3 ms·
The generic "without directly revealing PII, provide some detail which ML algorithms can use to determine the PII with a high degree of accuracy" is pretty clea
by cratermoon 5y ago
The generic "without directly revealing PII, provide some detail which ML algorithms can use to determine the PII with a high degree of accuracy" is pretty clearly a product of intentional data gathering. The fact that is might get copied and organically spread is just a bonus.
This also goes for "the first letter of your last name plus the date of your mother's birthday are your <pop culture tag>".
Oh and all the cutesy little image processing tools like "what would you look like older/younger/as a different gender/if you were a cartoon" are there to train facial recognition algorithms.
Yet even supposedly sophisticated people fall for these.
- cinntaile 5y agoDo you have any actual proof that this is used for data mining and not because it's an engaging, fun question?
- decremental 5y agoI think this misses the point. Even if what he said has never happened, your mind should be trained to never engage with things like that to begin with. The very first thing that should occur to you is "I'm about to upload a picture of my face on the internet. That's not a good idea. I won't do that." Same with entering personal information.
- _jal 5y agoThere are multiple "the point"s. Yes, teach your kid to be careful with their data. But also, how many outfits are actually doing this, or is this currently a theoretic concern? If people are doing this, what are their goals? Are they meeting them? Are there less obvious examples of the same thing? I'm sure you can keep going with more points.
- decremental 5y agoIf you just don't ever engage then even if the concern is not over a theoretical threat, you'll never have to worry either way. This isn't a "citation needed" kind of issue. "Do you have a source for it not being a good idea to provide personal information to strangers?" Bizarre.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- handoflixue 5y agoWhy should I care, though? "What state are you from" seems like pretty innocuous information. I'll readily mention that I'm from Seattle if it's relevant to the conversation or asked directly, and I tend to think of myself as being on the more paranoid / pro-privacy side of things. All the big players already have my address because I gave it to them, and a stalker should be able to work that information out pretty easily because I post in the Seattle sub-reddit and otherwise engage a lot with Seattle topics.
- edoceo 5y ago> seems like pretty innocuous That's how they get you. It's a trap!
- handoflixue 5y agoYeah, but... what actually IS the trap? What bad thing happens because of this?
- Pokepokalypse 5y agoNOTHING; individually. This is the way statistics work. The threat is an aggregate threat. What happens when 150k people respond to a post.
- AlexAndScripts 5y agoYou'll happily mention it, and a human can find it if they look through your profile. ML will have a much harder time in comparison to going through some comments, all in a similar way, on a post where everyone is saying something about their state.
- handoflixue 5y agoYeah, but... what's bad about that? Why should I be opposed to ML knowing I'm from Seattle?
- 1123581321 5y agoThe most commonly known proof that such tactics are used is that Cambridge Analytica used social quizzes and games to gather data. https://www.politico.eu/article/cambridge-analytica-facebook-data-brittney-kaiser-privacy/ https://www.politico.eu/article/cambridge-analytica-facebook...
- cinntaile 5y agoI would argue that's quite different from when some influencer asks what state you're from without telling what state you're from. Quizzes and games give data in a much easier format compared to this. It's just a trick to engage people and people like to laugh with stereotypes so they happily oblige. Analyzing all this unlabeled text data to find out what state someone is from seems hardly worth the effort, it's not like that's valuable information.
- 1123581321 5y agoThat may be. I’d expect these tactics to evolve, but like most people I’ll only know for sure if it blows up in a big scandal.
- jackson1442 5y agoThey didn't use the quiz to collect the data, no. They used the OAuth permissions granted to them when you connected with Facebook to collect that data.
- 1123581321 5y agoAh, sorry. I didn’t realize that.
- jackson1442 5y agoTaken to any extreme, this could easily be extended to "don't ever engage with anyone or anything for any reason whatsoever." Is there concrete evidence any of this is happening? If not, this just reads like a recipe for paranoia. What we've seen of ML really _isn't that good-_ my phone has full access to anything I've ever typed and its predictive keyboard rarely actually predicts what I'm going to say.
- mandmandam 5y ago> "don't ever engage with anyone or anything for any reason whatsoever." On Facebook. Yeah probably a good idea and not really paranoid considering Fuckerberg's history. > What we've seen of ML really _isn't that good-_ ... Yet. And, after Brexit and Trump we've seen the difference a few percentage points can make. Add another point every couple years as the tech improves and you're mad not to be paranoid.
- Pokepokalypse 5y ago>s there concrete evidence any of this is happening? Cambridge Analytica? Doesn't even matter if there's any truth behind the science. If the personality profiling works, they can apply their MODEL from the 270k responses they DID get, against every single other user's public profile information, and get a high-likelihood result. Does that mean they can tell exactly what MY personality type is? (as much as that may or may not be a valid "thing") - - I doubt it. But can they locate a region on a map where around 180,000 of 200,000 residents fit into a particular personality type, and then target ads to that region with a degree of better accuracy than "random"? Absolutely. Index that against voting records; (which is what the "fake election audits are for" why else do you think they started with Arizona which blew in an unexpected direction for them? Also Kobach's efforts in 2017 were probably actually a data-collection operation for the GOP) - and you have a good map for how to target campaign spending in the next election. I also assume the Census data is abused in this way, (by whichever party is in-power at the time). "dont ever engage with anyone or anything for any reason whatsoever" is fine and dandy. And it's like a Zombie Apocalypse: you can protect yourself from being bitten. But you can't protect yourself from the consequences of everyone else being bitten and turning into zombies and coming after you in such great numbers, that you don't have enough ammunition stockpiled for all the headshots you'll need. (That's my analogy for "people infected with racist (and etc) disinformation are gonna vote a certain way, whether you take in that disinformation or not.")