4 ms·
In Topology When Are Two Shapes the Same?
- woopwoop 5y agoWhen I took algebraic topology, the professor asked us if two topological spaces were the same. Then he looked at us for a moment, and said that actually, that was a "Bill Clinton question: it depends on what the meaning of the word 'is' is".
- sarosh 5y agoA nice summary of the current understanding (from a lay perspective) on manifold "sameness". From the article: "But Freedman’s [1981] proof left open the “smooth” four-dimensional Poincaré conjecture, which says that any four-dimensional smooth manifold that is homotopy equivalent to the four-dimensional sphere is also diffeomorphic to the four-dimensional sphere. This is an even stronger statement than the one Freedman proved — since a diffeomorphism is a stronger form of equivalence than a homeomorphism — and one that mathematicians today have no idea how to settle. This leaves them in the strange position of being unable to perform one of the most basic classification tasks of all: recognizing when a smooth four-dimensional manifold is really a sphere."
- donw 5y agoThis is one of the best lay-explanations of manifolds I’ve seen. Nice!
- Koshkin 5y agoA nice article, but it feels a bit weird that there was no mentioning of the Poincaré conjecture in its original form - the one that was named one of the seven Millennium Prize Problems.
- kevinventullo 5y agoThe final open question can be restated as asking whether any 4-dimensional smooth manifold which is homeomorphic to the 4-sphere is necessarily diffeomorphic to the 4-sphere. As a point of comparison, here is a surprising pair of facts about Euclidean space: - For n != 4, any n-dimensional smooth manifold which is homeomorphic to n-dimensional Euclidean space is actually diffeomorphic to it. - On the other hand, there are uncountably many pairwise non-diffeomorphic 4-dimensional smooth manifolds which are all homeomorphic to 4-dimensional Euclidean space.
- dpratt 5y agoIf I’m understanding this correctly, the statement is “There is a set of provably true assertions that are held in every n-dimensional geometry, except for n=4” If so, that’s fascinating. Has there been any proofs around why a dimensional ordinality (if that’s the right term) of 4 is different?
- kevinventullo 5y agoYes, and I agree it is fascinating! As for “why” 4-dimensional geometry is somehow special, I couldn’t tell you, but here’s a whole MO thread about it: https://mathoverflow.net/questions/47569/what-makes-four-dimensions-special https://mathoverflow.net/questions/47569/what-makes-four-dim...
- quickthrower2 5y agoThere is a good YouTube about this [1]: Pop a balloon and slowly let the air out. You can stretch the resulting fabric into a simple shape with no holes. The balloon therefore had -1 holes. They then go on to talk about 2D and 3D holes and Euler Characteristic etc. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ymF1bp-qrjU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ymF1bp-qrjU
- Jensson 5y agoThe pants example is wrong. Pants are equivalent to a disk with two holes, when you circle the two holes in a disk you get 3 separated areas you cannot move between. Topologically valid transformations of surfaces doesn't alter this property. The pants with connected legs however lets you circle two holes without separating any areas at all, you can move between any two points on the pants without crossing the lines just by circling the 8 they collapsed the connected pants into. So a punctured torus surface is not topologically equivalent to a pants surface. The problem with their transformation was that they twisted the surface. You aren't allowed to do that. It works if you see the pants as a volume though, but they specifically talked about surfaces. Similarly a möbius strip is different from a regular loop as a surface, but not as a volume. The twist here is similar.
- quickthrower2 5y agoThanks for that I was a bit bothered by the shorts transform but thought it was my not understanding something. All the animations require the twist to just kinda disappear.
- Dylan16807 5y agoSome of the animations, not all.
- Dylan16807 5y agoHe talks about that at the 29 minute mark. Rough quote: Technically, if these trousers were made from infinitely thin fabric, then this shape is not equal to this shape because of the twist problem. However, fabric is not infinitely thin [...] so I'm prepared to say a real pair of trousers are homeomorphic to the same pair with the ends of the legs stuck together.
- dukeofdoom 5y ago3Blue1Brown has a nice intro video on Topology https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AmgkSdhK4K8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AmgkSdhK4K8
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoThanks. This was really great.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]