7 ms·
So true. In HN articles where we discuss social media moderation there's often this idea that "they shouldn't be doing this at all". But I think for most com
by duxup 5y ago
So true.
In HN articles where we discuss social media moderation there's often this idea that "they shouldn't be doing this at all". But I think for most companies and users ... they won't like what a completely moderation free site looks like.
So here we are with this painful problem.
I kinda wish there was an imaginary "real person with an honest identity" type system that did exist where we could interact without the land of bots and dishonest users and so forth. But that obviously brings its own issues.
- commandlinefan 5y ago> they won't like what a completely moderation free site looks like. So you say, but we've never actually had a chance to see one. We have seen content moderation slippery-slope its way to highly opinionated censorship... every time it's been tried.
- duxup 5y ago>but we've never actually had a chance to see one Have we not had site after site that does this eventually start moderating for reasons every time? And we have darkweb sites... What are we missing?
- unethical_ban 5y agoThis is false. 4chan, some early reddit, voat, and a number of other sites. Moreover, that's the point: it's as i.possible to have a healthy anonymous forum available to the world as it is to have a large society with no laws or government, that isn't dystopian.
- commandlinefan 5y ago> early reddit Reddit is the best example of why heavy moderation is worse than lack of moderation.
- ronsor 5y agoThat's only because the most powerful reddit moderators are basically corrupt dictators.
- commandlinefan 5y agoIt's not just reddit, though - if you're going to start moderating, you have a meta-problem to address which is what to do about opinionated moderators.
- unethical_ban 5y agoAll mods are opinionated. They're either humans, or bots programmed by humans. I don't see why you're trying to deny humanity to moderators.
- ronsor 5y agoAll judges are opinionated. They're humans. I don't see why you're trying to deny humanity to judges. Read the above and reconsider if your argument makes sense. It stands to reason that if you have any position of "power," even if it's just "random internet moderator," you should at least try to be fair, consistent, and reasonable.
- raxxorrax 5y agoIt also puts the moderator under pressure. User will start ushering demands what you should ban. In worst case law enforcement too. I don't really understand why people waste so much time getting something removed instead of just reading something else, but there are whole communities that live for banning others by now. In a larger legal scope platforms are under heavy scrutiny by moral busybodies right now.
- unethical_ban 5y agoIt's a difficult problem. No moderation = porn, gore and nazi discussion. Period. "Light" moderation often = bad-faith trolls taking advantage of your moderation. HN does a good job of moderating for civility and effort of the post, rather than ideology. Here's the thing: Talking about controversial topics, or debating with people who think differently than you, takes a lot of effort online, because there are so many trolls and others baiting you into defending a position without putting any effort to explain their own. So yeah, heavy moderation is an unfortunate necessity in some forums.
- ziml77 5y agoThere used to be a fair chance that you'd stumble on CSAM on 4chan. Without filtering and aggressive moderation, that's what ends up happening (yes 4chan did have moderation to delete the stuff back then and dish out IP bans, but it wasn't fast enough to save people from seeing those things)
- Veen 5y agoOne alternative to moderation is to make people pay to post. If you set the price high enough, you'll disuade most spammers and some other species of asshole. Unfortunately, people who hate moderation also tend to hate paying for online services.
- raxxorrax 5y agoTrue, this keeps the community small and those work really well without moderation. The moment it becomes a bit more popular, shit hits the fan. I am still for a light approach. Banning spammers, trolls, and illegal porn posters is a separate issue for me, but many platforms began to delete unpopular opinions. The most heavy handed moderated places are very often the most toxic ones, I think they are far worse than free for all examples. Given, that might not work for the masses.
- bogwog 5y ago> I kinda wish there was an imaginary "real person with an honest identity" type system that did exist where we could interact without the land of bots and dishonest users and so forth. But that obviously brings its own issues. That sounds like it could be done in a way that isnt terrible. As a user, you sign up with an identity provider by submitting personal documents and/or an interview to prove that you’re a real person. Then, when you sign up to an app/service, you login with the ID provider and come up with a username for that service. The ID provider does not give the website provider any of your personal information; they just verify that you exist (and you login their their secure portal) The identity providers could further protect privacy by automatically deleting all of your personal documents from their databases as soon as the verification process is complete. They could also have a policy to not store any logs, such as the list of services you’ve signed up for. This could still be gamed (ex: a phone scammer tricking someone into getting verified with a provider to get a valid ID), but itd make things much harder and costlier. Am I missing anything obvious that would make this a terrible idea?
- duxup 5y agoThe thing I was thinking of when it comes to the ID provider is the potential power an ID provider has... if say you wanted to be validated, but still have some anonymity in some cases ... or just if they decide to invalidate you for any given reason. Granted all very hypothetical stuff, I'd give it a spin for sure.
- PeterisP 5y agoYour idea becomes useless for deterrence from the "automatically deleting" point. The only benefits for having users who are "real person with an honest identity" accrue when people either can't make many accounts (so banning an user actually bans them instead of simply makes them get a new account) or when you can identify them in case of fraud or child sexual abuse material or some such. So at the very least the "identity provider" absolutely needs to keep a list of all real identities offered to a particular service; otherwise the bad actors will just re-verify some identity as many times as needed. But if you give up the "hard privacy" requirement, then technically it's possible. It would also mean that the identity provider would sometimes get subpoenas to reveal these identities.
- throwawaysea 5y agoThe problem is where the line is drawn. Arguments against explicitly illegal content (like CSAM) or unhelpful content (like spam) are used to justify content moderation that goes far beyond. Moderation on the biggest social media platforms (like Facebook, Twitter, TikTok, etc.) includes more than just basic moderation to make the platform viable. They include a number of elements that are more like censorship or propaganda. These platforms ultimately bias their audience towards one set of values/ideologies based on the moderation policies they implement. And given that most of these companies are based in highly-progressive areas and/or have employee bases that are highly-progressive, it is pretty clear what their biases are. This present reality is unacceptable for any society that values free and open discourse.
- Nasrudith 5y agoPropaganda and bias are ultimately subjective notions. Suggest that kings are no different from the rest of us today aside from what their parents did to seize power and it would be slammed as wicked propaganda denying their divine right. Heck just suggest that disfavored groups are people!
- photochemsyn 5y agoI think the issue is more that these are for-profit corporations who care almost exclusively about advertising revenue. Now, if 10% of your 'product' (*your users) is driving away the other 90% of your product, and you can no longer sell them to your advertisers, well? I'm guessing it's more a business decision, they've decided that eliminating 'fringe views' is best for business. It's kind of like an advertising dystopian situation, where you want this homogenized audience (preferably rather dumbed down) who will eagerly buy whatever is advertised. And, you don't want to scare any of them away. Notice this view is not partisan or ideological, it's just pure capitalism, how can we wring the most value out of this setup for the shareholders, that's all that matters. The end result is the current mess we now have, in which nobody but the advertiser is all that happy.
- Nasrudith 5y agoI suspect that even if we could we would wind up with a disturbing "reverse Turing test". The dark suggestion that there isn't any difference between us and other malfunctioning machine learning arrangements trained by huge data sets. They may be objectively homo sapiens with honest identities devoted to something which makes them act indistinguishable from a bot.