18 ms·
Semi related – I find the fascination with large and heavy vehicles in America incredibly bizarre. At some point SUVs and trucks started being less about utilit
by paxys 5y ago
Semi related – I find the fascination with large and heavy vehicles in America incredibly bizarre. At some point SUVs and trucks started being less about utility and more a test of manliness or patriotism or something. Driving around in even a regular sized sedan sometimes feels like you are in a sketch comedy. I have seen people do grocery runs in literal monster trucks.
The average price of a pickup truck sold today is $56K, very far from the "blue collar workhorse" it is advertised as. 70%+ of them will never see a day of off-road or hauling use (https://www.thedrive.com/news/26907/you-dont-need-a-full-size-pickup-truck-you-need-a-cowboy-costume https://www.thedrive.com/news/26907/you-dont-need-a-full-siz...).
Aside from the safety problems (for pedestrians & cyclists, not the driver of course), these trucks also wreck city streets, which are not designed for them. It's disappointing that this trend is continuing with EVs as well.
- canada_dry 5y ago> 70%+ of them will never see a day of off-road I remember laughing my head off when Lexus announced they were making a "Luxury SUV". I'm on my second one and it rarely even experiences a gravel road.
- Gustomaximus 5y agoAs someone who likes 4WDing we appreciate people buying these. A ~10 year old nicely devalued and non-abused SUV is a perfect car for those that want to actually 4WD. Taking a new and expensive 4WD down a narrow track with branches scraping stripes down the side would be too stressful for most.
- Gigachad 5y agoRegistration fees should be based on vehicle weight to match the cost of the damage done to the roads.
- cptskippy 5y agoAnd emissions
- sacred_numbers 5y agoCurrently it's actually the opposite in some ways. Vehicles with a GVWR of at least 6000 lbs (2700kg) that are used for business can be deducted 100% in the first year, no matter what the business use is. This leads to a lot of white collar consultants buying giant luxury trucks or SUVs to drive around town meeting clients rather than luxury sedans.
- aqfamnzc 5y agoIn Utah, (and possibly other states?) we get to pay an extra yearly fee for driving a hybrid or electric car. :)
- dmlittle 5y agoI believe the extra yearly fee is to offset the tax on gas used to maintain road infrastructure that all vehicles use.
- rofrol 5y agoNope. The report produced an extensive list of equations for describing the data collected from the tests, and from those equations was born the Generalized Fourth Power Law. It’s a rule of thumb for comparing the amount of pavement damage caused by vehicles with different weights, in terms of axle loads: (W1/W2)^4 In the equation, W1 is the weight of an axle on vehicle 1, which we would compare to W2, the weight of an axle on vehicle 2. Let’s look at some numbers for comparison. Consider a standard sedan with two axles and a total weight of 2 tons. Assuming an even distribution, each of its axles would bear the weight of 1 ton. Now consider a semitruck with eight axles and a weight of 40 tons -- each of its axles would weigh 5 tons. The relative damage done by each axle of the truck can be calculated with the following equation, and comes out to 625 times the damage done by each axel of the sedan. (5 tons/1 ton)^4 = 625 Considering that the truck has eight axles and the sedan has two, the relative damage caused by the entire semitruck would be 625 x (8/2) -- 2,500 times that of the sedan. - https://www.insidescience.org/news/how-much-damage-do-heavy-trucks-do-our-roads https://www.insidescience.org/news/how-much-damage-do-heavy-... - https://urbanmilwaukee.com/2017/06/22/murphys-law-how-trucks-destroy-our-roads/ https://urbanmilwaukee.com/2017/06/22/murphys-law-how-trucks... - https://truecostblog.com/2009/06/02/the-hidden-trucking-industry-subsidy/ https://truecostblog.com/2009/06/02/the-hidden-trucking-indu...
- beerandt 5y agoRegardless of transportation cost attribution, the electric vehicle fees are meant to offset transportation funding, which ICE vehicles pay largely via federal and state fuel taxes. And which we as a society have decided is a political decision, separate from direct use/cost. Otherwise we'd have just stuck with everything being a toll-road. Equating the marginal increase in pavement maintenance costs (due to trucks and heavy-loads) to the overall costs of building and operating a highway is also entirely wrong, but that's a bit tangent the point here. I'm usually the first to point out the outsized amount of damage and wear attributable to heavy vehicles, but it's still a marginal increase of only one cost component in running a public transportation network.
- willis936 5y agoIt's not just manliness. It's everyone. Ford hasn't made a car in two years. Total insanity.
- p2t2p 5y agoFord said that they stop producing cars for US market some time ago meaning that they’ll produce SUVs and trucks only. As a family person that runs to fruit market every several weeks and brings back a boot load of fruits in boxes it is hard to understand how a sedan can suffice. Having said that huge SUVs are overkill too, something like Subaru Forester/Outback or RAV-4 seems to be the sweet spot for people with less than 3 children. With 3 children you start looking at something with 3rd row of seats.
- deelowe 5y agoJust to be clear, they aren't stopping sports car production. They did end all sedans though.
- seattle_spring 5y agoThey sure ramped it down though. No more Focus/Fiesta RS or ST stateside.
- deelowe 5y agoI’m guessing we’ll see ev equivalents for that soon enough.
- WorldMaker 5y agoGiven that Ford gave its classic sportscar "Mustang" badge to an EV SUV rather than anything resembling a classic Mustang, Ford seems to be putting a lot of work into avoiding sedans/coupes even in EVs.
- aidenn0 5y ago
- awsthro00945 5y ago> ... large and heavy vehicles... Aside from the safety problems (for pedestrians & cyclists, not the driver of course), these trucks also wreck city streets, which are not designed for them. The best selling trucks in America, the F150 and the Chevy Silverado, are lighter than a Tesla S.
- paxys 5y agoOkay..? So all three are very heavy.
- fastball 5y agoTrue, we should start a program to get everyone a GMA T.50 – kerb weight of < 1,000 kg!
- PpEY4fu85hkQpn 5y agoThe 4th Power Rule tells us that they are all doing bonkers amount of damage to roads. It's especially terrible considering very few truck owners actually use them for anything more than single-user commutes. Trucks are such horrible deadly things for cities and should be either banned or prohibitively taxed for anyone who doesn't need them. https://insidescience.org/index.php/news/how-much-damage-do-heavy-trucks-do-our-roads https://insidescience.org/index.php/news/how-much-damage-do-... https://www.thedrive.com/news/26907/you-dont-need-a-full-size-pickup-truck-you-need-a-cowboy-costume https://www.thedrive.com/news/26907/you-dont-need-a-full-siz...
- Accujack 5y agoThey are doing far, far less damage than heavy trucks, such as semi tractor-trailers or even box trucks with significant weight inside. Even so, the goal here is to spend the resources to permit movement of goods and people... not to limit traffic to those vehicle types that do the least damage to the road. The road is there to be used, not admired. If you really want 0 damage, work toward legalizing hovercraft on national highways.
- finiteseries 5y ago…streets don’t account for SUVs and pickup trucks in their designs? Absolutely disheartening to see EVs amenable to people who drive trucks and SUVs though, one would hope their manly culture of overpaying for patriotic vehicles would change before the climate does, but alas.
- renewiltord 5y agoBought a truck when I moved to Texas. I managed to furnish my home there off Craigslist by picking up stuff way cheaper than by buying new stuff. Completely infeasible to buy some of these things even with the Subaru Forester I used to have.
- bsmith 5y agoCouldn't have rented a van/UHaul for a day or weekend?
- renewiltord 5y agoNot really. In my experience, quality vs list time is a concave up decreasing function. If your close duration is high, you will get substantially worse execution. If you’ve been able to beat that, then you are better at this than I am.
- hytdstd 5y agoIt sounds like you've minimized one-time furniture costs by increasing your recurring fuel costs.
- renewiltord 5y agoI misspoke. I let the Forester. I just don’t use it for this anymore.
- zumu 5y agoOne theory I have as to a contributing factor is that the streets are poorly maintained in enough of America that an SUV/Truck suspension is a noticeably comfier ride.
- WorldMaker 5y agoOne thing begets the other though: more heavy SUV/Trucks the worse the wear on the road.
- culopatin 5y agohave you tried driving in the rest of the world? The US streets even in the north are pool tables compared to most of the world.
- hytdstd 5y agoLarger cars are safer-- to the people inside them[0]. And the cost of an SUV is nothing compared to medical bills and chronic pain. Of course, they only remain safer as long as they're larger than other vehicles on the road, so it's just a never-ending arms race. [0]: https://www.iihs.org/topics/vehicle-size-and-weight https://www.iihs.org/topics/vehicle-size-and-weight.
- kwhitefoot 5y ago> cost of an SUV is nothing compared to medical bills Another argument for universal, free at point of use, health care?
- pornel 5y agoAnd/or roundabouts. They significantly reduce lethality of collisions at crossings.
- kwhitefoot 5y agoAbsolutely!
- lucioperca 5y agoThe potential cost injuries from cycling are far less than the health benefits from it. Cars on the other hand are as dangerous as smoking for its user: https://academic.oup.com/jpubhealth/article/33/2/160/1591440 https://academic.oup.com/jpubhealth/article/33/2/160/1591440 In this sense an SUV is like smoking lots of cigarettes around others but without inhaling as much.
- nbzso 5y agoPlease stop. Comparing cars to tobacco and using a bike to transport your family or goods. Where is the parallel? It is obvious that we have to change towards reality of EV and optimization of cars. In EU SUV is not predominant form factor (yet), but there are use cases for different people. You cannot paint with this big and bold "everything on bicycles" brush, trucks are America's problem exclusively. The solutions are obvious. Create adequate public transportation grids for the cities and manage all car traffic. People living outside the cities cannot do they work on a bicycle.
- futevolei 5y agoAgreed about manliness (“build ford tough”!) and patriotism but don’t forget status. Part of me dies seeing people driving around land rovers in the city by themselves. What a waste of energy…
- freetinker 5y agoI used to have a similarly narrow view. And because my worldview was similarly colored and judgmental, I too would roll my eyes when I saw an off-road capable truck parked at a mall, and reflexively throw out similar loosely-substantiated stats (70% will never take them off-road, etc.), and even indulge in more vitriolic private musings such as "he's probably compensating for a smaller-than-desirable reproductive organ." That changed when I traded-in my Tesla for a mid-sized, off-road capable truck, and found myself on the receiving end of this view. I certainly did not buy a truck to "overcompensate" as the article suggests or to use it only to haul groceries. I'm not even a blue collar worker – decidedly white collar in SV, with no need to haul lumber or construction material. Luckily, being a SV white collar type also made me beneficiary of WFH, and killed my commute. I loved my model S, but didn't need an efficient/fun tarmac shuttlecock between work and home anymore. I also found that an off-road truck was more suited to my new "commute": like the ability to go haul my astrophotography equipment to the middle of nowhere – far away from light pollution where regular cars can't make it. I also traded-in my road bike for a mountain bike because I discovered that even small/mid-sized cars are hostile to cyclists in America. It doesn't matter if a Nissan Leaf runs me over or a Ford F-150 – I'm still dead. So now I also use my off-road truck to haul my off-road bike to places where a regular car can't run me over. A bear maybe, but not a car. Rivian seems to offer the best of all worlds, and I'm rooting for their charging infrastructure to grow asap – so I can still do truck stuff, without the emissions. Are there people who'll buy a truck/SUV only to use it as a mall crawler? Sure. Just as there are people who'll buy BMW M3s or Porsche 911s and never take it on the track.
- harpersealtako 5y agoI think the basic concept around truck ownership is as true now as it always has been: A truck can do everything a car can, but a car can't do everything that a truck does (at least not as easily or conveniently). Most people who buy trucks or similarly large vehicles with copious storage space do so because they think they might someday need to do one of those things.
- blue-gum 5y agoA truck cannot go under very short tunnels, under low & thick tree branches, etc... Each vehicle has its tradeoffs. With that being said personally i prefer a larger vehicle because its easier to get in/out of, sitting higher lets me see further, lots of other tall vehicles essentially force me to also be in a tall vehicle or have a worse view while driving.
- rasz 5y agoAnd this is one of the origins 1974 Chevrolet C10 Custom 3MT: Regular Car Reviews https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zeT6LspPPFQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zeT6LspPPFQ heavy cheaply made piece of shit with a cult status
- AndrewThrowaway 5y agoIt is all marketing. It was sold to people. Mainly as a symbol of a good life. Because it is hard to prove to others, and especially to yourself, that your life is quite good. You can buy expensive clothes (with huge logos that can be seen from a mile) but how expensive can they get, they can be fakes; you can have expensive house (but not much people can see you comong in/out), etc. So car becomes a perfect proof. "Everybody sees how big and how new and how powerful and loud it is". You have succeeded. Look at drivers sometimes. They are even acting like driving in a movie of some sort. Doing faces when accelerating and etc. It is the same with plastic surgery - you don't want it to be subtle anymore. You want it to be visible. So anybody can know that you can afford it.
- halo37253 5y agoCars are not very practical. Small and cramped on the inside, and not great for a family. Trucks and SUVs make for great family movers. I have a full sized half ton truck, It is the main family hauler. But I use the bed alot and tow my boat or trailer all the time. But something small like a Ford Escape is perfect for most, and that is why there are so many of these compact crossovers on the road. They are bigger than a Car, higher up, and the back seats can be fold down to allow for a lot of storage room. Our secondary Vehicle is a Escape titanium, and see these everywhere along with Rav4's and CRVs. Really the only 3 compact crossovers worth looking at IMO.