6 ms·
MovieLabs publishes common ontology for production
- unchocked 5y agoThis is great - now we can have algorithmic production of output from data-driven script bots!
- satyanash 5y agoThis looks like a large scale domain modelling problem for the movie production process. This is the last place I was expecting an overlap between computer engineering and film-making. But it is not surprising given that large parts of film-making are now supported by software, which has a tendency to direct the evolution of terminology and concepts. After a cursory glance at the model, it starts with a fairly generic set of primitives: Task, Asset, Participant, Context and Relationship. It then creates further instances based on this idea. I'm sure other industries could also benefit from collaborative modelling of their problem domains like this.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- beaconstudios 5y agoOntology is part of philosophy, and concerns itself with what exists; domain modelling is ontology applied to systems (typically software and/or bureaucratic systems).
- danpalmer 5y agoMaybe I'm just a huge nerd, but this is awesome. The product I work on ends up doing a lot of work for order processing, stock management, logistics, etc. There is no industry standard ontology for anything. All off the shelf software works in different ways. Terminology is somewhat consistent but not at all formally defined. The idea of being able to build software (or human processes) around a well understood ontology is great. Full software interoperability is a long way off, but building integration points is rarely the challenge when integrating, the real challenge is in adapting one way of thinking about a problem to fit someone else's entirely different model. If this is close enough to reality then it doesn't even need lots of parties on board with "supporting" it, they could already be close enough. Having it all written down is a great next step that should enable a lot more products to enter the marketplace.
- danachow 5y agoBetween ISO, UN CEFACT/OASIS, the now irrelevant/repivoted OMG, etc it isn’t like the idea is a new one or that anything isn’t written down - there are formal standards (insert xkcd here). The incentives for widespread adoption are just not there.
- nerdponx 5y agoMaybe the problem is too much generality? An industry-specific ontology seems a lot more tractable than a general purpose ontology for all industries.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jmole 5y agoAnd cost - most standards organizations charge money for implementations and for training. I find it no coincidence that the most widely implemented standards are the ones that you can learn about and implement for free.
- alvarlagerlof 5y agoEli5?
- InitialLastName 5y agoThe movie and film production process currently involves a large web of organizations, including both traditional movie production studios and software development firms. These firms have to be able to communicate effectively and work together, so they need a common language that they can use to describe concepts. Since (to paraphrase) the second hardest thing about software development is naming things, and software developers/filmmakers are likely to be unfamiliar with the other field's terminology, this guide is an attempt to provide suggested names of things such that everyone understands one another.
- karaterobot 5y agoAn ontology describes the things in a system and the relationships between them. By relationships, I don't just mean A is related in some way to B, I mean (for example) A modifies B, or A requires B, or even A eats lunch with B. In short, they relate things to each other using whatever the verbs in that domain are. Imagine a database schema, but with richer information. In theory, if you have a good ontology, you can translate an expert human's understanding of a system to something a computer can also understand. So if, for example, you were going to write software to orchestrate the production of a massive film, or a commercial production studio, you might benefit from a common ontology for film production. In practice, ontologies in the wild have had limited success, historically, compared to expectations in the academic world around the end of the last century.
- ok123456 5y agoAre there any real success stories for "ontolgies" like this? It seems like a lot of them are made, but they're ultimately not that useful. I've been forced to use some, and it seems that someone got paid a lot of money to come up with something that's incomplete and poorly models the domain. So the net change is some XML doodads that no one really wanted or needed.
- mercurialsolo 5y agoModern production pipelines have a lot of dynamic human fueled workflows with orchestration - having a common syntax definitely helps those in the control room and operating systems and tools have a common way to exchange - especially in a remote setup. The netflix production team also has done a great job of standardizing the vocabulary across their production systems. A lot of these ontologies depend on adoption in the organization and enforcement and without that these efforts really are show and of low utility.
- halfmatthalfcat 5y agoDisparate ontologies are ripe in the medical field (SNOMED, ICD 9/10, etc) and there are companies[1] trying to map between them for better interopt between healthcare networks. [1] https://clinicalarchitecture.com https://clinicalarchitecture.com
- danachow 5y agoMedical ontologies are different because there are two enormous economic incentives for their adoption: billing, in the US or any private healthcare - and medical research much of which is highly incentivized by the pharma, device, and diagnostic industries. Improving healthcare interop is not something that happens unless it is subsidized or penalized. 50 years of healthcare IT with systems that are basically the same with some new window dressing have proven that.
- cbetti 5y agoYes. In the early 2000s Endeca made use of several public ontologies to enhance its information access and summarization products for clients. One particularly compelling example that comes to mind was an ontology involving public companies, figures, events, and relationships that was combined with NLP (entity and concept identification) over semi-structured content on the ETL side, and faceted search and navigation on the retrieval side, to replace a research portal for a major UK newspaper in the mid 2000s. The results were mind blowing.
- georgeecollins 5y agoIn the US there are guilds that have rules that decide who can claim what production and who is qualified to do what job. That is one of the main reasons why while film is really specialized ("gaffers", "grips") you can on a US production know you have people who know how to do what they are supposed. It lets huge movies staff up or staff down really fast. I am sure there are people who like the model or hate the model, but its creative success in the twentieth is hard to argue with. I think as work forces become more flexible, it is something to think about.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tzm 5y agoNon-paywall: https://outline.com/KYk6bp https://outline.com/KYk6bp
- Animats 5y agoAutomation was supposed to prevent this. Years ago, I knew a B-list director who did some of the early films that combined animation and live action. What he wanted to do was make movies with a team of 20 or 30 people. What he was stuck doing was managing a factory with 100-200 people. He was hoping that automation would get the size of the team down to where he could get back to directing. Much as word processing and publishing tools vastly reduced the size of the team needed to edit and print a book. That didn't happen. Instead, it got worse. Much worse. Look at the credits at the end of a modern action movie. There are about a thousand people involved, at maybe 50 different subcontractors. Today there's a big pre-production and pre-visualization phase just to develop the plans and tooling to make the movie. The budgets are so big that nobody can afford a failure, so efforts to reduce risk dominate. Which is why most movies are now sequels or part of some "franchise".