5 ms·
For those who say "you don't need a helmet on campus," there's a simple science-based way to test your theory: Look at the stats on brain injuries for bicycle
by AlbertCory 5y ago
For those who say "you don't need a helmet on campus," there's a simple science-based way to test your theory:
Look at the stats on brain injuries for bicycle accidents on campus. [1] has anecdotes, but no stats, unfortunately.
You have other bikes to collide with, you have people crossing the path, and yes, there are cars on campus. I've driven there.
[1] https://transportation.stanford.edu/bicycle/learn-about-bike-safety/love-your-brain https://transportation.stanford.edu/bicycle/learn-about-bike...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- oefrha 5y agoAnd you have bike thieves screwing your wheels loose for whatever reason. Bike theft was a big problem at least when I was at Stanford years ago, and my front wheel once came off when I was biking (thankfully I was wearing a helmet). Guy at bike shop speculated that it was the handiwork of a thief, who might have been interrupted mid act.
- 13415 5y agoStrange anecdote: I once organized a workshop on reasoning about uncertainty and one of the attendants was a health official working on bike accident statistics. According to her, if going solely by the statistics, helmets would have to be prohibited in our country because people riding bikes with helmets had a significantly elevated risk of grave traffic accidents in comparison to those without helmets. Of course, she also said that you really couldn't use the statistics in this way and we agreed that it seemed likely that helmets could prevent serious head injuries. Still, it was an odd finding. Presumably, people with helmets drove faster or more carelessly but she did not have any evidence for that at the time. Edit (just in case): 1. I'm not an expert on any of this and it's just an anecdote. 2. I recommend wearing a good, certified helmet.
- detaro 5y agoOr people with more dangerous routes are more likely to wear helmets. There's also some data to suggest that drivers are less careful around cyclists with helmets, e.g. passing them with less distance. Somewhat related, specifically in the context of requiring helmets there's also arguments that people dislike them enough that the reduction in cycling happening would have worse overall effects than the injury reduction.
- mike_h 5y agoMore dangerous routes on a more regular basis (committed to commuting on roads with cars), and mountain biking: https://www.cyclehelmets.org/1261.html https://www.cyclehelmets.org/1261.html
- AlbertCory 5y agoThat's an interesting question: similar to seatbelts causing more dangerous driving. Maybe. However, we're talking about on campus here, not riding down Mission in the City.
- detaro 5y agoSure, the subthread here moved to more general helmet statistics.
- weird-eye-issue 5y agoThe lack of bad anecdotes on that page combined with the fact 13k people daily ride their bike on campus would only serve to make me not feel like wearing a helmet there... Yes that first story is unfortunate but I'd bet she just wasn't that great on a bike
- cratermoon 5y ago> I'd bet she just wasn't that great on a bike Literally blaming the victim. Not a good look.
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 5y agoKali Lindsay? Victim of what? Either way it was her actions that led her to getting brain injuries.
- cratermoon 5y ago> it was her actions Actions within a system in which better choices were not available. There's no reason to lay the blame at the feet of the victim in that system.
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 5y agoHow was wearing a helmet not available?
- cratermoon 5y agoWearing a helmet is one of the choices out of the ones possible within the constraints of the system. By "better choices" I mean ones that would require questioning the limits in which the existing choices can be made.
- pessimizer 5y agoThis is a discussion about helmet-wearing, which is voluntary. The entire discussion is about whether a victim deserves blame. Don't retreat into easy clichés.
- pessimizer 5y ago> For those who say "you don't need a helmet on campus," there's a simple science-based way to test your theory: > Look at the stats on brain injuries for bicycle accidents on campus. That's not science, that's looking. What you have to do is compare stats of the results and frequency of accidents with helmets and accidents without. There have been very good statistical cases made that the accidents that helmets protect against aren't the accidents that bicyclists get in (unlike the situation with motorcyclists, for example.)
- AlbertCory 5y agoThere are some obvious statistical fallacies here: 1) I don't know what you consider "looking" as opposed to "science" so maybe you can help us out? 2) No, you're wrong that "What you have to do is compare stats of the results and frequency of accidents with helmets and accidents without." That takes as a prior that the bicyclist is going to have an accident. The actual test is "head injuries from a bike accident while not wearing a helmet per units of helmet-less distance ridden." (I said "units of distance" because "miles" might be too big a unit here.) 3) who cares about motorcycles? We're talking bicycles here.