6 ms·
Especially with a law. The police generally consider laws to be for little people. In the US, any law that is supposed to apply to police has to not depend on
by ncmncm 5y ago
Especially with a law.
The police generally consider laws to be for little people. In the US, any law that is supposed to apply to police has to not depend on the District Attorney ever filing charges, because they won't, except for certain high-visibility murders, and usually not even then.
Something that has worked sometimes is a state or federal law affecting city police. The law should have provisions to allow citizens to initiate enforcement, and, for egregious offenses, provisions to restrict the convicted officer from working in other police departments.
Too often, departments appear to respond to public pressure by firing the officer. But that actually achieves very little; the officer just goes to work for another city, with a fresh, clean record. There are a lot of cities.
It would be helpful to establish a national registry of police behavior, so that offenses at one department follow them to the next.
- wccrawford 5y agoOTOH, the laws that work against cops are the ones that invalidate the things they do on their day jobs. If they violate the law and a suspect goes free, that has actual consequences for them, mentally at least. Of course, they still have to get caught, but it won't be the DA that has to do something about it, it's the defendant's lawyer who will do it.
- int0x2e 5y agoI agree, but this only helps if they're actually going after someone they charge with something. If they are merely violating your rights but don't charge you, this would have little to no impact on police wrongdoing.
- ncmncm 5y agoActual consequences? So, the cop cracks your skull, but the judge lets you go, and the cop continues cracking skulls, maybe yours again. Your lawyer maybe sues the department for use of excessive force, and maybe gets a settlement from the taxpayers. Again, with exactly zero effect on the crooked cop. Maybe lawyers should be suing the police union, too.
- 14 5y agoSome people have been pushing for persona liability with the police. I think we could assume in this better world we are dreaming of where citizens can arrest an officer they also have personally liability.
- TheSoftwareGuy 5y ago>Of course, they still have to get caught, but it won't be the DA that has to do something about it, it's the defendant's lawyer who will do it. But unfortunately, this means that anybody who can't afford a good lawyer, will be an easy target for trampling on their rights
- bsenftner 5y agoI just took a look, and "bad cop database" appears to be a new start up vector, littered with dubious websites.
- darksaints 5y agoAllowing citizens to initiate enforcement sounds like a potentially good idea. Are you saying that citizens can prosecute police on behalf of the state? Where has it been tried before? I might have some reservations with this, but proving that cops committed crimes is actually extremely commonplace. It happens in criminal courtrooms on a daily basis, as the primary vector to get evidence thrown out against a defendant. When cops commit crimes while gathering evidence, those criminal actions taint the evidence. The problem is that nobody ever prosecutes the cops for the crime. The evidence gets thrown out, criminals walk free, and then nothing happens after that. It would be nice if the same defense attorney that proved the cop acted unlawfully could follow up by putting the cop in prison.
- djbebs 5y agoTo be perfectly honest I see no reason why all the prosecutorial powers vested exclusively on the state should be exclusive to the state. There should be nothing that the executive branch does in terms of investigation and prosecution, that the average citizen should be legally barred from doing. This includes prosecuting crimes in criminal court, requesting and enforcing warrants, and so on. The only difference between an average citizen and the government employees doing these things should be that the government employes are being paid to do these things as a full time job.
- zepto 5y agoThat would result just in sovereign citizens doing an unlimited amount of paper terrorism.
- djbebs 5y agoAs opposed to the state? Simply add a cost to prosecutions that fail, with it going towards the winner.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago> with it going towards the winner. The cops will abuse the shit out of that. That gives them a monetary incentive to botch investigations when their buddies are involved.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]