10 ms·
The train that shrunk France and Western Europe
- zahma 5y agoIt's not usually obvious how shaving off one hour of travel time impacts cities. Several years ago, the TGV line was completed between Paris and Bordeaux — reducing the trip from three hours to two. The arrival of the TGV meant that Bordeaux saw exponential growth ever since and especially during the height of the pandemic. Even before the quarantine made everyone reconsider why the hell they were also confining themselves to Paris, wealthy and mobile Parisians saw the opportunity to make Bordeaux home and commute when they needed to. I credit that almost entirely with the arrival of the two-hour TGV. It's as if three hours was too much time, and two hours was the magical threshold that made living between the two cities feasible. Now it is teeming with Parisian opportunists, and I totally understand why. Paris has been crowded, polluted, and unreasonably expensive, and Bordeaux was quite literally the opposite: laid back yet sophisticated, beautifully framed along the Garonne river, and with easy access to nature and the ocean. But now with the sudden influx of Parisians, there is some malaise among the Bordelais that the city has fundamentally changed not only in demographics, but in cost and culture. The before and after effects are palpable. I saw Bordeaux before the boom started. In 2016/2017, it was sleepy and still cleaning the blackened grime off the building façades. The rents and cost of living reflected a city still growing, but the city itself has long been wealthy and home to a UNESCO world heritage site. Now there are cranes everywhere. New developments are cropping up around the city, and the costs of rents and living have soared. It even feels louder. The housing stock is depleted because the newcomers have purchased everything. That's not all bad for landholders and property owners, but it really sucks if you're just trying to make your way into the market, let alone a student trying to rent something. A part of me feels like it's a lost treasure that's now been overrun by the same people who make living in Paris so exasperating. I guess this is the nature of change, and I attribute it almost entirely to the TGV line. French life will always be centralized in Paris, and so without these high-speed lines, there is little reason to think Bordeaux would have grown so much if not for the reduced travel time.
- nspattak 5y agoThe upgraded TGV almost halved the time in the Paris-Bordeaux line from 4-4.5 to 2:15. This was a huge difference and combined with the convenience of the train station being close to the center as opposed to the airport, meant that people can easily go on a daily trip to Paris by train. However, the city has been developing heavily before that and Parisians who wanted a nicer place to spend their quarantine have plenty of other places to go to, either in the west part of the country or the south. In my opinion what needs to be done to further decentralize the country away from paris is to improve the connection between the other cities, eg Bordeaux Marseille is 6h by train!
- agumonkey 5y agoNote that I have a colleague who often suffers a 2h long commute to go to work. She could live on the other side of the country and take the same time.
- dopidopHN 5y ago2h plus métro time once she gets in Paris. Easily 30 min unless she works right next to the train station. But yes
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- choeger 5y agoI think that's an astute observation. For families, even one hour of commute can be too much (depending on the job and details of childcare facilities) and people that have to show up every day (usually lower-wage positions) cannot make this work at all. This means that the two-hour commute will have some filtering effect. towards professionals that can work from home or maybe earn enough to support a family from a single income. That effect will be even more aggravated if the two hours do not include the way from and to the train stations. So it's easy to see that the effect on the receiving city can be quite pronounced.
- mytailorisrich 5y ago
- masklinn 5y agoAlthough the TGV was purportedly for everybody, one of the things which long hampered it is the historical and technocratic notion of Paris being the sole hub of the country: while the first TGV section opened in 1981, the first section which was not subordinate to Paris (either going to it or directly extending a line coming from Paris) was the LGV Rhin-Rhone in 2011. To this day, if you want to travel between south-east and south-west france, you can go straight through using intercity trains (which takes 6h between Marseilles and Bordeaux) or through Paris on the TGV (which… also takes 6h). The distance between Marseilles and Bordeaux is about 650km, about the same as Paris - Bordeaux and significantly shorter than Paris - Marseilles (800km), both of which are about 3h TGV from Paris (resp. 2:30 for Bordeaux and 3:30 for Marseilles).
- andix 5y agoThis is probably one of the biggest problems of TGVl But at least it opens up France to people from Paris and London (region), the two biggest cities of Western Europe.
- samhw 5y ago> one of the things which long hampered it is the historical and technocratic notion of Paris being the sole hub of the country Is it really the 'historical and technocratic notion' which influenced it, or just the raw fact that it is the hub of the country, the place from or to which most people want to travel? Sure, that fact may itself have been determined by all kinds of historical and/or technocratic notions, but I see no reason why the TGV builders need to have been musing on history.
- masklinn 5y ago> Is it really the 'historical and technocratic notion' which influenced it, or just the raw fact that it is the hub of the country, the place from or to which most people want to travel? The former, concentrating state power in Paris, and limiting (or even outright suppressing) the importance and influence of the rest of the country (especially the southern half) has been a constant theme since the Bourbons: they underwent the project of moving france from a decentralised feudal state to a centralised absolute monarchy. This theme of centralisation of power remained a constant until very late in the 20th century e.g. regional languages remained pretty actively suppressed until the 50s (Loi Deixonne which allowed some of them to be taught at all). Even then that allowance remained limited until the 80s at the earliest. To this day, france has signed but not ratified the European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages. > I see no reason why the TGV builders need to have been musing on history. Because even if they had considered the idea (which they probably had not) it would have been shot down as completely useless by pollies.
- throw_m239339 5y agoAh France's crown jewel (along with the atomic bomb perhaps?). I remember doing Le Mans/Paris in TG every week day for a year to commute to work. Mind you, I actually saved (a lot of) money on rent compared to the cost of commuting via high speed rail... let's not even get started about the price of renting a 3 room apartment in Paris...
- sedan_baklazhan 5y ago(Almost) complete abandonment of overnight trains wasn't so good though. They are a great alternative to, otherwise, spending a big portion of the daylight in a TGV. As a tourist in France, I wished so much country still had those.
- iso1210 5y agoMassively expensive and people weren't willing to pay
- hef19898 5y agoHigh speed, maybe. The German railway gave up night trains as well, only to have the Austrians step in to take the night lines over. Which are now massively popular, and profitable.
- reacharavindh 5y agoI made the trip from Denmark to Austria last year on the train. It was lovely. We drive from our home in DK to Hamburg, loaded our car on the train (8:45 PM after having dinner). Slept comfortably in a cabin for the night. Drove off at Vienna the next morning from the train off to Salzburg. It was a joy to 1. Not worry about packing light to lug around all the stuff in a airport, or to worry about checking in luggages. We have a 2 year-old. So, these things are a source of stress. We just packed everything we wanted in the trunk of our own car. 2. Have our car with us during the trip so that we got the freedom to go wherever we wanted to and not have to rent a car in Austria. 3. Pay less. The cost of the train ticket can be seen also as including what would’ve been a night stay at a hotel. 4. Sleep comfortably. No driving over night or sitting in a cramped airline seat. I will happily pay extra for such car train trips. It’s a pity they very few.
- mungoman2 5y agoI had no idea this was possible. Will definitely do this in the summer. Thanks!
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoImagine you enter the train in New York at 8 pm, eat a nice meal, read or play a game, go to sleep and wake up at 8 am in San Francisco. No queuing in airports, no security checks, just the pure pleasure of traveling. Wouldn't it be nice? Well, it's not gonna happen in the USA. It is one of the important differences between the two continents: in Europe, public transport is important, and improving its infrasctructure is one of the metrics of success. In the USA, owning a car is important, and there is no (feasible) way to change it.
- GDC7 5y ago> No queuing in airports, no security checks, just the pure pleasure of traveling. Wouldn't it be nice? All those things are self imposed, and they are strangely only enforced on airplanes. Like the 300+ lives aboard a train are worth nothing
- maeln 5y agoThere was the same discussion a few days ago on another post. It's not a fair comparison. You can hardly hijack a train. Even if you manage to get control of the train, you cannot land it in a tower full of people. The worst you can do is make it de-rail which, while it will probably kill a lot of people, is unlikely to kill all of its passenger. And if you carry a bomb you will blow at most one compartment. Also, with train, even if someone manage to get to the driver compartment, you can still control a lot of the train from the outside. You can change its direction at exchange point, you can cut its supply in electricity (if it is an electric train) therefore stopping it (although in quite a dangerous way...). And you are still on the ground were it is very easy for police / military to catch up and intervene. You can't do that with a plane several kilometers high in the sky. Planes are much more sensible to all of those potential threat. That is why we ended up with such drastic security. Although I have to say, in a lot of places, security is way more relaxed. If you travel from the E.U to the E.U you have way less check and queue time.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoThe thing is that if someone wants to use a bomb to derail a train it may be easier to place the bomb on or near the tracks, which obviously bypasses any security onboard. This was attempted on the TGV during the terrorist wave of the mid-90s in France but, fortunately, it did not detonate. That being said, I think that they have X-ray checks now on TGVs.
- zokier 5y agoA title that screams for isochrone map
- mlok 5y agoI agree. Here is one : https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DD6Ud9BWAAAwVsM.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DD6Ud9BWAAAwVsM.jpg
- jaclaz 5y agoThere is a kind of maps where the territory is deformed according to time employed by this (or that) connection, I think they are called "time cartograms"[0], probably in the case of France it wouldn't be so extreme, but I remember one made of Italy where the country was very short north-south and very large west-east, because most of the high speed railway connections go in the north-south direction, and actually crossing the country from the Tirrenic to the Adriatic coast takes nowadays the same (or more) than before world war II. [0] http://googlemapsmania.blogspot.com/2017/12/how-time-can-bend-space.html http://googlemapsmania.blogspot.com/2017/12/how-time-can-ben...
- WelcomeShorty 5y agoAnecdotical: 1987 I was on holidays with my girlfriend and we decided to take the TGV from Lyon to Paris: it was a blast! There was a bar with beer on tap and whilst traveling with 300km/h, you would lean on the bar, standing, and enjoy the (for that time) incredible speed. Never used it again, we enjoyed the freedom of the car too much.
- dwd 5y agoAs a 13yo visiting Paris in the early 80's, the lineup of TGVs at the Gare de Lyon was on my bucket list. We were passed by one after leaving Paris for Geneva, puttering along in our combi van; blink and you would have missed it. Only thing maybe cooler was standing on an original GWR platform when a diesel InterCity 125 HST went through at speed. More recently took the Hikari from Tokyo to Kyoto and back on my JR Pass which was a blast.
- spodek 5y agoIt's not just the equipment. It's also the corporate culture behind it. If we in the US magically changed all the technology from Europe's or Japan's rail system with ours, but not the people running them and their culture, in Europe and Japan they'd have their now crappy trains on crappy tracks to dilapidated stations running on time and the US would have its now super-advanced trains running late and missing stops. If we changed the people instead but not the equipment, the US would start running its trains on time and Europe's and Japan's would run late. Think of that next time someone tries to solve a social problem like the environment with technology. If I had to pick one, I'd take a culture of stewardship over technological solutions any day. I'd rather have both, but regarding living sustainably, American culture needs fixing, not technology. Our technological innovations exacerbate our cultural problems because technology augments the values of the people and culture wielding it. In the US, that means waste.
- rhn_mk1 5y agoNot to take away from your point, but in Western Europe, trains running late is one of the favourite topics to complain about, next to weather. Move towards the east, and there's also dilapidated trains to talk about. I'm not going to judge whether the complaints are a reflection of some objective truth. It could be that the outliers are more visible.
- maccolgan 5y agoNow replace the interstate highway system with the european highway system and see the world end instantly.
- tgv 5y agoThe article doesn't mention airplanes at all, but it's planes that have truly shrunk (Western) Europe. London, Copenhagen and Amsterdam have only recently been connected to the fast train network, or not yet. But the most important factor, IMO, is price. The article hails "its affordability. “The TGV was meant for everyone and not just the rich.”" While that might have been true in 1981, nowadays a high-speed rail ticket is on average more expensive than a plane ticket, and train capacity is still lagging behind. I wish this could be reversed, but that would require more intervention than the EC seems willing to do, not to mention some very costly investments.
- Gravityloss 5y agoIf kerosene was taxed like other fuels and energy sources? Trains and their infrastructure are not exactly free enterprise either though...
- rsynnott 5y ago> While that might have been true in 1981, nowadays a high-speed rail ticket is on average more expensive than a plane ticket, I'm not sure how true this is when you factor in getting to and from the airport, or if you for some unaccountable reason want to bring anything larger than a laptop bag with you.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoFrom barcelona to amsterdam will cost about 50-100 bucks with luggage. Transfer to the airport costs 1-2 euros each side as both airports have excellent local train connectivity at regular local pricing. It takes 2 hours. With checkin and waiting hassles etc say 4. By high speed rail the same trip costs around 400, takes 12 hours and in most cases you have to transfer somewhere in Paris from one station to another by metro. There's simply no point in this. And there is no incentive for the rail companies in making this work. They fill up all their high-speed seats for in-country travel already so why bother making good deals for international through travelers? Better sell the same seat on the journey several times for a local commuter than once for long distance. For national travel you have a point, sure. In Europe national air travel is really rare. Even the biggest countries use their rail links for that. But on a European scale rail is not working at all.
- SeanFerree 5y agoVery cool!
- dirkg 5y agoThe US will never have a high speed train, or any mass transit. This country is run by corps and nothing that helps people will get approved. Whatever rail corridors exist are being cut and the big corps are trying to get rich off of the next big thing - EV regulations.