6 ms·
If they're doing that in class it sounds like a failing of the school itself. They can confiscate phones if they're being distracting or disruptive. Whatever h
by Cthulhu_ 5y ago
If they're doing that in class it sounds like a failing of the school itself. They can confiscate phones if they're being distracting or disruptive.
Whatever happened to rules in class?
- watwut 5y agoI have to agree here. It is no different then any other distraction, toy or whatever in class. If the teacher is unable to get control over those, there is larger issues in there - either with teacher or with the school not empowering teacher.
- sodality2 5y agoIt's far worse than that. You take a toy, they're done for the day. Kids have been known to bring iPods, old phones, etc to sacrifice to teachers. Plus, laptops are mandatory to have in my district (though not mandatory to use), so it takes about five seconds to cheat or get distracted in class.
- tjpnz 5y agoWhen I was going through High School in the early 2000s teachers had a box you had to put your phone into at the beginning of each class. Worked fine then, can't see why it wouldn't now.
- floren 5y agoWhen I've worked in classified environments, they'd have an array of phone-sized lockboxes right outside the classified area. Put your phone in, take the key (which is on a springy lanyard to go around your wrist). I assume high school students would immediately invent The Key Eating Game or something, where you swallow the lockbox key for TikTok clout
- asdff 5y agoWhen I was in highschool about a decade later we figured out we could just hand the teacher some ancient flip phone and keep our actual iphones in our pocket.
- tmp_anon_22 5y agoTeachers have large class sizes and limited ability to give each student individual attention. A student can whip his phone out for the 5 minutes the teacher is on the other side of the room, and even if they do catch phone usage it becomes a liability to physically take and store the device even with the support of administrators.
- Macha 5y agoBack in my day most of us could t9 text without removing the phone from our pocket, so you just needed a few seconds of the phone up your sleeve to read the responses. If anything, the need to physically look at the screen to use it should increase the window for the teacher to detect it?
- anarticle 5y agoIn a case near me, I know a middle school teacher who has to negotiate with students for lectures: "We'll do 20 minutes and then you can do 5 minutes for a phone break." Without this, the classroom cannot be controlled. She says without knowing when the next phone break is makes them very nervous, and very difficult to retain their attention. This is a classroom in a "good school" area, extremely high funding, all kids claim learning disability to get advantages, and parents come down on the teachers. The school bureaucracy is deeply anti-teacher, and allows parents to treat them this way. I definitely agree that it is a failing of the school itself. I have another friend who is a science teacher, but he doesn't have exciting stories like this.
- handrous 5y agoParents freak. The. Fuck. Out. If you touch their kids' phone, these days. You can maybe keep it to the end of the day (and some parents will still complain, "what if I needed to reach them?" Gee, I dunno, maybe call the office, just like all of history since schools got office phones) but past that, phew boy. No. I'm shocked that schools allow phones at all, and that they're not harsher on kids when they find one, but I gather messing with phones is a really good way to have pissed-off parents up your ass, and schools all really hate that, so they give in. Result: constant phone shenanigans.
- MisterTea 5y ago> "what if I needed to reach them?" What parent would call a child in the middle of class, rudely interrupting the entire class? And what would they possibly have to ask their child that so important that warrants interrupting their child's class?
- handrous 5y agoIt has been known to happen. And not for anything actually urgent. Yes, really. And not a one-off, but one of those "oh yeah, time or two a year that happens" sorts of things. Apparently taking kids out of school to get their nails done or whatever is also A Thing for some folks. I'd never have imagined it, but some parents treat school very differently than the parents I (fortunately) had.
- Loughla 5y agoMy spouse has taught for over two decades, I taught for 10 or so years before transitioning to gasp administration. Kids miss school more often today than when we started; our original attendance books prove that, at least for our classrooms. Reasons now range from spa days, to the kid didn't feel like getting up, to, and this is p.e.r.v.a.s.i.v.e., 7-10 day long vacations in September and October. This year, my spouse has not had a full classroom any single day due to family vacations. Pre-covid, it was not better, either. I'm afraid that I come across as a grumpy old man, but this is a problem that did not exist in the past. Education is seen as a burden, and a box to be checked anymore. Take from that sentence whatever you want.
- MisterTea 5y agoNowadays the kids are given laptops to perform their classwork on so there's no point taking the phones away when they have a more capable computer. And it is concerning when you hear stories from teachers about how they spend half of the day telling students to stop playing fortnight or browsing social media in class.
- asdff 5y agoThey should install mirrors in the cieling like CVS has so the clerk can monitor the entire store for shoplifters from the front
- asdff 5y agoGrowing up whenever a teacher thought they were clever and would confiscate phones, kids got even wiser and started bringing in their ancient phones to offer up as a sacrifice, and kept their smartphones hidden in hoodie pockets.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]