4 ms·
Is this part of the google monrepo? Not that it matters, but I wondered how far monrepo went, inside the tent. I hate to be a pessimist, and I may be simply ig
by ggm 5y ago
Is this part of the google monrepo? Not that it matters, but I wondered how far monrepo went, inside the tent.
I hate to be a pessimist, and I may be simply ignorant of some realities, but it FEELS like this is setting an impossibly high goal. I think there will turn out to be something significant in 9000 variances, which cannot simply be uplifted into mainstream, and which turn out to be hard to maintain as a continual rebase into the emerging mainstream.
I agree that 40 sounds low, but probably is a good indication it can work. 1% is within view, if they maintained pace so even on a 1% if the rebase cost can be handled, they can converge but that assumes there isn't a showbuster in the 9000.
- xyzzyz 5y agoFrom what I remember, prodkernel actually was outside google3 (the monorepo), and has been sitting in a git repository.
- anonygler 5y agoBuilds are all derived from the monorepo, but git makes sense for development as they have to constantly merge upstream git commits.
- mvgoogler 5y agoProdkernel is not in the monorepo - it's in a separate git repo and uses it's own systems for building and qualifying new releases. There is a system for using git* in conjunction with the monorepo that some developers use, but that system has nothing to do with the prodkernel. * there is also a similar system for using mecurial with the monorepo that some folks love.
- drewg123 5y agoNo. At least when I was there, the linux kernel was in git, and reviews were done in Gerrit. The monorepo (google3) and its review tools were used for most other projects.
- chrisseaton 5y agoWhat does the 3 mean? Are there three big monorepos?
- easton 5y agoAs I understand it (not working at Google) it's the third monorepo they've had.
- kevincox 5y agoIt's more the third build system. IIRC google1 (I can't remember the actual directory name, maybe //google/) used Makefiles and Makefile generators. IIRC there is a small amount of still-live code here. google2 failed fairly quickly. google3 is blaze/bazel and is where almost all development is today. All three trees are actually in the same source control "depot". If you read enough of their papers this is actually detailed there but spread across different papers.