8 ms·
When listeners pay attention to stories, their heart rates rise and fall in sync
- raxxorrax 5y ago> [...] could one day lead to new tools for measuring attentiveness, both in the classroom and the clinic. The day they will finally get me.
- prox 5y agoYeah, this really sounds sucky to use this in a classroom. Slacking is a basic human right! “Oh no, everything is not optimized 100% for efficiency!” sounds a lot like the Borg from Star Trek.
- d88 5y agoAs the list of ways to trigger and activate the chimp brain gets refined, how long before we end up with something like a Laser for society? The echo chambers on social media and reinforcement/amplification they produce seems to be very similar to the mechanism to generate coherent light. Does analogy break somehow? Instead of syncing waves or particles just button press and sync a bunch of humans brains. I guess armies and religion and politics and sports have been doing that (unsuprisingly through stories) but to achieve it instantly seems very possible the way things are going. I mean the Speed at which ppl on social media or news media or the russians (sorry russians! I just mean whoever is motivated enough) can get the herd to stampede in a partucular direction, seems to be increasing. How long before its instant? After all, its just chemicals being activated at the end of the day.
- playpause 5y ago> something like a Laser for society What does that mean?
- nxbso 5y agoIn a laser you are basically getting photons to behave exactly the same way. Trillions of them. To do that two things are required, keep a bunch of atoms continually excited by heat, electricity, whatever. And secondly, an echo chamber (think a tube with mirrors where photons fly back and forth). This sets up chain reactions. Each photon that flies thro an excited atom produces another photon which mysteriously has the exact same speed, color, phase as the original. Then you get a cascade as they bump into other excited atoms. The comment is saying, replace atoms with humans, photons with human action?, social media/news media/russians as source of excitation and amplification and you probably can get a whole bunch of humans in sync. Should point out no one really knew what to do with lasers for a long time after they were discovered.
- mistermann 5y agoIt's a stretched analogy, but humans do kind of exhibit the ability to behave either as individual "particles", but also in waves, kind of analogous to a large body of water when calm vs in storm conditions.
- LocalH 5y agoI mean, there's always the time it takes the signals to make it in or out. I think they estimate it at around 80ms? Seems like that'd be a hard cap (yes, our brains can compensate for that in some scenarios, but it doesn't always do it correctly, look at the phenomenon where you look at a ticking second hand and the very first tick seems like it lingers a bit longer than the following ones, because your brain literally lied to you about what it saw).
- eurasiantiger 5y agoNote that this doesn’t mean their hearts beat in sync, only that their heart rate tends to rise or fall in sync.
- rusk 5y agoIn fairness were it the meaning of synchronous that engineers are familiar with now that would be truly astounding. I’m happy to accept the more liberal interpretation of the term as not all knowledge of merit need be readily appreciated by the technical eye.
- B-Con 5y agoWhile interesting, not too surprising, right? Their heart rates will be low during the calm parts, high during the tense parts, etc.
- johnswas 5y agoIt depends though. If it's your mom talking, there won't be any heart rates at all.
- corobo 5y agos/synchronize/rise and fall in sync/ Maybe I'm being a bit of a jerk but.. yeah? The suspenseful parts of the story raise your heart rate and the relaxed parts go t'other way I'd be interested in knowing if this could be used for diagnosing mental disorder things such as sociopathy maybe
- wongarsu 5y agoIt's effectively measuring emotional response to fictional events, which sounds like a plausible way to diagnose a huge range of mental disorders. But if the subject wants to be diagnosed, why not just ask them how something made them feel? And if they don't want to be diagnosed (like you would expect for some sociopaths, pedophiles etc.) this won't help. If a full polygraph can't be proven to work against unwilling suspects, then one fourth of a polygraph won't work either.
- corobo 5y ago> just ask them how something made them feel Fair point. I was trying to throw the study a bone instead of declare it completely useless
- robertlagrant 5y agoI think it'll be good for developing a Voight-Kampff prototype.
- dougmwne 5y agoA silly study? But think of the use cases! The Wristband monitors everyone's heat rate and knows the correct response to each media input. "It seems you have stopped paying attention to your targeted advertising. Shall I replay your ads now?"
- teddyh 5y agoPlease drink a verification can.
- raesene9 5y agoI honestly will not be surprised when this comment gets turned into a start-up that gets funded... either this or the other obvious dystopian application, monitoring employees attention in meetings.
- dougmwne 5y agoI would be so screwed. They might as well start applying the electric shocks.
- withinboredom 5y agoSo would I. My heart rate rarely goes above 60 when sitting.
- imutemyteam 5y agoYou Kinky.
- teddyh 5y agoFake headline. This is not the usual meaning of the word “synchronize”. As many other commenters here point out, this makes the story a non-story. Strictly speaking, the headline is true in that the heart rates “synchronize”, but not the heart beats, which I would think that most people would mis-read the headline as.
- jb1991 5y agoAnd even then, the actual rate itself is unlikely to synchronize, only the delta on the rate over time. You don't put a bunch of people in a room, tell them all a story, and they all suddenly have 65 bpm rates.
- beeforpork 5y agoShoot. Just as I was just constructing the perfect murder story.
- PH01 5y agoAgreed. The headline is fascinating the content is appalling. PNAS reporting the shocking news that peoples heart rates tend to increase during the exciting part of a story and that an increased rate leads to higher correlation between subjects. Edit: Without naming any author in particular - does anyone else spot a pattern whereby certain researchers consistently hype their findings to the point of borderline dishonesty?
- agarsev 5y agoIn academia, you're often evaluated on "impact". So you have an incentive to be impactful, not truthful, and while many (most?) try to be honest in the content, hyping the title is an easy way to increase your metric (impact) while not having a very bad conscience because "everyone does it" and "the truth is in the contents, actually"
- kindle-dev 5y agoFake comment. The headline uses the word rates not beats. Not everything can be perfectly unambiguous all the time.
- anotheryou 5y agoSo basically: story telling works; the exciting parts of stories are exciting to more than one person at a time when told in public. %)
- tartoran 5y agoWhen people have a common shared experience they have similar responses, who would have thought!!!
- SimeVidas 5y agoI don’t know why, but whenever I check my heart rate with a stopwatch, my heart beats synchronize with the watch ticks almost immediately (my normal pulse is 60 bpm). You’d think the likelihood of that happening is fairly low, but it happens almost every time.
- aaron695 5y agoThe headline is a lie, of course. The idea is interesting. If the second derivative of heart beats is linked strongly to media and comprehension then your Fitbit like device can help with learning. As a startup your data is free. You could see the pattern of comprehension quickly on any media from user data, get the base line and use that to help others. In reality I'd bet the data is so weak you would not be able to use it for much. They found it statistically better than random. That's not enough to make calls off.
- lupire 5y agoTL;DR: People respond similarly to same stimulus. Heart rate response to excitement isn't primarily a function of who you are. Thanks for the verification research, but this is ancient common knowledge.
- motohagiography 5y agoAm following this topic from another thread on HN today about soundscapes and binaural beats, and what is the theoretical framework behind it, or is it just sympathetic magic? I was in a meeting yesterday about the truth and reconciliation stuff going on in Canada right now, and the first hour of the meeting was given to people who were sharing their experiences of residential schools by telling stories about them. The storytellers were fantastic, and one of them had a mesmerising and hypnotic effect that I was trying to isolate as a technique. I could see others attempting it as well. I had seen a similar story telling technique used by top professional stage actors in the past. When you watch the documentary, "Wild Wild Country," which is about charismatic spiritual leadership, they use a similar verbal mesmerism technique that can give people "chills," which are also physiological response, just not a cardiogram effect. Working in tech, one encounters improbable clusters of professors, behavioral economics readers, intelligence operatives, ad-tech designers, political campaign operatives, magicians, hypnotists, practitioners of so-called NLP, "pick up artists," con artists, and other people who practice and apply systematized methods of persuasion. My interest in it is mainly for experimenting with music, but my own practice of a simlar dynamic would be exercising craft as a writer. Of what is this synchronization and mesmerism the effect?
- Lidbob 5y agoQuantum Phase Coherence. Sustaining it requires a lot of energy though.
- warent 5y agoI remember studies that showed brainwaves also synchronize between people who are interacting, especially intimately, and close romantic partners who have been together for many years often maintain a synchronization even when apart. Maybe related to that? In any case the human body and mind are wonderfully mysterious https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/hyperscans-show-how-brains-sync-as-people-interact/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/hyperscans-show-h...
- mcbuilder 5y agoI'm not an expert on this exact subject, but my PhD was in computational neuroscience, specifically spiking neural networks, and I became a bit interested in the area of binaural beats. On exposure to binaural beats, neural networks in the brain can to synchronize in patterns that can be observed in EEG recordings (eg, Theta or Beta oscillations). So, while the science is conflicting and not settled there is plenty of actual research into this area. See https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00426-018-1066-8 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00426-018-1066-8 for a recent meta-analysis.
- ramblenode 5y ago> This correlation of heart rates, described this month in Cell Reports, could one day lead to new tools for measuring attentiveness, both in the classroom and the clinic. Shame such interesting science inspires such dystopian machinations. "People synchronize their bodies when absorbed in attention." --> "How can schools use this to make sure students are paying attention?" Please don't.
- UncleOxidant 5y agoExactly my thought. Instead of saying "hey, isn't this a really interesting finding and maybe we could use it to help people get over anxiety" or something like that, they go the dystopian route. But I do wonder if they go that direction because they're interested in corporate funding for their research and that could be a way to get it.
- pugworthy 5y agoAnother way to phrase it would be "How can schools know if they are engaging with their students?" Or, "How can teachers better understand what engages students and what doesn't engage them?" That said, a good storyteller or teacher knows if they are engaging their audience (or failing to) and can adjust for better engagement. Bad ones don't know this, or even if they do, don't necessarily know what to do about it.
- ALittleLight 5y agoThe immediate concern is that, if a metric indicates a problem, who will be forced to change? The student or the teacher? If Mrs. Smith realizes little Timmy isn't paying attention, is she going to accept and consider the possibility she is boring, or just punish Timmy? For perspective, consider how often children are currently drugged when they are found not to be paying attention in school. Privacy may play a useful role here in directing us toward the good futures rather than the bad. For example, maybe schools are allowed to use heart rate attention monitors, but the data must be aggregated and anonimized. It's okay for Mrs. Smith to learn that 74% of her X (where X is greater than 50) students pay attention when she speaks and this puts her at Y percentile of teachers across the country in her subject. It's not okay for her to know the attentiveness of individual students. Of course, in reality I have zero hope that this would be used in a positive way.
- toss1 5y agoOK, so it is everyone speeding up or slowing down heart rates at similar parts of the story, not all the listeners synchronizing heartbeats with each other so all heartbeats are simultaneous (when I read the headline, I thought it was talking about a phenomena like synchronizing metronomes [1]) [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T58lGKREubo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T58lGKREubo
- causi 5y agoI'm not seeing what about this isn't obvious. If you stimulate a crowd of people by firing a gun into the air they all react at the same time. If you stimulate a group of people with a stimulus it's possible to ignore like a story only the ones not ignoring it will react.
- imwillofficial 5y agoI’ve always been bad at telling stories. Listeners would more likely fall asleep in sync than have their hearts racing. HN have any tips, tricks, books or blogs to help with story telling skills?
- conductr 5y agoI’m bad as well. But if I were to set out to improve, I’d just listen to more deliberate storytelling. Then practice, write, edit, tell, and tell again. The craft of stand up comedy has always interested me and you can find some nuggets by listening to popular comedians talk about how they develop a skit or entire performance.
- corobo 5y agoCircle around a punchline until you're done with your story or the audience is bored It doesn't matter if you were boring or not if you end on a laugh, people remember the laugh You're also allowed to write and rehearse your stories in advance :)
- hosh 5y agoOddball question: I wonder if that syncing happens with people who are not neurotypical -- examples, ADHD, Autism, etc. Are the syncing happening because of following along the narrative structure and character emotions? What about use of music scores, visual cues, etc.? To what extent of this syncing happens with personality types or emotional states? For example, do extroverts tend to sync more than introverts? If someone is relaxed and attentive vs. someone is anxious and distracted, how much would that change?