5 ms·
It's like the complaints about Wikipedia you read on Hacker News. Someone smart who knows something wants to add it and gets tangled up in "useless" beaurocrac
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
It's like the complaints about Wikipedia you read on Hacker News.
Someone smart who knows something wants to add it and gets tangled up in "useless" beaurocracy. Why can't they just let me do it!?
Because if they did just let people do stuff, then lots of other people you consider idiots would have already done things you consider stupid and or bad.
Basically everyone wants rules for the idiots so they don't ruin things and at the same time to not be included in the list of idiots.
That would sound harsh though, so mostly people just moan about rules, rather than them not being exempted, but I don't think anyone genuinely wants the rules to be dropped for everyone.
- Dumblydorr 5y agoWhat complaints about Wikipedia are you referring to? I post a lot on HN and I also edit Wikipedia. I don't recall any complaints of that kind.
- photochemsyn 5y agoI block Wikipedia from all search results, mainly because so many links to sources are broken or paywalled. This is kind of ridiculous for an outfit that claims all information must be properly sourced and no 'original research' is allowed. It would seem fairly easy for Wikipedia to examine its own pages for broken links and flag any such link (and its related content) as unreliable. Wonder what that would look like...
- detaro 5y agoThe main criticism of wikipedia here afaik is of "deletionism", and I don't think that framing fits for that - most people are completely happy if other people also get to make articles about their pet interests.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- someguydave 5y agoI want no idiots, not rules.
- elpatoisthebest 5y agoWe are all somewhere on the idiot scale.
- SonicScrub 5y agoNot only that, but we have multiple on differing levels of the idiot scale depending on the topic at hand. The biggest idiots I've encountered are brilliant people outside their knowledge domain.
- Bootvis 5y agoThe other way around I hope ;)
- SonicScrub 5y ago*The biggest idiots I've encountered are brilliant people within their knowledge domain. Exhibit A: me writing ;p
- foldr 5y agoDon’t worry :) I read it as “The biggest idiots I've encountered are brilliant people (who are [idiots when they are]) outside their knowledge domain.”
- andrekandre 5y ago> we have multiple on differing levels of the idiot scale depending on the topic at hand or even depending on the time of day, or current stress/work levels alot of things can affect the idiot scale...
- v-erne 5y ago
- im3w1l 5y agoWikipedia doesn't have an idiot problem. It has a smart people with an agenda problem.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoIt also has an idiot problem. The idiots are there, and you will occasionally run into them. I've found pages in the course of natural browsing which were suffering from both obvious and very subtle vandalism.
- closeparen 5y agoThe solution for that is review by a smart person who is empowered to consider the context and use her professional judgement, not a static set of criteria.
- photochemsyn 5y agoUnfortunately, a 'smart person' in the employ of one industry might not agree with a 'smart person' in the employ of another industry. For example, consider two smart Wikipedia editors working on the climate change and global warming pages... one from the fossil fuel sector, one from the renewable energy sector.
- closeparen 5y agoThe sensibilities of your gatekeepers are your organization’s culture. If you don’t like them, you have a deeper problem which rules aren’t going to fix.
- someguydave 5y agoPrecisely, rules are implemented by people, and people are often idiots.
- vkk8 5y ago1) Such smart person might not even exist 2) If she exists, and is as smart as she should be, she will realize quite quickly that her power can be used for personal gain and she will become corrupted. Power corrupts, etc. and you can't really entertain any kind of organizational solution without considering game theory of the situation.