. Its too bad Jobs would not give Dell reasonable terms.
- elromulous 5y agonit: did macos x even exist in the 90s? Or did you mean macos 9?
- techrat 5y agoMacOSX was released in 2001, so it would have had to have been System 7/8/9 by that point.
- jandrese 5y agoWork porting System 7/8/9 to Intel would have been completely wasted.
- flenserboy 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Trek_project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Trek_project
- jandrese 5y agoIt might have been worth it in 1992. By 1998 there was no point. That is a really interesting what-if scenario, but I don't think the mid-90s Apple corporate management would have been willing to go through with it. At the very least they would have tried to lock it down to Apple designed Intel hardware, they've never been able to let go of being a hardware company.
- jbverschoor 5y agoIf that's the case, that would be fun. Give Dell an outdated OS, and launch a brand new OS yourself
- Synaesthesia 5y agoI think at that stage it was still NextStep morphing into Rhapsody/OS X
- wtallis 5y agoMac OS X was a work in progress during the late 90s. The Apple/NeXT merger was in 1996, there were developer releases of Rhapsody (with x86 support) in 1997 and 1998, and Mac OS X Server 1.0 was released in 1999. But the first public beta of Mac OS X with the Aqua UI was in 2000, and OS X version 10.0 was in 2001. So any deal negotiated in the late 90s to bring Mac OS X to Intel PCs would have taken a few years to come to fruition, but Apple did have a usable x86 operating system to base negotiations on in the late 90s.
- throwawayboise 5y agoOPENSTEP was running on x86 even before the merger. The work would have been mostly to make it look and feel more like what Mac OS users were familiar with, and adding the ability to run "Classic" Mac OS applications.
- wtallis 5y agoTrue, but OPENSTEP on its own would not have been of much interest to Dell given the very small software ecosystem. The promise of also inheriting the Mac application ecosystem made Mac OS X far more marketable.
- thewileyone 5y agoI used to work on OpenStep and it was nothing like the previous version of MacOS; I used to work on MacOS before OpenStep.
- guessbest 5y agoMac OSX Server wasn't very popular. I'm guessing since Dell made very respectable servers in the 90's this was an effort to put a kind of NeXT server on Dell hardware, or at least an early version of Mac OSX Server.
- raman162 5y agoJobs was pretty bold asking Dell for a royalty of every Dell PC sold. I'm curious what a world like that would have looked like, where you can choose between OS X and Windows when purchasing a computer.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mistrial9 5y agoyou mean exactly as M$ft did ?!? "bold" ?! do-tell
- tombert 5y agoI'm not exactly a huge fan of MS, but at least when MS basically got a royalty for every Dell sold, there was a reasonable certainty that a vast majority of them were going to actually use Windows. It was the only OS pre-installed, meaning that unless the person was a geek (like basically anyone who hangs around HN), they were probably going to use Windows. If there were two operating systems installed, there's a good chance that a majority of people would still only use Windows, and Dell would be paying a license to Apple that only 10% of their customers actually used.
- nodejs_rulez_1 5y agoLet's not pretend that a sizable bunch of devs did not install Win 10 on their Intel macbooks. Apple was quite good at hardware at the time.
- fomine3 5y agoYou say Win7 or Win8?
- toast0 5y agoThose were tremendously bad terms, especially given what happened with the licensed Mac clone program which was ended, apparently shortly after these discussions with Dell.
- skrebbel 5y agoIirc he tried the same with Sony VAIOs around that time.
- wil421 5y agoSony VAIOs were the MacBook pro’s of their day. I har a couple of them and so did my brother. All were very nice computers even with the garbage OS that was Windows Vista. They had some cool models in the 2000s. https://www.theverge.com/2014/2/6/5385716/sony-vaio-iconic-pcs-photo-essay https://www.theverge.com/2014/2/6/5385716/sony-vaio-iconic-p...
- Austin_Conlon 5y agoIn a number of his keynotes he regarded Sony products as the industry standard for quality.
- wil421 5y agoYup and Sony had the pebble keyboards first!
- tylerscott 5y agoVAIO were a solid computers (at least my memory of them). I would have killed to have Vista on my VAIO. I had Windows ME on it! Despite that fact, it still sits among my most beloved computers that I have owned. It was also the first that I had purchased new whereas all the previous ones were hand-me-downs. Thanks for the trip down memory lane!
- wil421 5y agoLove my VAIOs if I had put an SSD in my last one I probably wouldn’t have bought a Mac until much later.
- mmmmmbop 5y agoIn a testament to how powerful product placement can really be, the image of James Bond using a VAIO laptop while sitting on a boat is still burned in my brain.
- tombert 5y agoIt's interesting to envision the what-if universe where licensing OS X (and other software) became Apple's main business model. I wonder if in this universe, Apple is basically the Google of our time (everything is a cloud service, massive ad tracking, using metadata as their revenue generation), or if they would be more like the MS of our time (playing a game of catch-up with Google). While I don't really blame Dell for not taking this deal (it seemed like a pretty raw deal for Dell), I wonder how much more popular Unix would be nowadays had this gone through. OS X was (and is) almost certainly the largest desktop *nix distro out there, and if it were installed on every Dell computer (and presumably later other manufacturers as well), I wonder if Unix might have become the "standard" for desktop OS's.
- bityard 5y ago> I wonder if Unix might have become the "standard" for desktop OS's Microsoft is pouring buckets of money and human capital into WSL2. Today, it's their way to drag cloud developers away from the Mac and Linux ecosystems into the corporate-blessed Windows ecosystem. But tomorrow, maybe developers and server admins will demand more Linux compatibility and, who knows, maybe they will reach a point where the only way to improve performance is to "port" Windows services and applications to the Linux kernel. The open source community has already proven that much of it can be done via Wine. One of those things that doesn't look terribly likely now but might prove obvious in retrospect.
- qbasic_forever 5y agoAre they really, is there anything to back up the claim WSL2 is a huge team internally? Because the way I see it WSL1 was much more novel and likely required a dedicated team to manage the kernel API to windows API shim layer, but now with WSL2 it's just a gussied up hyper V integration.
- sz4kerto 5y agoProbably not a huge team, but I guess the number of people involved has easily 3 digits, as MS needs to pay the developers, marketing people, manage the releases through Windows Updates, collect feedback, check compatibility etc. At the scale of MS a "major" Windows feature can't be cheap, even if it looks simple. Seriously, look at how difficult it is for them to port the old style control center or improve notepad.exe.
- baybal2 5y agoHe tried to pitch to Sony as well
- ridruejo 5y agoI'm half way through the book and found it quite good if you are interested in strategy, private equity because it talks about relatively recent events. There's also a recent a16z podcast with Dell, Martin Casado and Andreessen that I enjoyed https://future.a16z.com/podcasts/cloud-wars-company-wars-play-nice-but-win-michael-dell-book/ https://future.a16z.com/podcasts/cloud-wars-company-wars-pla...
- yelnatz 5y agoMichael Dell went on John Calacanis' podcast last week too, discussing the book. It was a pretty good listen. Jobs wanted a cut on every PC sold if the deal went through. That was too much for Dell since they were selling so much PCs already, so it fell through. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/googles-game-changing-ad-policy-michael-dell-on-play/id315114957?i=1000537030941&itsct=podcast_box_link&itscg=30200&ls=1 https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/googles-game-changing-...
- vondur 5y agoI believe one of the founders of PowerComputing (one of the original Mac Clone Makers) was an ex-executive from Dell. PowerComputing was really putting the hurt on Apple's sales of computers for a while.
- dingosity 5y agoRandom factoid since we're talking about PowerComputing. Back in the day, you could run MacOS on an IBM RS/6000-43P (I think it was the only RS/6000 with MacOS drivers) and you could run AIX on the Apple Network Server machines (which were the only macs with AIX drivers.) But since other people in this thread are talking about other Unixes, it's fun to think of what would happen if IBM and Apple continued the AIX / Mac experiments.
- hardwaregeek 5y agoI can't see that working very well. Dell computers are profoundly ugly. Mac OS X was a decent operating system but it would have hurt the Mac brand to have it running on the dull gray boxes that are Dell computers. Just seems like a last ditch strategy to get some revenue for Apple.
- nekoashide 5y agoYou're looking back with all the knowledge and information today, the NeXT computer was for all it's glory just a black box. At the time Apple did not have anything like what you see now, that didn't come until the 1998 iMac and only because of Ive. Steve Jobs would have literally done anything to save Apple, you only need to watch the 1997 Macworld Expo to see how far he was willing to go. Those people absolutely hated Gates and you can guarantee you would have seen Michael Dell on that stage if it had gone the other way. With that said Mac Clones were a thing, Jobs even tried to keep those deals going but they did not make sense at the time. Apple for all its worth was both a hardware and software company and the clone makers would have been competition anyways.
- throwawayboise 5y agoYes the NeXT was a black box but it was visually striking. Nothing else looked like it. It appeared to be from the future. But you're right at the time Macs were just beige boxes, and pretty dull looking.
- lizknope 5y agoThe NeXT Cube and Slab were some of the prettiest black boxes I have seen.
- hardwaregeek 5y agoI think we're in agreement. I'm saying that this was a last ditch effort to save Apple, but it wouldn't have scaled beyond a few years of runway. Jobs likely understood that a long term OEM deal would have hurt Apple's brand, but would also stop the bleeding short term.
- 5y ago
- NetBeck 5y agoJobs still reached an audience through iTunes. It paved the way for the iPhone to be untouched by carriers. Verizon rejected the first iPhone, but Cingular agreed to Apple's terms.[0] [0] https://usatoday30.usatoday.com/tech/news/2007-01-28-verizon-iphone_x.htm https://usatoday30.usatoday.com/tech/news/2007-01-28-verizon...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thought_alarm 5y agoThis would have been a re-badged version of OpenStep, then named Rhapsody, well before OS X roadmap was plotted out, let alone released. NextStep/OpenStep had support for x86 since 1994, so it was all ready to go if Dell wanted to play ball. But it wouldn't have included any support for Classic Mac software. In other words, it wouldn't have supported any software at all, except for the few OpenStep devs still hanging on. But perhaps it would have been a good way to help kick-start OpenStep development. Apple's original plan was to ship OpenStep as the next generation Mac OS, while running classic Mac OS software in a VM. This OS was eventually released as Mac OS X Server in 1999 But this plan was hugely unpopular in the Mac community. Microsoft and Adobe told Apple that there was no way they would port Office and Photoshop to OpenStep, and that killed the original plan. This forced Apple to go back and tightly merge classic Mac OS and OpenStep, with the Carbon APIs and a ported version of the classic Mac Finder. And thus, Mac OS X was conceived. Three years later it was released. Two years after that, it was good enough to use. Two years after that, it was running circles around an aged Windows XP.
- leoc 5y agohttps://arstechnica.com/staff/2008/04/rhapsody-and-blues/ https://arstechnica.com/staff/2008/04/rhapsody-and-blues/ is a fairly good article covering the attempty to woo Adobe and MS.
- vagrantJin 5y ago> Two years after that, it was running circles around an aged Windows XP One could argue that XP is still running. Quietly plodding away unseen on some pretty critical systems. I'm sure that counts for something, no?
- protomyth 5y agoIt would have been interesting if it ended up like Microsoft today that sells their own hardware (e.g. Surface) and licenses out the OS. I just cannot see Apple giving up hardware of their own at any point. I doubt whatever went on with OS X would have transferred to the iPhone or iPods before it. Truthfully, it would certainly relieve a lot of pressure on Apple surrounding the Pro models. There are certain models that Apple always look like its reluctant to build and the Mac Pro has been that model. It would also have made the virtualization story a bit better.
- ggm 5y agoI don't think it would have worked. Jobs had fixed views about hardware Dell was never going to align to. And, Jobs would have wanted serious rent (IPR) for designs put into Dell. And, the tension between Apple-hw and Dell-hw would have torn them apart. iphone and ipad basically work because they're owned. There could have been a port out to Samsung native OLED tablets any time. The lesson was learned early: don't bother forming alliances which leave "their" name on the box.
- orionblastar 5y agoWhen the Mac came out, Microsoft wanted to license the OS and convert it to PCs. Apple said no.