10 ms·
Flickr is dead
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Tichy 15y agoNot that I have high hopes for Flickr, but sampling the trends going on a walk with Google employees is probably a bit biased. As for Flickr: isn't it strange how the products with the worst user interfaces always seem to become the most popular? Same with Facebook.
- wgx 15y agoOr: they become popular despite, and then they're too scared to improve the UI for fear of change?
- macdonald 15y agoI don't agree with the interface comment. Facebook became popular in part because it had a much cleaner, more usable, interface than MySpace. I think the same is true of Flickr, though I'm not a heavy user. It's probably true that other, newer companies have created better interfaces since then, but I'd argue that they became popular because their interfaces were superior at the time.
- masklinn 15y ago> I think the same is true of Flickr, though I'm not a heavy user. Might have been true in the past, but I'll be damned if I don't just insta-close any flickr link I click by mistake these days. I just want to see a picture and half the time I get these two dots swirling around for what seems like half an hour, until it leads me to a half-broken interface with a tiny dot of a picture. Not worth it.
- ugh 15y agoBoth Flickr and Facebook had awesome interfaces when they first became popular. They just didn’t change enough or went in the wrong direction afterwards.
- tmcw 15y agoMuch the same with Google Plus. It takes serious effort for growth and the infinite strength of 'user needs' not to clobber a good interface with lots of cruft that most users don't want.
- Maro 15y agoI think the Flickr UX is pretty good, but I've only been a user for a couple of months. So maybe the problem is that the Flickr UX can't grow with the user/photographer?
- buster 15y agoI don't know what the article is about, since the website seems to be down, but i found Google+ to be an awesome photo community.
- spjwebster 15y agoI knew I'd heard that name before: > Flickr will be here long after you are and its cultural significance to our world will outlast your quarter to quarter financial results. http://www.businessinsider.com/an-open-letter-to-carol-bartz-2010-12 http://www.businessinsider.com/an-open-letter-to-carol-bartz...
- EwanToo 15y agoThe short version of the article is that Flickr hasn't changed in years, no one at Yahoo seems interested in it, the community is drifting away, and they're heading towards Google+. I think this is pretty much true, though I'm not sure Google+ will really be where everyone will end up - it certainly lacks a lot of things (like shared circles for example), and whether Google will support those communities by creating the features they want is really up in the air right now.
- hackermom 15y agoAfter 10 minutes his website finally loaded and I got a chance to read his blog entry. What he backs his claim up with in the end is that a lot of his photographer friends, some of which work for Google, talk about Google+ instead of Flickr, and that there's a tipping point situation happening because the 10% that represent the "best" Flickr contributors are moving to Google+.
- hopeless 15y agoHere are a few things that have killed Flickr for myself and 80% of my photographer friends: - Poor quality of work (or, rather, the good photography is buried under mounds of dross). 500px has the advantage of being new, and limits monthly uploads, so the quality there is surprisingly high - Vacuous comments. "Nice capture!". "Great shot!". This is only made worse when looking at the horror-movie-esque overdone-HDR monstrosity. - Group and all flashing badge icons in comments - woeful mobile interface which is slow and eventually displays a non-zoomable postage stamp sized image. I cringe whenever I see a Flickr link on twitter In short, Flickr might still be a place for photographs but not for photographers. Actually, I think photoblogs or 500px combined with twitter provide a great way of showing off your photos and getting great feedback from people you respect.
- potatolicious 15y agoThe whole photo-sharing space is ripe for a massive disruptor. Photographers and enthusiasts have been drifting away from Flickr for ages, but up until now there's been no offering that's really a suitable full replacement. On the one side you have sites like SmugMug, which has an awesome API, detailed controls over your images... but is devoid of any of the social features Flickr users have grown to love (and loathe sometimes - YOUR PHOTO HAS BEEN INVITED TO [INANE GROUP HERE!]). Or you have beautifully designed sites like 500px... which also has no API and forces its users to operate the whole thing painfully in manual. But it does have really good discoverability features, maybe better than Flickr. I'm not confident that Facebook and Google+ will take over the photography enthusiasts' world. I believe that most regular people will share their pictures there (and they already do, on Facebook), but the photography community won't jump on board until there are some very significant leaps (solid API, discoverability features, more niche-specific social features). But in any case, Flickr is feeling old and creaky, we're all just waiting for something better to come along. Honestly, I'm surprised it's taken this long.
- vijayr 15y agoThank you for mentioning 500px. I didn't know of it, just checked it out, it has some incredible photos.
- eyko 15y agoWow I didn't know about 500px. Thanks for mentioning it, hope they release an API…
- ashconnor 15y agoFlickr is beyond irritating at times. I uploaded duplicate photos by mistake on Flickr and had to go through hundreds of photos one by one deleting them. There's no option to delete duplicates based on file name or file name/creation date etc. because Flickr has basically been dormant from a development standpoint for years.
- xuki 15y agoYour need is very unique and it's something you only do once in a while. And yes, you can delete all the photo at the same time using organizer, or you can use the API to write your own delete method.
- Terretta 15y agoExcept that this gentleman has previously complained about Flickr censorship, yet completely ignores that Google+ is far more restrictive and has already been accused of pulling people's photos (e.g. Lego cleavage[1]) and pulling non "real name" accounts. I don't think he's thought this through. 1. http://www.networkworld.com/community/blog/did-google-ban-cleavage-snuggling-lego-stormt http://www.networkworld.com/community/blog/did-google-ban-cl...
- ja27 15y agoFlickr has had and continues to have plenty of problems over arbitrarily deleting accounts.
- abava 15y agosite about "dead" Flickr is dead :-)
- ShardPhoenix 15y agoMaybe it's just because I'm not a photographer, but I'm surprised that something like photo sharing can generate this much passion.
- keithpeter 15y agoWait till they start discussing quick release mechanisms for tripod heads. You haven't seen anything yet.
- tripzilch 15y agohttp://www.downforeveryoneorjustme.com/flickr.com http://www.downforeveryoneorjustme.com/flickr.com I think it's just you. Stupid sensationalist headline.
- zobzu 15y agothomashawk.com/2011/08/flickr-is-dead.html Connection timed out Must have been hosted by flickr then.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoTry http://thomashawk.com.nyud.net/2011/08/flickr-is-dead.html http://thomashawk.com.nyud.net/2011/08/flickr-is-dead.html
- acangiano 15y agoI'm surprised he hasn't disclosed it himself, but it's worth noting that the author has tried his own hand at this problem with the site Zooomr.com. Things didn't work out though and the site never took over Flickr.
- vbone 15y agoExactly, I am at a loss to explain why so many people continue to fanboy this blowhard. He has expressed on multiple occasions his dissatisfaction but fail to disclose his conflict of interest as well as the fact that if he really really hates the service so much he can take it elsewhere or try to start his own (oh wait, that didnt work out).
- brlewis 15y agoZooomr is no longer a conflict of interest since he no longer works there. Zooomr has been closed to new registrations for ~2 years. He has never stopped using Flickr, and still thought Flickr was great when he went to Zooomr: http://thomashawk.com/2006/06/why-im-going-to-work-for-zooomr.html http://thomashawk.com/2006/06/why-im-going-to-work-for-zooom...
- mkr-hn 15y agoTrying, even if he failed, puts him in a better position to criticize than an average armchair pundit.
- raganwald 15y agoBe careful not to accidentally commit a Circumstantial Ad Hominem. His so-called conflict of interest has no bearing on whether his argument is cogent. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2868269 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2868269 ;-)
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Maro 15y agoHis site could have failed for a number reasons, such as lack of funding, lack of viral growth (if it was social), or whatever. I think you should be careful not to pick on someone because their startup/project failed. Especially here on HN, where we're supposed to embrace failure.
- ANH 15y agoOne thing Flickr has going for it is photos aren't so closely tied to a user's identity. I'm a bit of a photography buff, a Flickr Pro user for years, and I'm not sure I want my photographs to be in the same place where I update friends and acquaintances about my status. It's an entirely different thing to me. The article has it right, though, about Flickr's lack of updates. The most recent major change I've noticed was a year or two ago and, IMHO, it made the site worse.
- Tomek_ 15y agoRecent major change was the photo page redesign done this year no? (or was it last year?), and that redesign is good. About the 1st point: totally agree. I use flickr to look for a good pictures and from time to time to post some of mine that are reasonably OK - for me it's not, and never has been, a site to post photos from last night's bash or socialize with people, that's what Facebook is for (and maybe G+ will be someday in the future (but it won't come easy for them)). I also don't need the site to change every 6 months - if it works OK (and flickr works OK for me) then changing it is not really necessary (or at least, not that important).
- bane 15y ago"I'm a bit of a photography buff, a Flickr Pro user for years, and I'm not sure I want my photographs to be in the same place where I update friends and acquaintances about my status. It's an entirely different thing to me." Absolutely agree. I'm a hobbyist travel photographer, so I end up with essentially two kinds of photos: photos of a place, where I try and form a nice composition, post process (crop, colors, balance, etc.) and then carefully catalog on flickr (for the former, I might take 20,000 photos during a week, and end up with a couple dozen really choice ones I want to keep in this way), and cheesy photos of me and my family at these places, mostly goofing off with statues or whatever. The semantics of the two kinds of photos couldn't be different. So I use FB and G+ for the latter, and flickr most definitely for my carefully curated former.
- brlewis 15y agoGoogle+ makes it easy to share some items with some circles, and other items with other circles.
- tricolon 15y agoNo photographer will take Google+ seriously as long as uploading an artistic nude could result in your entire Google account being disabled.
- ja27 15y agoFlickr will close your account over a single photo not having the appropriate safety level setting and plenty of photographers take it seriously.
- Maro 15y agoI'm a weekend photographer and I recently became a paying Flickr user. For my simple use-case of uploading files and sending off the URL to a couple of friends per email Flickr is the perfect service.
- lurker19 15y agoWhy not use free PicasaWeb for this? $5 gets you bbasically unlimited storage. The only answer I can say myself is that PicasaWeb uses the ugliest possible lossy compression settings on all photos it displays.
- Maro 15y agoPicasa is all integrated with the other Google services (which I'm a heavy user of), but in the case of Picasa it results in a messy UX for me. Eg. I just went to picasaweb.google.com to check out whether it's $5/mo or $5/year, and what is shows me is a bunch of pictures from my G+ stream, but the whole UX is confusing. It doesn't even have a front page (like flickr.com). Where do I find pricing? It seems to me that Flickr is better at the whole "do one thing and do it well" paradigm and it results in a much smoother UX compared to the integrated G+ mess. EDIT: There's a tiny "Upgrade your storage" link at the bottom, pricing is $5/yr for 20GB.
- RexRollman 15y agoYahoo, which once held great promise, seems to have become the company that buys things and fails with them. Some examples off the top of my head: Konfabulator (Yahoo Widgets), Geocites, Delicious, Flickr, Broadcast.com. Heck, they don't even provide their own search results anymore. Can anyone think of something that Yahoo has bought that has flourished under them?
- lurker19 15y agoThat's their business model. Yahoo is a media slaughterhouse, not a farm.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- drgath 15y agoFWIW, Konfabulator (now Y! ConnectedTV) is on 8 million TVs and growing. Pairing that with their recent IntoNow acquisitions, if those are to be integrated (rumored) then it could be a very unique and exciting product.
- olefoo 15y agoThomas Hawk has a long history of enthusiasm and rage; if his normal pattern holds expect to see him lambasting Google for not adding his pet (absolutely essential) feature in six months or so. This latest enthusiasm has me puzzled though. I mean Google+ looks like it's great for sharing photos of limited interest that aren't necessarily public. But it doesn't strike me as a good place to present your art to the world. I'm surprised that no one is selling turnkey photosharing sites that work off an Amazon backend and that operators can skin with their own branding and mix and match galleries and slideshow Javascript, and other features.
- vbone 15y agoThe more telling thing is that Thomas Hawk isn't even his real legal name (Google it) so is in BLATANT violation of the Google+ real name policy. Feel free to report it. I personally don't see why he should get a free pass on this.
- olefoo 15y agoI wouldn't report it because I try not to be an utter prat, on the internet or IRL. But it is a telling instance of Google's hypocrisy on the issue of pseudonymity.
- lurker19 15y agoI think you are describing SmugMug at the end there.
- EwanToo 15y agoHave a look at Openphoto, it's an open source (kickstarter funded) option to do exactly what you're talking about http://theopenphotoproject.org/ http://theopenphotoproject.org/
- martingordon 15y agoFlickr may or may not be dead, but Google+ isn't going to replace it. The great thing about Flickr is the discovery. Flickr has a ton of tools that help you find other photographers (explore, tags, groups) and Google+ has none of these. Whereas Flickr enables and encourages users to seek out new contacts, it seems to me that the purpose of Google+ is to better facilitate communication between existing contacts. He doesn't mention this in the post, but does anyone know how was the photo walk organized?
- filmgirlcw 15y agoExactly. Now, this isn't to say that Google couldn't create new solutions to some of these problems, but I get the sense that at its core, Google+ isn't going to be about discoverability per se, but about, as you say, connect with people you already know. Flickr's search is actually quite robust and amazing. I frequently use the Creative Commons archives for my work as a writer. It's a fantastic resource. Flickr might be dying, dead or stagnant, but I don't think that its replacement will be a slightly rehashed Picasa. Instead, I'm guessing it will be some sort of new network design that is able to surface photos from multiple sites and accounts and identities.
- jsavimbi 15y agoIn short, Mr. Hawk is pointing out that Flickr is no longer dedicating resources to untangle a PHP codebase that has taken on a life of its own after seven or eight years whereas Google+ is embracing photo-sharing as an integral part of its new offering. Proof to that is that I have Brian Rose in my circles right from the beginning and I had no clue who he was. A photo-walk with the Facebook team? Can anyone even tell me who's on the Facebook photo team? Flickr? Flickr will not be rebuilt nor will it be offering incremental feature upgrades of any importance going forward. I'd be surprised if they actually had a dedicated development team versus a group of maintenance developers. The managers are there to make sure I pay for my Pro account once a year and report back to the board that the money is still rolling in. Google+ pictures to help you share, discover and reinforce social relationships, Flickr to store and organize your crap. OMG does 500px suck. It's Flickr with a new theme and Stumbleupon integration.
- Hisoka 15y agoIsn't there a chicken and egg problem for new entrants? There's not a lot of photos to discover if you're building something brand new.
- ChrisArchitect 15y agoa bit heavy on the google influence in the article.... I don't feel like G+ is at all geared to photographers. Flickr has tons of features/tools that seem natural to many but are key to managing photos, making sets, organizing etc. The meta data alone you can associate with flickr photos is incredible. G+ can make a photo set in the same way Facebook can, not really same target/point.
- whazzmaster 15y agoI was thinking the same thing re: google influence. Also, was it any wonder that at a photowalk attended by a ton of Google people, Google+ would be talked about more than Flickr? He makes some good points about the interface stagnation and community excitement (even my own Flickr account has grown weedy and sparse over the years.) However, it was off-putting to see so much, I don't know, what seemed like personal vitriol next to evaluations of the service itself.
- gchucky 15y agoSensationalist title aside, I think Google+ and Flickr fill two different niches: the former is for the social sharing of images, whereas Flickr appeals more to a professional/enthusiast group. One thing is that Flickr puts control of image copyrights into the user's hand, whereas G+ doesn't really have that at all. To that end, someone looking to protect their images would seem to prefer Flickr, I should think.
- nhangen 15y agoTLDR; Google+ has infinite scrolling, and Flickr does not, therefore Flickr is passe and not supported by developers or the photo sharing community.
- ajays 15y agoThomas Hawk is a well-known Flickr hater. He keeps bashing Flickr at every chance he gets. And then he continues to use Flickr. I've been reading his "Flickr is dead" and "I hate Flickr" rants for years and years. He tried to start a competing service, but it failed miserably; so he continues to bash Flickr instead. Dude: if you don't like Flickr, don't use it. Plain and simple. And if you think you can build a better product, go ahead and build it. The world would be a much better place with fewer whiners and more doers.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- 9999 15y agoWhen he noted that he had been banned from their help forum a lot of alarm bells went off for me.
- drgath 15y agoWell, considering he trolls the blogosphere with a new "Flickr is Dead"-type post every month, I can't imagine he was very helpful within the help forums and was doing more harm than good.
- Terretta 15y agoHe has 60,000 photos on Flickr, and 198 on Google+. Some of his Flickr photos are against G+ ToS.
- ja27 15y agoI'm not going to argue that Flickr isn't dying, but they do have some things that Google+ and Facebook don't have: groups. A lot of groups are a waste, but some well-administered groups are awesome, both for the group photo pools and discussions. The Strobist group is one example: http://www.flickr.com/groups/strobist/ http://www.flickr.com/groups/strobist/
- Jun8 15y agoOne thing I always thought that Flickr lacked was an integrated, easy way to buy photos. I don't want to contact the photographer and wait for a reply, when I need a photo for a slide, I want to be able to buy it instantly. At this point Flickr seems like a site that just survives by inertia, nothing new seems to be done, they have pretty much accepted defeat, I guess.
- Terretta 15y agoIt has this. The photographer needs to enable it.
- pkulak 15y agoGoogle+ finally made me move from Flickr. The integration between Google+ and Picasa is really well done. Now I can upload HD video longer than a minute and a half. I can easily share content with exactly who I want to (without them needing an account anywhere). Before I had to upload family photos to Flickr (world-public, of course, or no one was going to be able to figure out how to see them) then email the album around or post it on Facebook. Now it's all in once place and way easier.
- cek 15y agoIf Google really wanted to make this true, they'd add "Import from Flickr" to the G+ Photo Upload page.
- acabal 15y agoI could never understand the appeal of Flickr. I've always found the UI to be extremely confusing and close to unusable. Way back in the day I used to post my travel photos there, mainly because back then there weren't that many alternatives. None of my family could figure out how to use the site to view my albums either. Thank God we have a competitive market for this sort of stuff now so that I haven't had a reason to visit Flickr in years.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoFlickr hasn't much changed their business model or their service offering in a long time, meanwhile online storage costs have dropped through the floor and competitors have been innovating like crazy. There isn't quite a "flickr killer" out there just yet for flickr's key users (avid and professional photographers), but it's getting closer and closer.
- xbryanx 15y agoFlickr is an amazing resource for sharing and using Creative Commons licensed photos. We use it extensively in creating museum exhibits. I hope that Google+ makes it easy to search and share photos with Creative Commons licenses.
- alrs 15y agoInfinite scrolling makes me nauseous. I literally feel sick to my stomach when the bottom of the page is always yanked out of my grasp, Sisyphus-style.
- bad_user 15y agoThe problem with Facebook and now Google+ is that these are not specifically designed for sharing photos. Facebook gets more photos uploaded than Flickr can ever dream of, but they are family pictures or pictures of drunken teenagers, of poor quality in general. If you want to see art, Flickr is a wonderful place to discover amateurs with talent and there's nothing out there that can beat it. Also, I think a photo-sharing service has to have good tools for exploring said pictures. On Flickr, even if it has many flaws, it is really cool to search for pictures with a high interestingness score and then to start following the people that took them. I found some breathtaking works of art that way. On Facebook and G+ you have to rely on your friends-feed instead for discovery, but that's not how art is supposed to be discovered. Flickr, for all its flaws, works for its intended purpose and can only be killed by another web service that is created explicitly for photo-sharing. Google is in a position to do that however, but with Picasa Web and not Google+, although integration would be nice.