6 ms·
> I know folks are saying Trevor and Nikola Motors have some sort of ground breaking hydrogen tech So, they have "ground breaking tech" in a dead-end technolog
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
> I know folks are saying Trevor and Nikola Motors have some sort of ground breaking hydrogen tech
So, they have "ground breaking tech" in a dead-end technology then? The energy losses required to power vehicles with hydrogen are much greater than losses with electric batteries (there was a recent article on HN that really drove this point home for me). Seems like the only folks pushing hydrogen these days are folks that made bets on what turned out to be the wrong tech (cough, cough, Toyota).
- jazzyjackson 5y agoI like hydrogen. The idea that every personal vehicle should have 1000 pounds of lithium-cobalt-etc is crazy to me, that's before getting into super-trucks and 18 wheelers, then not to mention aircraft and cargo ships. Batteries are neat, but I'm not sure they scale.
- devoutsalsa 5y agoI was hoping we’d just make synthetic gasoline from atmospheric carbon dioxide. Wouldn’t require changing any infrastructure at all. Just make gibs of it using renewables. It sounds good in theory anyway.
- moonchrome 5y agoOne of the nice aspects of electric cars is going to be eliminating city polution and reducing road noise. I have no idea what the CO2 impact would be and don't really care that much ("cutting CO2 will reset the climate to some state we like" sounds like wishful thinking and most of the talk in this space is ideologically coloured I don't even want to pay attention) but the improvement in urban living is going to be undeniable.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoaside from accelerating at stoplights, electric cars and gas cars make similar noise levels just from the rubber against the road. rubber is a significant pollutant as well, as is brake dust. Don’t get me wrong, electric is much better, i’m only nitpicking since you said “eliminating”
- moonchrome 5y agoBrake dust is much less of an issue with electrics too, but agreed that tires are still a factor. But as someone who lived in urban centers for the majority of his life - I think getting down to tires being the major issue is solving the majority of the problem.
- cesarb 5y ago> aside from accelerating at stoplights, electric cars and gas cars make similar noise levels just from the rubber against the road. There's also the idle engine rumbling noise while waiting at stoplights, which does not exist on electric cars.
- cesarb 5y ago> but the improvement in urban living is going to be undeniable. When the pandemic arrived here back in March 2020, and nearly everyone suddenly stopped leaving their home, it was eerie: the air where I live (in the middle of a major urban area) suddenly smelled as if I was in a rural area. It was something I wasn't expecting to see so soon; I have for a long time been rooting for EVs to arrive and make the air quality better, but unfortunately EVs are simply way too expensive yet (so far, I only have seen an EV once, and it was an i3 with a range extender; and I do live in a major metropolitan area).
- m4rtink 5y agoThat would still not solve all the localised polution caused by burning it in cars.
- coryrc 5y agoModern vehicle weigh multiple tons, what's a half-ton battery really matter? Also much of the weight is carbon and oxygen. LiFePO4 also (obviously) is substantially iron and phosphorous. Li-Ion battery production had been growing at double-digit percentage for decades. I think they've proven you wrong many times over. Finally, electric cars charge at ~96% efficiency, while hydrogen is something like 40%. I, for one, am not interested in paying 3x per mile.
- rewma 5y ago> Modern vehicle weigh multiple tons, what's a half-ton battery really matter? The Tesla Model S weights about 2100kg. The Tesla Model S battery weights about 540kg. This means that a 1500kg car is forced to pack an additional 540kg to be able to store energy. That's an additional 30% of the mass that you need to accelerate and brake. People do care about that. In the very least, the battery mass is responsible for an effective drop in energy efficiency of around 30% just to cart someone around. > Finally, electric cars charge at ~96% efficiency, while hydrogen is something like 40%. I, for one, am not interested in paying 3x per mile. This claim has little substance and credibility. For starters, if you factor in how much additional energy you need to waste just to pack along a massive half ton battery, you'll eventually realize that the effective energy waste of a EV is not much different than the hydrogen one. I mean, the point of a EV is not to have it parked on the driveway, charge a battery, and proceed to boast about how that was very efficient. Your goal is to move around, and moving that massive half ton beast of a battery along with you wastes a lot of energy too. Also, battery efficiency is around 80%, which naively sounds a far improvement over fuel cell's lauded 40% efficiency. However, a Li-Ion battery weights half a ton and represents around 1/3 of a EV's mass, which also requires energy to be moved around. For reference the fuel cell of a Toyota Mirai is only 40kg, less than the weight of an adult passenger. Once you do your math you'll quickly notice the effective energy use is not that different. And then there's the cost argument. The typical back-of-the-napkin figure for how much EVs cost to run is around 500€/year. Even if you bump that up to twice the cost, that price is eclipsed by the huge markup that you're already paying for an EV. I mean, a Tesla Model S costs about a century worth of energy bills before it even gets it's tires dirty. Playing the frugality card with the current batch of EVs lacks any credibility and is, at best, being penny wise and pound foolish.
- simondotau 5y ago> The idea that every personal vehicle should have 1000 pounds of lithium-cobalt-etc is crazy to me Whether it seems crazy is evidence of unfamiliarity, not whether it is actually crazy. Is it really any crazier that continually pumping every car with juice made from literal fossils? At least the battery is continually reusable — and at the end of its useful life, over 90% recyclable.
- swman 5y agoWhat happens to the lithium and other metals? I don’t know much about this stuff so I’d appreciate to know
- tantony 5y agoThey can be almost 100% reused. In fact, given how valuable the metals are it would be cheaper to do so than mine for them . There are multiple companies working on this. E.g. https://www.redwoodmaterials.com/ https://www.redwoodmaterials.com/
- smilekzs 5y agoMy opinion is that long-haul trucking is pretty much the only application where Hydrogen propulsion could make sense: Refueling infra only needs to cover truck stops (much more geographically consolidated compared to passenger cars). Autonomous driving tech would made it possible to run 24x7 (given recent advances, this is no longer a pipe dream), so BEV long recharge times would eat into uptime, but H2 refill won't (compared to diesel). Heck, if some kind of ICE could support flexible H2/LPG/CNG fuel, it's still gonna be much better than diesel + DEF.
- Schiendelman 5y agoBEV is perfect for trucking - you’re sleeping on the road. Just have to be sure to have enough spots at Love’s or TA. The market will work that part out.
- rewma 5y ago> So, they have "ground breaking tech" in a dead-end technology then? The energy losses required to power vehicles with hydrogen are much greater than losses with electric batteries (there was a recent article on HN that really drove this point home for me). These comments show a failure to understand what does hydrogen mean and why did it popped up as an alternative to ICEs to begin with. Hydrogen is presented as an alternative energy store that is clean, renewable, and can leverage existing infrastructure and, perhaps more importantly, consumer patterns and mental models, with little to no change. Energy efficiency is not a concern with hydrogen, or even a relevant talking point, because the promise of being able to generate it through renewable sources means it has no implication on its carbon footprint or even pollution. Also, it was a topic that was actively being researched and thus, much like photovoltaic panels, its efficiency was likely to go up. We also need to keep in mind that hydrogen was closest to production and mass adoption a few years ago, and we need to remind ourselves that not so long ago the idea of widespread supercharger stations and affordable electric batteries with enough storage to power a small family car was very close to a pipe dream. In my opinion, the only reason hydrogen why hydrogen hasn't been mass adopted was the colossal investment in marketing and R&D that a few private companies made in electric vehicles in general and Li-Ion batteries in particular. In the future we might very well look back at hydrogen in a similar way that a few years ago, when ICEs were the only game in town, we looked at the EVs from the late 19th/early 20th century and we wondered why were we so close but still missed the boat.
- grey-area 5y agoEnergy efficiency is important relative to other distribution methods. If the efficiency is half that of electric, you can power half the cars you could with electric with existing energy supplies. Obviously that is incredibly important - energy supplies will always be finite and fully utilised. A few places have tried to build a hydrogen network with. Metal embrittlement is a real problem and storage is not straightforward, even after you've produced it. https://electricrevs.com/2019/06/11/recent-explosions-shutdown-hydrogen-vehicle-refueling-in-norcal-and-norway/ https://electricrevs.com/2019/06/11/recent-explosions-shutdo... Hydrogen hasn't been adopted because it is expensive, dangerous, difficult to store and not as efficient as electric. With advances in batteries in the last few years it is definitely on the way out and electric is the clear winner here.
- franga2000 5y agoWhen using renewables, losses don't matter. The matter a lot now, where the losses are covered with fossil fuels, but that's now where we're heading. Hydrogen fuel tanks are far cheaper and more sustainable than lithium batteries. I believe the power density is also superior, although I don't have time to check right now. Additionally, hydrogen fuel isn't only useful in vehicles and a more efficient production method would still be great to have.