6 ms·
Isn't protected class an american legal term? Seems weirdly ameri-centric for a document of this nature. Not to mention that gay people weren't even a protected
by bawolff 5y ago
Isn't protected class an american legal term? Seems weirdly ameri-centric for a document of this nature. Not to mention that gay people weren't even a protected class in the usa until last year afaik. Not exactly a very inclusive definition.
Not to mention the implication that harrasment is somehow ok against people who are not members of the protected class? I appreciate minorities get a lot of shit that others don't, but its not like bigioted assholes are the only people who harrass other people.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoLike it or not, the ameri-centric views spill around the world causing tensions and misunderstandings. In countries with practically no colored people and no history of slavery certain things seem a bit ridiculous if imposed on the whole community.
- brabel 5y agoWhich countries do you think have no slavery in their history?
- dym_sh 5y agothose re/formed within last 100 years. (and those who actively deny its existence /s)
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoYou are right. It also depends if you include serfdom in slavery. In any case, just to generalize, the countries that practiced slavery were mostly those that colonized the world the most. Many of those who didn't colonize the world used serfs, like most of Eastern Europe. For these people there is no cultural association between slavery and the present. Also the proportions are different: in most countries the non-serfs were a relatively small minority. So waking up one day and reading that, say, all references to slavery are banned seems somewhat strange in other cultures.
- tekknik 5y agohttps://brill.com/view/book/9789004381735/BP000002.xml?language=en https://brill.com/view/book/9789004381735/BP000002.xml?langu...
- _lazlo 5y agoI find this offensive
- raxxorrax 5y agoHow many people in the OOS community or elsewhere did you meet that were in favor of enslaving people. Sometimes it is necessary to ask naive questions to determine if you dig yourself into something.
- SturgeonsLaw 5y agoCoCs themselves, and the wider identity politics culture war, are also extremely Ameri-centric. > the implication that harrasment is somehow ok against people who are not members of the protected class? There is a subset (I like to think that they're the fringe, but have no numbers to back that up) of those who engage in identity politics who do believe that bigotry does not apply when the target is the dominant demographic.
- blueflow 5y agoSomehow these people also tend to be the ones who have their pronouns in their twitter bio. Am i the only one noticing that correlation?
- type0 5y agoit is the depiction of in-group https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ingroups_and_outgroups https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ingroups_and_outgroups Modern tribalism at it's finest
- roenxi 5y ago> CoCs themselves, and the wider identity politics culture war, are also extremely Ameri-centric. An idea can be both a good one and political. And indeed a good idea while Ameri-centric. The risk is that this might be a status play by authoritarians, who very rarely have good ideas and typically do a lot of damage once they get in to power. I suspect actual minorities & protected classes are more worried about authoritarians than racist jokes. If they aren't they should be.
- lsiebert 5y agoI've never seen anybody suggest that you can't be bigoted against a dominant group. I have seen it suggested that specific terms like racism and sexism are not generic terms that apply to any sort of discrimination along racial, ethnic or in the case of sexism along gender lines, but apply specifically to actions that maintain or reinforce the power of dominant groups and existing privileges and positions that advantage them, and that trying to expand those terms to describe all discrimination serves to obfuscate and minimize the existing structural and institutional power disparities. Or to analogize, if my boss hates me, that's probably a big problem for me and my work. If alternatively hate my boss, that's not really a problem in the same way for my boss. I can't fire them, or decide what projects they can work on. They aren't the reverse of each other, because the power dynamic isn't the same.
- mikojan 5y ago> Isn't protected class an american legal term? Protected class ("geschützte Gruppe") is a commonly understood concept in Germany, too.
- Oak_ 5y agoThe abstracting concept of "protected group" is not commonly understood. I had never heard of it before this thread. Anti discrimination of course is, but not this specific term. Neither in the German Wikipedia nor in the Duden (German dictionary) or on the website of the "Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung" (Federal Agency for Civic Education) can I find any reference to "geschützte Gruppe". The German constitution, explicitly states: "No person shall be favoured or disfavoured because of sex, parentage, race, language, homeland and origin, faith or religious or political opinions. No person shall be disfavoured because of disability.". This is often emphasized in things like job postings, but never in abbreviated/conceptualized form.
- bitwize 5y ago> Not to mention the implication that harrasment is somehow ok against people who are not members of the protected class? The GNOME CoC gleefully states they will ignore complaints of racism against whites and sexism against cis men because "we prioritize the safety of marginalized groups over the comfort of privileged groups".
- simiones 5y agoThat's not what that line means at all. That line means that an argument like `let's stop using gender-neutral language in our documentation, it's easier to just say "he" instead of "the user"` won't fly: this type of argument prioritizes the comfort of a privileged group (males) over the safety/well-being of a marginalized group (women and non-binary people).
- utexaspunk 5y agoI'm all for being gender-neutral for the sake of neutrality, but the idea that the use of "he" somehow hurts people's safety or well-being sounds a bit absurd to me.
- Fellshard 5y agoThat is a complete misreading of the clear statement that text is making!
- _-david-_ 5y agoYou are going to have to explain how using 'he' can harm the safety and well being of somebody else.
- OJFord 5y agoProtected characteristic in the UK: https://www.gov.uk/discrimination-your-rights https://www.gov.uk/discrimination-your-rights EU has the concept but doesn't name them in that way, countries implementing them may do in their respective language (someone else has already commented as such for German): https://ec.europa.eu/info/aid-development-cooperation-fundamental-rights/your-rights-eu/know-your-rights/equality/non-discrimination_en https://ec.europa.eu/info/aid-development-cooperation-fundam...
- bawolff 5y agoRight, many countries have similar ideas. They all define them slightly differently. The americentric part is using the american legal term of art in an international context and assuming everyone just understands it, and that its a reasonable definition in context. The idea that minorities exist and should have some additional legal protection is not the aspect that is americentric.
- OJFord 5y agoMy point is that I don't think it is using it as an American legal term, it's using it generically for the the broadly understood idea, a lot being common. At least that would be my assumption. They could hardly go out of their way to find a synonym not in use by any country, and then keep checking in case some country started using it and people started interpreting the document as using it in the sense of that country's law specifically. It's not an American legal document, so unless it explicitly defines the term as such, that's not what it means, it's just words. If it said 'murder' or 'jaywalking' we wouldn't pick a country that uses those terms to interpret them in its legal sense, we'd just understand the broad sense of what they are anywhere, even in countries where they are not used ('jaywalking' here in the UK). > The idea that minorities exist and should have some additional legal protection Again, that's not what it is. The legal protection is against discrimination based on your <something> such as race or ethnicity. No matter whether the particular value in your case is held by the majority or a minority of people.
- bawolff 5y ago
- anothernewdude 5y agoThe whole movement is American colonialism.
- k7ra 5y agoYou have what is unfortunately a common misunderstanding of the term protected class. Nobody is IN a protected class, because protected classes are not any particular group of people, like middle class or working class. In the civil rights act of 1964 protected classes are the classifications that the law refers to such as race, religion, etc. So it is illegal to discriminate against someone because of their religion, but it does not protect any religion over any other. For race, race itself is the protected class. So it is illegal to discriminate against anyone based on race, not just black people or Asians, for example.