4 ms·
I like the headline. Nobody really knows how the economy works. Economics is an attempt to explain how wealth and prosperity are created. That also means some b
by imtringued 5y ago
I like the headline. Nobody really knows how the economy works. Economics is an attempt to explain how wealth and prosperity are created. That also means some branches are biased towards what we already have. It gets especially bad when morality is used because from the perspective of something as uncaring as an economy there are no meaningful morals, they are all made up. I personally think the vast majority of economic problems are caused by modeling errors. The model we use to look at the real economy is too rigid to represent it.
The laziest way to explain the rigidities is to just blame someone else, most of the time governments. However, getting rid of goverments doesn't seem to get rid of all rigidity because, as it turns out, our physical world is constrained by more than just politics. What's often forgotten is that governments can also fight against natural forces that reduce flexibility in the economy. Therefore the answer is neither more government or less government. No it's the usual boring answer. What we need is better governments. It's like a supply and demand situation. There is demand for a certain size of government and the supply is often either too high or too low. The goal is to find a balance.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Economics is an attempt to explain how wealth and prosperity are created To expand on the question's unknowability, "wealth" and "prosperity" are measures on a population's utility functions. "Utility" is an attempt at mapping the set of possible things a person could want to an ordered set [1]. This goes to the heart of preference, free will and consciousness. Fortunately, at a population level, persistent effects do manifest. But we don't know why. Because at the individual level, they're inexplicable (if existent at all). This is why, by the way, economics often finds inspiration in particle physics. Not because people are particles. But because it's a field that has developed techniques and methods that make useful population-level predictions without completely understanding the individual components. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoFraming the question as one of "more" or "less" government seems to contain an implicit assumption about the value of government itself. The value of any government. It assumes all government is qualitatively the same. Hence the only question is whether we should have more or less. Whether that is a reasonable assumption to make is left as a question for the reader.
- MuffinFlavored 5y ago> Economics is an attempt to explain how wealth and prosperity are created. Overly simplistic view from scratch: Individuals start businesses to offer other individuals and businesses goods and services. Wealth transfers daily to and from many individuals/businesses. Where does this definition fall apart/breakdown as you start to zoom in (or out)?
- biotinker 5y agoI think it breaks down when you start trying to look at emergent behavior that only becomes apparent at large scale. An analogy would be to start looking at a water molecule, H2O, and then trying to explain glaciers and oceans without any sort of similar system to use as a model.
- tibbetts 5y agoBreaks down instantly when you try to define which activities count as businesses, or try to define why individuals are offering goods and services to one another.
- fighterpilot 5y ago"define why individuals are offering goods and services to one another." Because these individuals think it's mutually beneficial to enter into the trade. This explains all voluntary cooperation including barter and modern trade. I sell my goods and services to someone who needs them because I can then go and buy food with that money. Currency obfuscates this picture a bit but its only role is to solve double coincidence of wants. Underneath it is just barter via a layer of indirection.
- MuffinFlavored 5y agoHow is an individual offering goods and services to one another not a business?
- Ieghaehia9 5y agoIs a Wikipedia author participating in a business when they update an article, thus contributing to the service of a better encyclopedia? Is an open-source programmer doing business when they post their GPLed source on the web? Is gift-giving (offering a good) business? That definition seems to be a bit too broad. So maybe there needs to be compensation. But then the determinists would say that even gift-giving has compensation (in the form of reciprocity) and thus isn't much different from credit. So the compensation should be something closer to monetary compensation. But then barter economies have no businesses. Etc.