6 ms·
I Was a Facebook Fact-Checker (2019)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- smhg 5y agoTo anyone with strong opinions (any direction) about this topic and who wants to gain a deeper insight, I'd highly recommend Radiolab's episode about it: https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/articles/facebooks-supreme-court https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/articles/faceb...
- concordDance 5y agoThis is approaching from the wrong angle. Trying to stop the tide of bullshit is futile without hundreds of thousands of "fact checkers", what's needed is teaching people good epistemological hygiene. How to read an article, how to respect quantification, what sort of things to be suspicious of, how to find out accurate information and when to withhold judgement.
- volta83 5y ago> what's needed is teaching people good epistemological hygiene. How to read an article, how to respect quantification, what sort of things to be suspicious of, how to find out accurate information and when to withhold judgement. Good luck trying to teach a >20 year old this. When you teach children that the scientific method is useless, logic is not necessary, and therefore Creationism is fine, repairing that "damage" once Children are older is pretty much impossible. You have "habituated" them to the lie, just in the exact same way that "child soldiers" and "terrorist" get habituated. Part of the habituation process is making them personally invested on the lie, e.g., for a child soldier or a terrorist that's their first "kill". From that moment on, either they are right, or they are a horrible human being. Same here, it might start with Creationism, then shaming someone for wanting an abortion, etc. One of these is going to be their first "kill" moment, their point of no return, and then the only way to "heal" is for them to discover that they are horrible human beings. Pretty much impossible to heal in practice. In the exact same way that this is not the child soldiers fault, it is not the fault of children that have been educated their way to end up raiding the capitol. I'd go as far that it is not the fault of these children to even then lobby as adults for the process to continue, for more creationism, for more extremism, etc. Maybe at some point someone in the USA was at fault for allowing this to happen. But at this point I think that a big part of the population particularly in central america are just victims of the system. They were raised into what they are now, and lots of psychological hard work would be required to "fix" any single one of them. Simplifying this issue to "this people are just dumb, and facebook should send them a link to a page that teaches them how to read" would be as effective as trying to address terrorism by repeating on TV that killing people is bad.
- netcan 5y ago>> what's needed is teaching people good epistemological hygiene. What's needed of who? I agree that epistemological hygiene is good, but how is FB supposed to tackle this. Even the education system may have trouble, and even if they don't it will take a generation. Problems need to be framed in ways that don't avoid dealing with them.
- concordDance 5y agoMy view is that asking Facebook to tackle it is asking way too much. Indeed, I wouldn't want the government to try and control what people can communicate either. Yes, it will take a generation for people to figure out how to navigate a world like this, but ultimately its the only option that doesn't end up with a centralised arbiter of truth restricting communication (where a dystopia will inevitably follow in a few decades).
- atoav 5y agoWhile I agree these are important skills that everybody should learn, especially in todays world, I don't think this is the whole problem. Quite often it is not the issue that people don't know they might be wrong, but that they don't care whether they are. In their worldview small (or sometimes even big) lies are justified in a "war" that conveys "a bigger truth". In their eyes, people who stick with the truth no matter what are naive, stupid or both. As with the deprogramming of Nazis like my grandfather after WWII, the hardest ones to get back to the truth are ot the ones that couldn't tell, but the ones that could tell, knew it was wrong, knew what was going on and went for it anyways.
- sayonaraman 5y agoFB, while being the prime medium by which fake news spread, is at the same time terrible for anyone who attempts to control public opinion. You can never hire enough "fact-checkers" thank God, it's democracy in action.
- colordrops 5y agoThe main problem with many of these "fact checking" organizations and processes is that they often overstep their bounds. They work fine when they can source exact data and facts, e.g. a date, a number, the conclusion of a scientific study, the name of a person, and exact phrase that was said. But more often than not, they delve into opinion or judgement of vague or complex situations. This intermingling is not much different from how newspapers and channels intermingle reporting with opinion, often with very little indication of the difference between the two.
- smt88 5y agoThe difficulty of objective fact-checking doesn't mean we shouldn't do it. To use that logic, we should also not have judges or a legal system. Most people would agree an imperfect attempt with lots of transparency is better than no attempt at all. The first thing you learn in journalism is that you can't be 100% objective, even if you're 100% truthful. Let's say you're reporting on Obama's birth certificate, and you write 20 pages of a deep dive into where he was born and all the evidence for it. You are complete and thorough, and you end up concluding that he couldn't have been born in Kenya. Just the fact that you wrote that much to debunk a nonsensical, evidence-free lie is actually going to make it seem like they had evidence! You can also neglect to report on things. You can report on 150 burglaries a day and give people the impression that burglaries are skyrocketing when they aren't. So of course there will be subjectivity that leaks out, but that's not something we should fear to the point of giving up.
- drewcoo 5y agoThe whole point of judges is that they are humans who exercise their judgement. IANAL, but I'm pretty sure that's intended to counter a cold, dry, robotic application of the letter of the law.
- jdthedisciple 5y agoExactly. Add to that that in legal trials there is also a proper defense, which is crucial. You don't have that online most of the times. (Social) media fact-checking also often becomes a form of silent censorship.
- roenxi 5y ago> We’d be asked to check if a story about a woman who was arrested for leaving her children in the car for hours while she ate at a buffet was true; meanwhile a flood of anti-semitic false George Soros stories never showed up on the list. This is an interesting take. Doubly interesting to me because this is evidence for something that was always likely - Facebook fact checkers aren't particularly qualified in the areas they are fact checking. This woman with a background in journalism would have been taking down posts by doctors and nurses for being COVID misionformation.
- raziel2p 5y agoYou do not always have to be a subject matter expert to do fact-checking. Furthermore, doctors and nurses can (and have) also spread COVID misinformation, it's not a bad thing to have journalists check them.
- redis_mlc 5y ago> doctors and nurses can (and have) also spread COVID misinformation Especially Fauci.
- germandiago 5y agofact checking is just a political fight for making things look true or false. It is an official ministry of the truth, reminds me of past times, and certainly not better than today or 15 years back, where absolutely any aspect of life tried to be politiziced. Many things cannot be easily audited, are about points of view, and fact checking enables censorship and bias towards one side or another. And last but not least, I am not a kid. When I go out at night I know there are good and bad places and people. I figure out what is good and bad and if I make a mistake, I learn. I am an adult. I do not need babysitting. If there were far fewer people to control the rest of population, special mention to politicians here, who are kind of a mafia, then people would care way less about news. I know a bunch of people, just like me, that have taken the road to believe NOTHING from mainstream media because it is so obviously manipulated, even fact checking. We have our own and different views and philosophies but we reached the conclusion that politics and trading to extract resources and create obedience from people are the main goals of people who want to control others. I do not need fact checking.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 5y agoBrooke Binkowski, author of the submitted article, has been reprising a number of pieces on Facebook's largely ineffective and by many appearances broken-by-design fact-checking initiatives of the past few years. Another particularly goood piece is this from The Guardian in 2018: 'They don't care': Facebook factchecking in disarray as journalists push to cut ties Current and former Facebook factcheckers told the Guardian that the tech platform’s collaboration with outside reporters has produced minimal results and that they’ve lost trust in Facebook, which has repeatedly refused to release meaningful data about the impacts of their work. Some said Facebook’s hiring of a PR firm that used an antisemitic narrative to discredit critics – fueling the same kind of propaganda factcheckers regularly debunk – should be a deal-breaker. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/dec/13/they-dont-care-facebook-fact-checking-in-disarray-as-journalists-push-to-cut-ties https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/dec/13/they-dont... More are appearing on her feed, see: https://nitter.kavin.rocks/brooklynmarie https://nitter.kavin.rocks/brooklynmarie
- teddyh 5y agoAny “fact-checker” which is mandatory, is a censor in all but name.
- blitzar 5y agoteddyh rapes children. Are you going to censor me "in all but name" or allow the statement to stand on the record as a fact?
- concordDance 5y agoIs teddyh a mandatory fact checkers?
- reilly3000 5y agoFacebook created the censorship, fact checkers merely research claims and publish their analysis. Never before Facebook did a fact checker have any bearing on content distribution outside of their own news organization.
- ajkjk 5y agoCertainly not. Censorship is suppressing views. Fact-checking is identifying false information. They are only the same if you are only putting out false information. Then the fact-checking looks like censorship. You will say, well, the fact-checkers tend to get political. Nevertheless, they're still fundamentally different than censors.
- kortilla 5y ago> Fact-checking is identifying false information. Right, identifying information as “false” is censoring it on Facebook because it suppresses it.
- ajkjk 5y agoThe difference is whether it is removed for being wrong versus for political/ideological purposes. You would not call a newspaper editor who refuses to publish dishonest journalism a censor, would you? Obviously there is a stance going around that 'calling things wrong' is being done for political/ideological purposes, but that doesn't make fact-checking censorship _in principle_.
- daniel_iversen 5y agoA few comments; - firstly, just because you can’t eradicate all fake news and misinformation does not make the effort “doomed” - you can’t get rid of all crime in the world either, or all disease, but you can still try and reduce it and it’s a worthy effort. - the writer conflates a bunch of things - they wants the algorithms to be open, transparent and opt-in. While that would be nice, I don’t think that’s required to eliminate misinformation (nor will it solve it) - what makes the article less credible is the author ends it with complaining about revenue sharing and saying Facebook must pay writers and publications. While potentially that could be nice it does not seem to have anything to do with the issue at hand and makes it read just like any other “let’s crap on Facebook” article
- amelius 5y ago> I don’t think that’s required to eliminate misinformation (nor will it solve it) It might reduce it (see your first point).
- throwaway510921 5y agoWhen you consider fakes just as the symptom of cognitive deficiencies and all you do is label these stories as why and where they are wrong, your impression of a doomed attempt seems quite understandable to me. It would be much more helpful to explain and teach by example the underlying cognitive mechanism that tricked you in the first place. An example. Alot of climate change "sceptics" repeat over and over again, that CO2 is just ~2% of earth atmosphere (doesn't matter if the number is correct or not) and they conclude that therefore CO2's effect on the climate is neglectable. This is wrong reasoning, you got tricked by a small number, but it appears right for a superficial look. (Following this logic, cyanide would be harmless too.) The over and over (and over and over and over) repetition of that aspect is like a chain reaction you can only effectively stop by halting the underlying process. Otherwise some else fake news get spread next iteration.
- netcan 5y ago> the writer conflates a bunch of things - they wants the algorithms to be open, transparent and opt-in. While that would be nice, I don’t think that’s required to eliminate misinformation (nor will it solve it) "Required" might be a strong word, but "would be nice" is too weak, IMO. I suppose it depends on what you see as the goals and purpose of moderation. I've seen a lot of agreement about SM requiring moderation, while totally disagreeing about what, why and to what end. If fairness s concern, nevermind freedom, openness is a factor. Also, while he doesn't state it... the author is concerned about moderating facebook, not just facebook users. That makes some sense, from where he's sat. The job is to "prevent the spread of misinformation" on FB, especially headline stuff: political/electoral misinformation, covid related, etc.^ He sees this stuff repeatedly go viral... and that logically leads to the platform and recommendation algorithm itself. Applying moderation after may not (in his view) be enough to do the job. Opaqueness probably makes it as hard for moderation teams to understand the nuances as it does for us. Maybe openness and free software adjacent principles are not the only way to approach an actual solution, but most of the best ideas are not unrelated. If you think of bullshit propaganda going viral as a bug, transparency is definitely relevant. Opt-in & respecting user wishes generally, are also part of a lot of hypothetical solutions. One of the ways pre-FB social media dynamics was various "bad behaviour" rooms. HN works as an example. You can choose to view dead comments. Most choose not to. Still, that tiny piece of transparency and user choice moderates some of the moderation's weaknesses. I don't think you can say anything definitively, but there are logical links between FB's control oriented model and the problems moderators are tasked with fixing. ^He cites Myanmar as an example. This is in a language & culture that FB don't speak. They really don't know what is going on, and I think it's likely they heard about FB's role in causing major violence against a minority from a third party. COmpare that to the level of
- richardfey 5y agoThe revenue sharing part sounded like a delusional dream; I would opt for a greylisting mechanism for all domains that are first time used on Facebook.
- angelzen 5y agoWe live in an information oversupply era. Refuting information is just as important as creating information was in older eras. Unfortunately funding comes primarily from political operations. The incentives are aligned to refute one side of the aisle, while leaving the other side propagating cockamamie bullshit unchecked. The end result is cockamamie bullshit. 'Fact checking' or not, the morass will deepen.
- jdthedisciple 5y agoThere was a video on YouTube titled "Who fact-checks the fact-checkers?". Of course that one has by now been "fact-checked" off YouTube. So even if I wanted to, I couldn't refer you to what was a very neat presentation of some of the issues with fact-checkers with clear evidence showing where these in fact present misinformation and demonstrate clear political bias. And that is the problem with fact-checkers. (In this case, the "fact-checker" called YouTube that decided it didn't like the facts presented in said video).
- Mordisquitos 5y ago> There was a video on YouTube titled "Who fact-checks the fact-checkers?". A quick search of YouTube shows a very large number of videos using that (somewhat clichéd) title, so as far as I can tell that video may still be available. I call a fact-check on whether who fact-checks the fact-checkers was in fact fact-checked off YouTube.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ObamaBinSpying 5y agoThe fact-checkers will eventually be used to control the (political) narrative.
- was8309 5y agoPlease provide clear evidence showing where Brook Binkowski presents misinformation.
- vixen99 5y agoI wonder why, if I'm familiar with the background, I find it so trivially easy to predict what every 'Fact-Check' piece I've ever read, will say?
- blunte 5y agoVery small point about this story, regarding the true|false|mixture|satire options, specifically the satire option - good satire can almost be indistinguishable from proposed fact. In other words, I daresay that people of less education and less experience reading (or where the article is written in a language which is not the reader's first language) would not realize it is satire. This has happened many times where certain political groups have promoted Onion stories that appear to favor their policies - but which are clearly satire to some of us. So even if the fact checkers could stay on top of the flood of misinformation, I expect there could be a minimal formula for getting content marked as Satire while still delivering false information to gullible/ignorant readers. A problem too great (or late) to solve is the relative ignorance of many of the readers. These are also the people who vote in politicians who work directly against their needs. When a person can stand in a burning building and say, "We're sure glad we got our guy leading the government, because those other guys would have ruined everything we care about." No amount of fact checking can solve this mental problem.