4 ms·
The article goes on and on but dances around the actual dilemma. There are ~8,035 homeless people in San Francisco and 225 vacant housing units. You can either
by paxys 5y ago
The article goes on and on but dances around the actual dilemma.
There are ~8,035 homeless people in San Francisco and 225 vacant housing units. You can either allot them on a first come first served basis, or run a lottery, or use some kind of objective criteria (aka "algorithm") to decide who needs it the most.
No matter which one you pick, the vast majority of people will be denied housing. Writing feature length articles with nothing more than "this process is bad because it rejects some people" is idiotic. The entire point is prioritization.
The article is criticizing social workers for asking personal questions like past incidents of trauma. If they didn't do that, you'd instead read all about how the city doesn't care about abuse victims and is doing nothing to help them.
It mentions someone who came here from LA and ended up on the streets, and is criticizing this system because he was put in the back of the queue. This shows another problem – the more/better services you provide, the more vulnerable people you will attract from all over the country. Somehow pull a miracle and actually "solve" the city's homeless crisis? Nevada, Texas, Arizona will very happily send more buses your way.
- dehrmann 5y agoThere's also the thorny question of why are we trying to house these people in the ~most expensive city in the country? On one hand, we could house several times more in Bakersfield, but on the other, exporting homeless to cheaper places is its own moral dilemma. We also can't induce demand by treating the homeless particularly better than the rest of the country.
- zarzavat 5y agoSingapore is one of the most expensive cities in the world, yet it doesn't have a problem with people sleeping on the street - in true Singapore style it's actually illegal to be homeless, the government has to provide homeless people with housing, and the homeless people have to accept it. Now you can make the argument that Singapore has a number of policies that stop people from becoming homeless in the first place, but I think the most fundamental reason why San Francisco and the US in general has a homelessness problem is because Americans don't feel sufficient shame for living in a city with a large number of homeless people. If Singapore suddenly found itself with the same number of people sleeping on the street as in San Francisco, you can bet that the problem would be solved extremely quickly because people would feel deeply ashamed at living in an environment with such a large number of homeless people.
- mcntsh 5y ago> Americans don't feel sufficient shame for living in a city with a large number of homeless people. I don't think this is true. No one likes living around massive homeless encampments, garbage, filth, and unpredictable people with severe mental issues. This is why the homeless services budget goes up significantly every single year in most coastal American cities. People want this problem to be solved, they just have a different idea on how to solve it. The difference between the US and Singapore is that "authoritarian" policies, like forcing people to live somewhere they might not want to, would never fly. One side of the spectrum would resent the handouts to others while they themselves continue to struggle with no help, and the other would complain the housing comes with too many rules and is too restrictive.
- paxys 5y agoSingapore also implements border controls. San Francisco cannot.
- dehrmann 5y agoThis is huge. If SF tries to house its homeless, it'll attract homeless from Oakland (and probably even further). Since Singapore has border controls, it doesn't have to worry about its neighbors taking advantage of its charity.
- rufus_foreman 5y agoIt used to be illegal to be homeless in the US as well, it was called vagrancy. There were various solutions depending on the cause. If you were homeless because you didn't want to work, there was the workhouse. If you were homeless because you were insane, there was the asylum. If you were homeless because you were a drunk or a drug addict, there was jail. People complained that those were authoritarian policies. Judges ruled against vagrancy laws. Petty theft was de facto legalized. Judges made rulings that make it very hard to commit insane people to an asylum. People wanted drugs legalized. Now there are bums defecating on the street, people passed out drunk or on drugs, needles on the sidewalk, insane people ranting and committing assault, so much shoplifting that stores are closing. Things are that way in San Francisco because people there want them that way. It's not a bad place to live if you are rich, you can insulate yourself from all that. And if you just want to shoot up heroin and meth every day until you die, well you know where to go.
- krageon 5y agoThere is so much wrong with this I don't even know where to start. These are people. If there is demand for housing for the homeless, you absolutely should do better than the rest of the country (especially when that country is the US, which has a terrible homelessness problem and a long history of shipping them around the country to look better for a while).
- silicon2401 5y ago> There is so much wrong with this I don't even know where to start. These are people. This whole comment is basically just an emotional appeal trying to shame the other commenter. It would be more constructive to the discussion to provide actual arguments and evidence than to just say the equivalent of "how could you say such a thing". People don't have a right to live in SF specifically; there are plenty of other places they can be handled, and that is a fully reasonable suggestion.