5 ms·
> Private companies seem to be the only ones with the resources to store all the video content we produce Definitely not. It's an addressing problem. I guarant
by mindslight 5y ago
> Private companies seem to be the only ones with the resources to store all the video content we produce
Definitely not. It's an addressing problem. I guarantee plenty of people have the youtube video downloaded with more redundancy than Google, and the OP even has the source files. The problem is that Youtube became the canonical URL for referencing the video, assuming singular power to control that address based on the flawed protocol of http(s), and now there's going to be a lot of strife and damage as we readjust at a higher level.
- filleokus 5y agoOoh. Crazy, not at all thought through, probably bad, legislation idea popped in to my head: EU Data Address Ownership Directive: All services that allow users to upload data that is then made publicly available, MUST have a method for the user to create a 301 redirect to another location where the content is available. (Maybe allowing for a "Are you sure you want to follow the link to https://alternative.com https://alternative.com and leave Youtube? We have no responsibility nor control for the content on alternative.com")
- nradov 5y agoMaybe we need a new URI scheme and associated address resolution system for videos and other user generated content?
- janandonly 5y agoThe proposed solution of a different URI scheme exists. It's called IPFS.
- tremon 5y agoOr, a little older, magnet:
- wvh 5y agoAssuming Youtube video IDs are unique even in the case of removal, we could just create a URN space for Youtube, say urn:google:youtube:<video id>. Another option would be a content-bassed hash, but that would make quality variations of the same video unrelated. Once you switch to a permanent resource identifier, you don't need to rely on Google for locating the video anymore. That won't replace Youtube as the massive video store it is, which is probably not a (financially, legally) feasible undertaking even on a national level, but at least you untangled one part of the kludge.