5 ms·
It's a misleading way of calculating the number, since it refers to all of the future debt obligations, including Social Security out many decades -- but also i
by jfengel 5y ago
It's a misleading way of calculating the number, since it refers to all of the future debt obligations, including Social Security out many decades -- but also ignoring the fact that we'll be collecting taxes all that time.
It's a bit like concluding that you're a million dollars in debt because you are going to need to buy food for the rest of your life. I suppose it's true -- it is something you need to plan for. But it's misleading to suggest that it means you're automatically destined for bankruptcy.
The fact is that Social Security is in trouble: the pay-as-you-go plan doesn't work with an increasing lifespan. The establishment of the Trust Fund didn't really solve it -- it really just increased the size of the federal government without having to explicitly borrow money (and then still somehow managed to also have to explicitly borrow money).
But that doesn't make "$146T" a meaningful number. The meaningful number is 2033, the year Social Security is projected to run out of money. Also, conveniently, the year I qualify for Social Security -- this is something Gen X'ers have always expected, though it got worse during the pandemic.
That doesn't automatically mean we won't get anything, but it does mean that the government is going to have an even harder time meeting its obligations.
- megablast 5y agoWouldn’t the date it runs out of money be pushed out further due to increased deaths during the pandemic?
- ceejayoz 5y agoThat might be confounded a bit by https://www.ssa.gov/benefits/survivors/ https://www.ssa.gov/benefits/survivors/.
- smaryjerry 5y ago600,000 over the last two years may seem like a lot of deaths at face value but over the same period of time about 4,500,000 died from other non COVID things and 6,000,000 people were born. So the deaths from COVID are relatively small in comparison. Plus the debt only increased due to COVID as they printed and spent trillions upon trillions of dollars.
- JumpCrisscross 5y agoWould also note that if you're incorporating unfunded future liabilities, it also makes sense to cancel out intergovernmental debt, e.g. Treasuries held by the Federal Reserve or by agencies.
- nickff 5y agoYou can't quite 'cancel out intergovernmental debt', as their sale (to extract their value) would cause devaluation. I am not sure how you would model the loss in value.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> You can't quite 'cancel out intergovernmental debt', as their sale (to extract their value) would cause devaluation Not saying the U.S. default on that debt. Just that, for accounting purposes, if you're including far-in-the-future liabilities, you should also take into account the fact that every dollar of interest paid by the U.S. Treasury to the Fed ends up, more or less, back in the Treasury's account.
- Bostonian 5y agoIf you were valuing a company you would add the value of the pension fund but subtract the present value of the pension liabilities. When considering the level of indebtedness of the Federal government, I think liabilities such as Social Security and Medicare should be included.
- Kranar 5y ago>ignoring the fact that we'll be collecting taxes all that time. This is all wrong and it does not ignore this. The calculation only includes the portion of future obligations that can not be funded based on future revenue estimates. It does not simply take future expenses without taking into account future revenue as that would be patently absurd. Furthermore it only includes future obligations that have currently been committed to, so for example it does not make projections about people who will at some point in the future be enrolled into Social Security (for example people not yet born).
- DFHippie 5y ago> The meaningful number is 2033, the year Social Security is projected to run out of money. This is the year the trust fund runs out of money, at which point Social Security won't be able to meet its full obligations, only what it can cover with current payroll taxes. Social Security can't run out of money unless the taxes that support it are eliminated. "Social Security won't be available for you Gen X'ers" is misleading propaganda spread by people who want Social Security to go away. When the trust fund is tapped out, unless we remove the income cap, Social Security will be less generous. It won't go away. If we remove or lift the income cap, this problem goes away altogether.
- tibbon 5y agoRemoving the income cap is really a clear way to mitigate this problem greatly. From what I understand it doesn't fix it entirely. I wonder if we could put SS on capital gains, even at 1%. That would help this include investment gains.
- BitwiseFool 5y agoPlease, no. Social Security was never meant to be funded this way. It was originally supposed to be paid for by a tax on labor, originally a minuscule at ~3% but now it is around 12.5%. It was supposed to be something that would pay out roughly what you paid in. But now it looks like people want to decouple that aspect of Social Security and turn it into a general wealth redistribution program.
- ethbr0 5y agoRemoving the income cap for social security tax ($142,800 for 2021) would be interesting, because that's also the max for benefit purposes [0]. 35 years at max = max social security benefits. [0] https://www.ssa.gov/OACT/ProgData/retirebenefit1.html https://www.ssa.gov/OACT/ProgData/retirebenefit1.html
- dragonwriter 5y agoApplying the full amount of payroll (both SS and Medicare) tax to income regardless of origin, including capital gains (and the both-halves self-employment style to all non-wage income) or amount (uncapping contributions), while also uncapping benefits (but adding additional “bend points” above the current cap so the revenue-to-obligation ratio for high incomes is better) is a great way to secure the programs, increase fairness of treatment of labor and other income, increase fairness of taxation of low vs. high income, and extend qualification for social insurance to people of moderate means but atypical income patterns. But it means that people with disproportionate political clout would be taxed more heavily than in the present circumstances, so it would face an uphill battle.
- matthewdgreen 5y ago> The meaningful number is 2033, the year Social Security is projected to run out of money. This comment is excellent, except for one clarification: "Social Security" is not going to run out of money. The "Old-Age and Survivors Insurance Trust Fund" will run out of money in 2033 (the disability insurance fund is solvent until 2057). After this happens -- and assuming no action by Congress -- Social Security will still be able to pay 76% of benefits to retirees based solely on payroll taxes collected. This isn't a great outcome, but it's far from insolvency.
- platz 5y agothe government can't be insolvent to by owing money to itself.
- jfengel 5y agoThat specific fund can be insolvent. It's a specific pot of money set aside for the purpose. The government can fill it, but it will need to pass laws to do so.
- throw0101a 5y ago> Social Security will still be able to pay 76% of benefits to retirees based solely on payroll taxes collected. 78% actually. See Figure II.D2: * https://www.ssa.gov/OACT/TR/2021/tr2021.pdf https://www.ssa.gov/OACT/TR/2021/tr2021.pdf It falls to 74% by 2095.
- hartator 5y ago> But that doesn't make "$146T" a meaningful number. If you have to pay annuity to a relative until they die, I don't think it reflects a good picture of your net worth to ignore that number either.
- listless 5y agoIf I’ve learned anything during the pandemic, it’s “that’s not how money works”. If it runs out, they’ll just borrow more. The real question is at what point are we so leveraged that we default on bonds because we can’t meet our obligations? 10 years? 100 years? I don’t think anyone can answer this. But this is how it will likely end.
- OldHand2018 5y agoIsn't it more like 3 weeks, according to Janet Yellen?
- smaryjerry 5y agoThat’s if we don’t borrow any more money beyond the debt limit before then. The real question is when will people stop lending to the borrower? That will be when inflation gets high enough to our pace the rates you can safely receive elsewhere. For example, if inflation is 3% per year and you are only getting 2% yield, it doesn’t make sense to lend anymore because your getting about -1% return… unless every other country with a guaranteed return is returning even less due to their own inflation. Say Germany’s rates are 0% but inflation is 0%, lenders should simply be holding German dollars and stop lending to the US. Then the US will default dude to not being able to borrow.
- bscphil 5y agoThe real misleading part, to the point of being actively malicious, is "Each Taxpayer's Share: $951k". This is intended to make the median viewer, who will never see that much money at once in their entire life (and will take 20+ years to even make that much before-tax), feel that the Federal government is being irresponsible. It's an obvious push for fiscal conservatism which, crucially may or may not be warranted by the actual facts. To state the obvious, most people out there do not make enough money to plausibly pay one million dollars in taxes. Therefore they will not be paying one million dollars in taxes (you can't squeeze blood from a stone). The inevitable result is that either the U.S. government is doomed to go bankrupt (what they want you to think), or rich people will be contributing more than that to the United States' debt obligation (hint: they already are).
- bassman9000 5y agofeel that the Federal government is being irresponsible. It is. https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/government-spending https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/government-spendi...
- belltaco 5y agoIf it really is then why are bogus arguments like the OP used to make it seem so?
- nradov 5y agoA sovereign can't literally go bankrupt. Instead when debt service inevitably becomes unmanageable then the Federal government will most likely force creditors to take a cram down.
- bscphil 5y agoSure, not in a literal sense (to the extent they manage internal affairs with a sovereign fiat currency, it's not possible for them to be under water in that currency), but it's possible for them to destroy their own credit due to defaulting on debt obligations to the point that the economy suffers greatly and enters a hard-to-control downward spiral for many years. I think that's what most people understand by the concept of the government going "bankrupt".
- throw0101a 5y ago> The fact is that Social Security is in trouble: the pay-as-you-go plan doesn't work with an increasing lifespan. The situation is not ideal, but it isn't cataclysmic: > The authors of the most recent report even took their calculations out to the year 2095. At that point, they estimate payroll taxes should still be able to cover 74% of payouts to Social Security recipients. * https://awealthofcommonsense.com/2021/09/can-young-people-still-count-on-social-security/ https://awealthofcommonsense.com/2021/09/can-young-people-st... The report in question: * https://www.ssa.gov/OACT/TR/2021/tr2021.pdf https://www.ssa.gov/OACT/TR/2021/tr2021.pdf Two possible solutions (non-exhaustive): increase pay cheque contributions, use general revenues to make up the shortfall.
- smaryjerry 5y agoI thought it could be misleading as well but it is not just calculating the “food you’ll need,” it is also calculating receipts over the same time that pay for food. It’s like saying you promised to buy a TV for $900 in December and by December you will only have $300. That means you will have to borrow $600 before then to meet that promise. Does that mean you owe $600 now, no, it does mean you either can’t buy the tv or will have to borrow that much more. It is essentially debt.
- EastOfTruth 5y ago28T or 150T ... either way it is really bad....