5 ms·
Why civilization is in decline – and what can turn it around
- an_ko 5y agoSaving you a click: No solutions are presented; it's just a list of obvious problems, and "maybe it will sort itself out somehow". Followed and preceded by a pitch for the interviewee's new book, of course.
- dredmorbius 5y agoSometimes advocating for problem awareness is useful in itself, especially when the loudest and most influential voices are incessently proclaiming "no fire!" in the burning theatre. As is pointing out evidence, etiology, and some proposed goals and/or redress modalities which do not in fact appear to be working. https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/2fsr0g/hierarchy_of_failures_in_problem_resolution/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/2fsr0g/hierarc...
- an_ko 5y agoI agree. My complaint was that the title is clickbait. It promises a solution ("and what can turn it around"), which the content doesn't deliver.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThat's a gripe with the CBC / Ideas, not Potter. Listening to the full interview (the webpage text is a very condensed version) makes quite clear that Potter himself really doesn't have any facile answers. Or possibly any at all.
- simonh 5y agoA book like this will sell very well to the contingent that always thinks everything's going downhill. People have been saying the same at every single point all the way through the remarkable advances over the last few centuries. Running out of steam, as in a slowdown in the growth curve on various metrics is not the same as a decline. It's simply unrealistic to expect technology and engineering to advance as fast as they did in the mid-20th Century indefinitely. We've exhausted a lot of the low hanging fruit on the science and technology trees, but there are still plenty of fruit to pick, we just need to put more work into reaching them. On the political side, again political division and policy confusion are nothing new. The scientific and technical response to the Pandemic are a resounding validation of our capabilities and the strength of our institutions, even given the many frankly inevitable policy missteps. The big one is climate change. That's a huge problem that's a real test of our capabilities and resolve, but the main obstacles are actually political. We do have the technical capability to bend the curve on climate change and soften the blow quite a bit. Hand wringing isn't going to help, in fact it emboldens those who for various reasons don't want to do anything about it.
- LocalH 5y agoThings can still be "going downhill" while some things are better than they've ever been in human history. Frame of reference is a big thing that is almost never discussed - one's perception of how "bad" things are can only be informed by what one has already experienced, and otherwise influenced by the media that is plopped in front of us (in a kind of feedback loop). Your "bad" is not the same as my "bad" and that is true for everyone. A certain amount of "bad" experience is necessary in this world, in order to truly appreciate the "good", when you look at it. In that sense, a pure utopia would actually be a bad thing in the whole of human existence.
- simonh 5y agoI simply don't believe that a preponderance of the things we value in our society are actually declining. From the article: "In his new book, On Decline: Stagnation, Nostalgia and Why Every Year is the Worst One Ever, Potter argues that the West's two centuries of progress and prosperity — underpinned by liberal democracy, plentiful energy and natural resources, and economic growth — has ground to a halt and is now even going backwards." None of those things - technological progress, prosperity, access to democracy, economic growth - are actually declining. Take out the last 2 years of the pandemic, and global metrics on all these fronts have been making robust advances. Global poverty in particular has undergone dramatic falls as hundreds of millions of people in China and across South East Asia left behind grinding poverty and joined the global middle class. Even Africa, which always has problems in many areas, has actually been doing pretty well by historical standards. "The West" is doing fine as well, a few slow patches and setbacks sure but nothing fundamental. All the things weighing on people's minds in the last few years - Brexit, Trump, immigration, even Islamic terrorism - are just annoyances. Relative to actual tangible improvements in most people's lives they're just unfortunate speed bumps. They don't actually move the needle at a civilizational level.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mdp2021 5y ago
- AzzieElbab 5y agothe world is not in decline, western institutions are.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mdp2021 5y agoDo you have better news for non-Western institutions?
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe book specifically addresses the West, yes.