8 ms·
I expect there will be a lot of comments on this post representing a diverse set of views. From an economics perspective, people choosing to avoid vaccinations
by tomrod 5y ago
I expect there will be a lot of comments on this post representing a diverse set of views.
From an economics perspective, people choosing to avoid vaccinations adopt a stance that exacerbates a public health risk because, by their choice, they avoid internalizing the costs of their decisions. Mandates like the one rolled out by the Biden administration are legal, have strong standing, and are effective policy tools. And no one is being held down and coerced to receive a shot.
- beerandt 5y agoIt's the businesses choice to make healthcare a job benefit. I know we've gotten to where the practice it's common, but that doesn't make it any less of a business decision. So what happens when companies start screening new hires for expensive health issues?
- bastawhiz 5y agoIf the health issues were communicable to the other employees in the office, I would personally probably support those screenings. Besides being expensive for the company that pays me, it's entirely reasonable to expect my coworkers have done the absolute bare minimum to also protect me from an awful disease.
- beerandt 5y agoFauci was also for banning hiv/ aids patients from public places in the 80s. Because a novel disease was thought to be more communicable, more deadly, and more of a pandemic than it really was.
- bastawhiz 5y ago> more deadly, and more of a pandemic than it really was Essentially 100% of people who contracted HIV in the 80s died from it. So I'm really not sure how you can say that it was thought to be "more deadly" or "more of a pandemic than it really was." HIV was a death sentence, and without treatment, it continues to be a death sentence. HIV and COVID-19 are not comparable, and the politics around them cannot be boiled down to a single person's opinion at any one point in time.
- beerandt 5y agoNo one cought it by having a conversation or casual contact at work or in public. >Essentially 100% of people who contracted HIV in the 80s died from it. You need highly contagious and deadly. Not or. Speed of spread/ death counts, as well. Besides, COVID was initially sold as being much more deadly than actually is. Hindsight makes justification/ lack of easy. Yet how long would the hypothetical lockdowns have taken credit for slowing the spread back then? Even without lockdowns, how long did the cooties stigma last? >cannot be boiled down to a single person's opinion at any one point in time. I've been told to trust the experts.
- bastawhiz 5y agoUnfortunately, the only fact you've stated is this: > No one cought it by having a conversation or casual contact at work or in public. Correct. The transmission of HIV was also not understood. Nor was it even known to be a virus for quite some time, hence why it was called "the gay cancer." Part of the reason why it wasn't understood was the government's intentional apathy towards it, out of bigotry. > Besides, COVID was initially sold as being much more deadly than actually is. You might recall that the first wave completely depleted the availability of ventilators. In fact, this very website hosted links to DIY ventilator projects because the problem was so bad. Who are you to decide how much death is enough death to warrant concern? If the world healthcare systems cannot keep up, it's a problem. Five million people will have died by the end of the year. No other disease in US history has ever killed as many people. Your waffling about what makes a disease worthy of concern is unnecessary: salmonella only kills 0.4% of people who contract it, but we don't argue about restaurant staff using clean cooking equipment.
- dantheman 5y agoMandates like the one rolled out by Biden administration are definitely not legal, just like the eviction moratorium is not legal. The federal government does not have police powers and the agencies and regulators can't make rules outside their mandate. The authority to mandate vaccines is at the state and local level.
- chewbacha 5y agoFwiw; Biden has full authority to mandate federal employees are fully vaccinated.
- chickenpotpie 5y agoExplain OSHA
- iammisc 5y agoHonestly... will someone please explain OSHA? It was held by many to be unconstitutional at the time of institution. It still is today. Just because the feds broke the law in the past doesn't mean we get to excuse it again in the future. The federal government is very good at breaking laws. At some point, they must be held to account.
- mullen 5y agoNo police powers are being used, so I don't see how that is relivate. Also, the Agencies are not going out of their mandate. OSHA was created to make the workplace safer and by mandating vaccines, they are.
- bpodgursky 5y agoPolice powers are obviously being used... how do you think laws and regulations are enforced? If a business violates the OSHA rules and then doesn't pay the penalties, they are shut down and, if the business continues operating in violation of the regulators, arrested. That's the obvious and implicit statement. The police do that! The police aren't out raiding houses but the police powers are obviously being used; it's the state's monopoly on violence! It's the government's biggest lever!
- AutumnCurtain 5y agoIf their hospital is anything like the one I work for, their business model would be crippled by not requiring vaccination simply due to the impact on utilization.
- po1nt 5y agoFair point of view. Except that everybody pays taxes yet get different treatment based on what they decide to do with their body.
- munk-a 5y agoThat has pretty much always been the case though right? In 1995 people who chose to smoke were prevented from being indoors in NYC for their entire dining experience if they wanted to have a cigarette. It is perfectly reasonable that there be some differences in treatment based on your choices.
- iammisc 5y agoExcept 'having a cigarette' and 'breathing' are activities with two different moral weights. 'Having a cigarette' in a building is a luxury. Breathing in a building is not. For example, it would be okay for a state to ban drivking alcohol anywhere. Alcohol is a luxury. Breathing is not. Neither is working.
- po1nt 5y agoWell I'm against government forcing this either. It should be venues responsibility. You can always leave a venue that is smoker friendly.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wyager 5y ago> From an economics perspective, people choosing to avoid vaccinations adopt a stance that exacerbates a public health risk So do people choosing to leave their house. There are certain classes of externalities that society has chosen not to explicitly internalize, such as those imposed by living a normal life.
- tomrod 5y agoWhich, moving forward, will probably mean being vaccinated for COVID.
- wyager 5y agoMaybe, but don’t pretend you’re arguing from a purely economic basis, unless you’re also willing to punish people for ever leaving their house. You’re also missing the higher-order issue of internalization overhead, but that’s a whole separate consideration.
- iammisc 5y ago> And no one is being held down and coerced to receive a shot. This is absolutely garbage reasoning. They're having their livelihoods ripped away. Simply not pulling a trigger does not give you some moral high ground.
- darwinwhy 5y agoFunny choice of words when talking about healthcare workers.
- panda-giddiness 5y agoHealthcare workers have a duty to their patients. Those patients include the willfully unvaccinated, but they also include immunocompromised individuals who can't mount a robust vaccine response. While that latter class of people might sound like an edge case not worthy of consideration in larger society, it is exactly the sort of edge case that's relevant in a healthcare setting. If a healthcare worker isn't willing to receive a jab that could literally save someone else's life, they're in the wrong field. If they don't believe that vaccines are effective or safe or whatever, they can choose not to vaccinate; but they shouldn't be allowed to force that risk on their patients, especially since a "vaccine-hesistant" position is overwhelming at odds with the medical consensus.
- TacticalCoder 5y agoBut that doesn't explain firing all those among those 1400 who tested positive in the past and whom, according to recent studies, are not just a bit but way less likely to spread the Delta variants than those who, like me, got the Pfizer vaccine but never tested positive. I'm vaccinated but this entire witch hunt against unvaccinated people makes me very uneasy.
- panda-giddiness 5y ago> But that doesn't explain firing all those among those 1400 who tested positive in the past Sure, I think that's a valid concern, but it's also shifting the goal posts. You can advocate for that specific subset without advocating for the entire group.
- akira2501 5y ago> they avoid internalizing the costs of their decisions. You don't know that. There are ways to take precautions to the benefit of your fellow citizens that do not involve taking the vaccine. There's more than one way to be civil. > And no one is being held down and coerced to receive a shot. No.. but you're limiting their rights under the guise that their decisions must be harming someone. You're engaged in penalizing behavior without actually establishing any guilt. It's disturbing that this is bandied about so readily.
- orf 5y ago> You don't know that. There are ways to take precautions to the benefit of your fellow citizens that do not involve taking the vaccine. That's certainly true, but I expect the intersection between "people who don't trust vaccines" and "people who don't take any precautions" to be overwhelming.
- akira2501 5y agoWhat is this expectation based on? What if it was only true for 50% of the unvaccinated, would that still justify this approach? At what rate would it be justified?
- Mirioron 5y agoObesity has a sizable impact on the healthcare system. WHO says that obesity kills 2.8 million people a year.[0] Would these kinds of methods work there too? Get fit or be let go? Obviously this wouldn't ever be taken seriously, but it is surprising to me that obesity is an issue that's mostly ignored. Yet the impact of it is on at least the same scale as the pandemic. [0] https://www.who.int/news-room/facts-in-pictures/detail/6-facts-on-obesity https://www.who.int/news-room/facts-in-pictures/detail/6-fac...
- xjlin0 5y agothat's a valid argument, also please keep in mind that obesity kills people in decades, while covid kill people in days. And sadly there are some people would get fired because of overweight in some fields.
- munk-a 5y agoI think, speaking as an obese person, that if there was a solution that was as easy as getting jabbed in the arm twice - I'd jump on it in a moment. Obesity has a diversity of causes but I can guarantee you that it's never an easy thing to overcome.
- staplers 5y agoMy body my choice. If you infect me with your covid, it's a problem. Covid kills more people a year than obesity.
- chucksta 5y agoHow does my body my choice not apply to the other person?
- ballarak 5y agoThe obesity examples fails because obesity is non-contagious. The issue with COVID is that not getting vaccinated puts your coworkers even more at risk in an environment where you're already much more likely to be infected. Additionally, in health care you're often working with patients who have comorbidities, for these patients, contracting COVID from a healthcare worker could be a death sentence.
- codeecan 5y agodo you know what coerced means? compelling a party to act in an involuntary manner by use of threats, including propaganda or force. They're clearly coerced, unless you don't think getting fired falls under threats.
- tomohawk 5y agoIt is immunity which confers safety. You can achieve immunity by vaccination, but if you've already had covid, you have better immunity. Many countries recognize this When the government requires people to get a medical procedure, it had better be necessary, not just for the population, but also the individual. If there is no benefit to the individual, it is unethical, and probably illegal, to force a person to get it.