4 ms·
Is it the official stance of the CDC or WHO that a country with 99% of eligible adults double-vaccinated would have no need for masks, lockdowns, social distanc
by michaelt 5y ago
Is it the official stance of the CDC or WHO that a country with 99% of eligible adults double-vaccinated would have no need for masks, lockdowns, social distancing, travel restrictions or other restrictions?
I'm vaccinated, and in a country with 80% of people on two doses and 90% on one dose. But we still have a lot of cases, and a lot of people stuck on ventilators in hospitals.
- mcguire 5y agoThe UAE? 300 new cases / day, 5500 active cases, and 2 deaths / day, for a country with 10M people. (3 new cases / day, 55 active cases, 0.02 deaths / day, per 100,000.) Compared with, say, the US: 112,000 new cases / day, 9,800,000 active cases, 2000 deaths / day. (34 new cases / day, 3000 active cases, 0.6 deaths / day, per 100,000.) I'd say you're in better shape than we are. (https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus)
- refurb 5y agoThis always makes me laugh. The virus comes in waves and someone will point out one country is doing “better” when it’s just the fact the country is past the latest wave. I even saw different regions of my country do this. Fast forward 2 months and the situations are reversed and so is the finger pointing. It’s absurd.
- avhon1 5y agoNobody is willing to take a stance that strong, because they can't know that for sure. There could be further viral mutations, an unexpectedly sudden decline in immunity from vaccines, a string of unlucky superspreader events, a completely unrelated pandemic, or any of a lot of other uncontrollable, unknowable factors that could make continued restrictions necessary in an almost-fully-vaccinated population. It's an unfortunate circumstance that 90% of people being fully vaccinated might not be enough to stop COVID-19 in its tracks. Even just 1% of people being unvaccinated makes millions of people who could catch, mutate, and transmit the virus. Especially if those people were loosely clustered together, and didn't take precautions against spreading disease, they could possibly keep the virus active (and hospitals busy) for a long time on their own.
- tunesmith 5y agoIt depends on the R0 of the mutation, and the efficacy of the vaccine. For instance if Delta has an R0 of 8, and we're 100% vaccinated, and the vaccine has an efficacy of 85% against infection, the resultant Rt would be 1.2: 8 * (1 - (1 * 0.85)) So that means that some other form of mitigation on top of 100% vaccination would be necessary to stop the spread. But for mutations with lower R0, or higher vaccine efficacy, herd immunity may still be possible.
- nradov 5y agoThat's kind of a moot point since the Delta variant has now out competed all other variants in the wild. If another new variant takes over from Delta it's unlikely to have a lower R0. At this point nothing we do can really stop the spread. Everyone should get vaccinated if they can because herd immunity won't protect anyone from infection. https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#variant-proportions https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#variant-proportion... https://www.businessinsider.com/delta-variant-made-herd-immunity-not-possible-astrazeneca-developer-2021-8?r=US&IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com/delta-variant-made-herd-immu...
- tunesmith 5y ago> At this point nothing we do can really stop the spread. Everyone should get vaccinated if they can because herd immunity won't protect anyone from infection. I think that's an overstatement of the links you are sharing. Several parts of the country have pushed Rt < 1, so there are clearly things we can do to stop the spread, through a combination of vaccination and other mitigation measures. And the definition of herd immunity is literally what protects people from infection. (Herd immunity includes vaccine immunity.) And even before the HIT, vaccination reduces contagion, reduces the doubling rate, buys time to implement further mitigation to drive down Rt < 1, and saves lives. Anyway, what the Astra Zeneca guy is saying is just that our vaccines are not effective enough against infection to get Rt < 1 on their own. mRNA Vaccines do have efficacy against infection, and additional effectiveness against infecting others; it's just that they're still not quite as effective as their effectiveness against hospitalization and death. Improved vaccines, or the third-shots happening now (which do temporarily improve infection efficacy) improve those stats. Herd immunity isn't yet theoretically impossible even if it's a practical impossibility in our populations. It probably is true that we can't go back to the way we were pre-covid, no distancing, no masks, and avoid COVID spread. We're not there and may never be since there's a likelihood that some variant of COVID will be endemic. But there's plenty we can do - vaccination, and mitigation to get Rt < 1 during spikes. Those two practices protect people from infection. Agreed that everyone able should get vaccinated.