4 ms·
It's nice that it has a dashboard in front of the driver, not off to the side. There are some things that tesla does that I think are poor design, and that is
by m463 5y ago
It's nice that it has a dashboard in front of the driver, not off to the side.
There are some things that tesla does that I think are poor design, and that is the most egregious. lack of tactile controls for critical functions is just as bad, like touch controls for turn signals... ugh.
- mehphp 5y ago> touch controls for turn signals Wait… really?
- akerl_ 5y agoNot sure what they mean. My Tesla definitely has a turn signal stalk just like every other car I’ve ever owned.
- josephcsible 5y agoThe 2021 Model S has touch controls for turn signals. The rest of their lineup still has a conventional turn signal stalk.
- vrc 5y agoSo I was a staunch physical control guy (drove a manual through 2016, with the first car lacking power steering), and now a Tesla owner. I thought I’d feel more strongly against the entire touch setup. And it does suck a lot and makes me take my eyes off the road more than I should. At the same time, my spouses Honda, which has more physical buttons than many other cars, requires fewer, but not markedly fewer eyesight departures. I guess the last car I could drive and fiddle with the controls without looking was my 2003 EP3 hatch. So I figure if all cars are going to make me look at a screen as I fiddle, in for a pinch, in for a pound.
- frosted-flakes 5y agoAnalogue physical controls are ideal. Infinite-spin dials suck (except for speaker volume), and digital buttons for controlling ranges are even worse: fan speed, temperature, blend door control, wiper intermittency rate, etc. work best with absolutely poitioned analogue controls that you can feel the current state by touch alone. Early 2000s cars do it best, in my experience.
- wumpus 5y agoYou can't tell the wiper intermittency setting with your eyes looking through the windshield? It's either too little or too much.
- colordrops 5y agoYou obviously don't own a Tesla. Turn signals are not touch controls. There are enough physical controls for important functions. Everything else being on the screen has been perfectly fine. In fact it's mostly better, due to automatic sensor-based control and high quality voice recognition. The only annoying thing in my mind is opening the glove compartment.
- maxerickson 5y agoThey made some noise about it at least. https://carbuzz.com/news/tesla-replacing-indicators-with-guesswork-in-updated-model-s https://carbuzz.com/news/tesla-replacing-indicators-with-gue...
- josephcsible 5y ago> Turn signals are not touch controls. In the newly refreshed Model S they are.
- 6a74 5y agoWell you obviously don’t own a new Tesla Model S. The yolk steering wheel has capacitive buttons for signals and the horn [0]. [0] https://thegreencarguy.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/GCG_Tesla_New_Interior_ButtonDet-850x532.jpg https://thegreencarguy.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/GCG_Te...
- EForEndeavour 5y ago> yolk We'll you've obviously been driving an egg this whole time.
- 6a74 5y agoSorry. Yoke.
- rconti 5y agoSo, that's correct, but it just means everyone's correct. The original commenter said "like Tesla does" implying that significant number of Teslas have this, or it's their standard, which isn't true. It also makes one think of a touchscreen control rather than a capacitive button on the steering wheel. Don't get me wrong, it's a stupid design. I have a Model 3, and really wish I had a front instrument cluster, too. But the whole thread seems to be half-truths from various camps trying to mislead each other.
- wumpus 5y agoFor those confused, this is a reference to the new Model S and likely the new X, when it comes out. Tesla may yet change their minds. My 2013 S (car ~ 4000) has the cruise control stalk in the Mercedes position. It was moved to a more traditional location a few months later.
- m463 5y agoI saw a plaid delivered with the yoke steering wheel and no stalks anywhere.
- mft_ 5y agoI get the argument about the touchscreen generally, but think you’re wrong about the location of the dashboard being a problem in a Tesla M3/Y. Here’s the thing: any dashboard (that’s not projected into the windscreen) requires you to look away from the road, whether it’s front/below or side/below. The only data you’d likely be checking on a regular basis in an EV whilst on the move is speed; speed is top-left of the screen (i.e. closest to the driver’s regular gaze position) and retraining to deflect your gaze there takes very little practise. Once you’re accustomed, flicking your eyes there for a fraction of a second is no different to flicking your eyes to a traditional dashboard for a fraction of a second.
- csunbird 5y agoTesla M3 desperately needs a heads up display. The location of speedometer is completely wrong in Tesla M3, in my humble opinion. For example, I have glasses and my peripheral vision is far better in vertical direction, opposed to horizontal direction. Even without glasses, to look at your right direction, your nose is in the way of left eyes vision and you actively need to look at the speedometer by turning your head.
- mft_ 5y agoFair enough, tho' my experience is different. I find it equally quick and easy to flick my eyes to the speedo in the M3 vs. a traditional location. And I'd argue it probably better than some traditionally-located speedometers, given challenges of poor contrast or visibility, different gauge styles, and the unpredictable coverage of the cluster by the steering wheel in various cars.
- Corrado 5y agoI actually prefer the speedometer location in my Model Y to almost any other car. It literally took me an hour to adjust to looking over rather than down.
- AuryGlenz 5y agoI don’t know why every vehicle doesn’t have a HUD at this point. Once you have one you don’t want to go without, even if it’s just the speedometer.