8 ms·
Lightning Network Flaws
- skybrian 5y agoThis is an impressively long list of articles about problems with Bitcoin’s Lightning Network. It’s not my area of expertise so I thought I’d see what people have to say about it.
- Proven 5y agoWhy waste time on that, it's not like you'll get paid for it or be rewarded some other way. Move on. There are many other coins.
- __Admin__ 5y agoLN is a "soltion" Blockstream (tm) created to solve a problem Blockstream created. "Solution" because it does not actaully allow fast and cheap "cash-like" transactions as Bitcoin was originally designed to do (and still can easily scale to Visa-like levels). From day one Satoshi had built Bitcoin to scale to to Visa levels of transactions by simply incrementaly increasing the block size over time. Blockstream hijacked the Bitcoin Core GitHub repo and soon after disabled several core features and have since refused to increase the block size while pushing their products (Liquid and LN) as "solutions" to this problem they created.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Vecr 5y agoNo, Blockstream's thing was Liquid, an actual product that was supposed to make them money. Lightning can't really make them any money (they would get caught in a race to the bottom), unless they want to do consulting. Consulting probably would not give them much or any control.
- 3np 5y agoThe list is a mixed bag of past CVEs; discussions on challenges or concerns (some absolutely valid) with architecture, routing, emergent centralization and privacy; FUD social media/blogspam; past and current (but solvable) UX issues; reddit/twitter rants; etc. Many of the links are nothing-burgers but there are a few exceptions. Specifically wrt to privacy, there are pitfalls and subtleties in using Lightning Network privately but it is doable. I think this article does a good job summarizing the current state [0]. IMO LN is secure enough to sleep well at night with open channels but you definitely want uptime monitoring and at least one watchtower hosted on separate infrastructure from the LN node, or great trust in whatever custodial wallet provider you may be using to not doxx you if you do and that's a concern. (Seriously though, any cryptocurrency going through any form of custodianship with any form of company/business will eventually have to be KYC’d and accounted for to authorities, if currently existing and planned regulations take effect. Self-custody and, for L2 like LN, self-hosting, takes some self-education but is the only way to get the true benefits of cryptocurrencies) [0]: https://abytesjourney.com/lightning-privacy/ https://abytesjourney.com/lightning-privacy/
- mw888 5y agoWeird to use Github for a simple list of hyperlinks. Anyways, this debate is extremely political as this is essentially a Bitcoin Cash viewpoint, and lightning makes BCH obsolete if it works, so from any dogmatic holder of BCH the motivated reasoning is obvious. That doesn’t mean issues can’t be true, but from following both the BTC and BCH communities for a long time I have trouble stomaching the same critiques about lightning over and over when it’s clear one community has never wanted it to work, and actively shit on progress or innovation. As soon as you see the monetary incentives posts like this start feeling like an insult to your intelligence, whether they fundamentally have a point or not.
- skybrian 5y agoGood to know that it’s a political minefield. It doesn’t help to understand whether it works, though? Maybe someone who has actually investigated will have something to say?
- lawn 5y agoAt the same time, if LN doesn't work then BTC is completely and utterly obsolete. And finally, it's not just "a Bitcoin Cash viewpoint" and labeling it as such does the criticism a big disservice.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- idiotsecant 5y agoNot to say that you're making this point, but I would argue that if Bitcoin is obsolete and irrelevant than Bitcoin Cash most certainly is equally irrelevant and obsolete. The Bitcoin Cash approach to distributed database design is kind of like seeing a car with a 1kw engine, realizing that it will never be able to reach orbit, and putting a 100kw, diesel-electric hybrid engine in it instead. I think it's undeniably better, but in a direction orthogonal to what the protocol needs for long term usefulness - a more sustainable consensus mechanism with massively higher throughput.
- eluusive 5y ago
- ilaksh 5y agoTake a look at Algorand if you are looking for a high-performance cryptocurrency.
- rvz 5y agoVery well then. I will read its whitepaper. Nice to see other cryptocurrencies emerge but some of them will fail.
- baby 5y agoI made a video to explain parts of their consensus algorithm https://www.cryptologie.net/article/484/algorands-cryptographic-sortition/ https://www.cryptologie.net/article/484/algorands-cryptograp...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Konstruct 5y agoThe biases and cultish mentality of hardliners in the Bitcoin community make it difficult to have an honest discussion about these issues. There are interesting and nuanced security flaws listed here around both DoS and more recent routing fee exploits. My takeaway here is that there is a general lack of understanding and sufficient security testing around LN implementations. I wouldn't run my country on it but I wouldn't throw it all in the trash and abandon the concept like the author of the Github link is suggesting.
- mattwilsonn888 5y agoThat's a very manipulative comment to make. I don't own either, I am impartial, but both sides have their own money invested in what they see as the right way forward for a new technology. Both sides are at times horribly biased and I've seen more reasonable people on the BTC side by virtue of it being a larger and more well funded community.
- ricardolopes 5y agoLike others mentioned, this list is a mix of some valid known issues and some low quality bad-faith bashing filled with incorrections. It's also weird that it goes all the way back to 5 years ago, given how young this technology is and all the improvements it has seen since then. Anyway, I'm glad Lightning has been gaining momentum lately. Lots of innovation happening, and lots more still to do to address its current flaws.
- user-the-name 5y ago> lots more still to do to address its current flaws That is a bit of an understatement, given that actually implementing a routing algorithm that works at scale is an open problem in computer science with nobody even knowing where to begin.
- gwicks56 5y agodoesn't the internet route at scale?
- DennisP 5y agoThe internet doesn't have nodes that stop working if too many packets go through. Lightning nodes only work as long as they have enough liquidity to cover your transaction.
- ashwagary 5y agoRemember that the lightning network actually doubled in capacity recently over a few months and that channels increase in size as the bitcoin price goes up. Meaning a channel with $2000 of capacity today will have ~$20,000 of capacity by the next halving (assuming we continue the 10x trend) without any changes. This results is a decreasing failed transaction rate for increasing sizes of transactions as we move into the future.
- lawn 5y agoNot in a decentralized manner where nodes can enter and leave in a permissionless manner and in adverserial conditions.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- varajelle 5y agoSo this is a page made by a lightning network "hater", who just collected every bad article about it out there.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- joshsyn 5y agoSo you dismiss by attacking his character instead of refuting his claims by evidence?
- xiphias2 5y ago,,WARNING: If you try to use the Lightning Network (LN) you are at HIGH RISK of losing funds and it is not recommended or safe to do at this time or for the foreseeable future.'' This looks outdated. This warning was true a few years ago, but nowdays the risk is low enough for everyday use (as a checking account, not as a savings account).
- jeroenhd 5y agoHow is any system that risks spontaneously losing funds any better than just using the existing banking infrastructure that has this down to an absolute minimum? Of course market speculation has made any cryptocurrency system completely unusable for long term value storage so I wouldn't put my savings in there anyway, but even for a checking account the existence of risk of spontaneously losing money that you can never get back while using the system normally seems like a massive design flaw.
- xiphias2 5y agoIt's never spontaneous. Banks and transaction processors lose money regularly, they just don't expose merchant fees and chargbacks to the buyers directly, but when you remit money to another banking system or want to cash out your balance, you are exposed to those fees and times and limits. Bitcoin and lightning network exposes the end users to all the potential security issues, but gives finality and no bank bailouts in return.
- ogogmad 5y agoAre the security problems with Lightning fixable without resorting to centralised custodians? If people need Paypal to transact with Bitcoin, it undermines Bitcoin's selling point of decentralisation. Might as well use Paypal to transact in gold, which has the same economic properties as Bitcoin, but doesn't involve expending enormous amounts of energy doing Proof Of Work. I've never owned BCH, and I was once an owner of BTC who steered clear of BCH, but I have to admit that the BCH solution has the major advantages of simplicity and tried-and-provenness. It's tried-and-proven because it doesn't make any additions to the algorithm Bitcoin uses, which after 11 years of experience we know works. If you want a computationally secure system, then you want it to have exactly the aforementioned qualities. I guess if gigabyte/USD prices for storage devices were to drop fast enough, and if it were possible to turn down the latency of transactions without compromising the safety of the network, then maybe the Big Block solution could work? I'd still be worried about surges in latency when there are increases in demand. The LN approach seems very complicated and experimental, and involves playing with real money. It's been in development since 2017 and is perpetually 12 months away from being ready. Some papers introducing attacks list numerous difficult tradeoffs that need to be made to make the network secure against them. The descriptions of it I've seen online seem naive and simplistic compared to the reality. Complexity is antithetical to security and correctness.
- dmm 5y ago> because it doesn't make any additions to the algorithm Bitcoin uses I haven't paid attention to BCH in a while but when it was released they had changes to the difficulty calculation that allowed difficulty to drop before the normal 2016 block interval. In principle this could give miners greater control over inflation. I'm not saying it's good or bad but it is a change to the bitcoin algorithm.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- smoyer 5y agoWas the algorithm changed or just a constant/variable. I'm not as familiar with how mining difficulty changes but the reward halvening is based on a relatively simple algorithm that uses a constant of 210000 (blocks). Changing that constant doesn't change the algorithm but certainly changes the behavior of the system. In this case, the security of the system is clearly not changed when the constant is changed. My understanding of mining difficulty is that you could tune it without compromising security so long as it's hard enough to provide dampening to the system. Right now it's adjusted to produce one block every 10 minutes on average. Ultimately, if you want to keep the algorithm you need to either allow bigger blocks or allow blocks to be produced more often.
- eraad 5y agoThis is just a list of links with no context or real technical analysis. I guess you are comparing LN to something else, in that case you should too make a list of links of the problems and fraud issues with, for example, fiat based payment networks or as another example, real adoption issues for things such as bcash. And if your objective is to discard LN because of those issues, those same issues do not seem to matter in the real world where people are actually using LN for real transactions every day all over the world. This is public data you can check yourself. Anyways, I think this list of links is biased and doesn’t add value to someone trying to understand modern payment networks.
- DennisP 5y agoSeems to me the most critical flaw is that you have to be online to receive funds, unless the sender is directly connected to you instead of hopping through intermediaries. This is inherent to the way the whole idea works[1]. Your only options are to either keep a lightning node online yourself, or to trust another node to custody your funds. At scale I think most people would do the latter, which sorta breaks the whole point of "p2p digital cash." [1] https://github.com/moneybutton/yours-channels/blob/master/docs/gentle-lightning.md https://github.com/moneybutton/yours-channels/blob/master/do...
- orena 5y agoNot true - https://github.com/breez/LightningRod https://github.com/breez/LightningRod
- schemescape 5y agoCan you clarify how that is different from what the parent poster said? > or to trust another node to custody your funds
- sjtindell 5y agoWho can look at defi exchanges, bridges, and wrapped tokens, and think that any particular coins technology is going to matter?